Mercone v Monroe County Deputy Sheriffs' Assn., Inc.
2011 NY Slip Op 09752 [90 AD3d 1698]
December 30, 2011
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 1, 2012


Antonio Mercone, Appellant, v Monroe County Deputy Sheriffs'Association, Inc., Respondent.

—[*1]Frank A. Aloi, Rochester, for plaintiff-appellant.

Trevett Cristo Salzer & Andolina, P.C., Rochester (Daniel P. Debolt of counsel), fordefendant-respondent.

Appeal from an order and judgment (one paper) of the Supreme Court, Monroe County(Matthew A. Rosenbaum, J.), entered September 2, 2010. The order and judgment dismissed thecomplaint after a nonjury trial.

It is hereby ordered that the order and judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmedwithout costs.

Memorandum: Plaintiff, a former Monroe County Deputy Sheriff, was discharged from thatposition by letter dated December 15, 2004. Pursuant to paragraph 35.3.1 of the applicablecollective bargaining agreement (CBA) between Monroe County (County), the County Sheriffand defendant, the union representing plaintiff, the parties had 10 business days from the date ofplaintiff's discharge to file a grievance and demand arbitration thereof. Plaintiff testified at trialthat defendant's outgoing president assured him that a grievance had been timely filed on hisbehalf. When a new president assumed the duties of office in February 2005, however, hediscovered that no grievance had been filed. The new president and other union officersattempted to file a grievance with the County or demand arbitration on several occasions, butthey were unsuccessful. Defendant subsequently filed a demand for arbitration with respect toplaintiff's discharge with the Public Employment Relations Board, and Supreme Court (Frazee,J.) granted the petition of the County and the County Sheriff seeking to stay arbitration. Plaintiffcommenced this action on or about August 9, 2005 seeking to recover damages for defendant'sbreach of the duty of fair representation. Plaintiff appeals from an order and judgment dismissingthe complaint.

We reject the contention of plaintiff that Supreme Court (Rosenbaum, J.) erred indetermining that the action was time-barred. An action against a union for breach of its duty offair representation "shall be commenced within four months of the date the . . .former employee knew or should have known that the breach has occurred, or within four monthsof the date the . . . former employee suffers actual harm, whichever is later" (CPLR217 [2] [a]). Here, "the harm complained of . . . occurred when defendant allegedlybreached its duty of fair representation by refusing to file the grievance" within the time limitsimposed by the CBA (Leblanc v Security Servs. Unit Empls. of N.Y. State Law EnforcementOfficers Union, Council 82, AFSCME, [*2]AFL-CIO, 278AD2d 732, 733 [2000]). Thus, plaintiff suffered actual harm when defendant failed to file thegrievance on or before December 30, 2004, which is 10 business days after he was discharged.

We reject plaintiff's further contention that the court erred in determining that he knew, orhad reason to know, of defendant's failure to file a grievance more than four months prior to thecommencement of the action. Plaintiff testified at trial that he did not learn of defendant's failureto file a grievance until a later date, but the court did not credit that testimony. It is well settledthat, although this Court's authority in reviewing a nonjury trial is the same as that of the trialcourt, "[w]here the findings of fact 'rest in large measure on considerations relating to thecredibility of witnesses' . . . , deference is owed to the trial court's credibilitydeterminations" (Sterling Inv. Servs.,Inc. v 1155 NOBO Assoc., LLC, 65 AD3d 1128, 1129 [2009], lv denied 13NY3d 714 [2009]; see Storico Dev.,LLC v Batlle, 9 AD3d 908, 909 [2004]; Ring v State of New York, 8 AD3d 1057 [2004], lv denied3 NY3d 608 [2004]). Here, there is ample support in the record for the court's credibilitydeterminations, and we see no basis upon which to disturb them.

Contrary to plaintiff's contention, the statute of limitations was not tolled by the continuousrepresentation doctrine. That doctrine, "although originally derived from the continuoustreatment concept in medical malpractice cases, has also been held applicable to professionalsother than physicians" (Zaref v Berk & Michaels, 192 AD2d 346, 347 [1993]). Forstatute of limitations purposes, the Court of Appeals has defined professionals as those whoseemployment qualifications "include extensive formal learning and training, licensure andregulation indicating a qualification to practice, a code of conduct imposing standards beyondthose accepted in the marketplace and a system of discipline for violation of those standards. . . Additionally, a professional relationship is one of trust and confidence, carryingwith it a duty to counsel and advise clients" (Chase Scientific Research v NIA Group, 96NY2d 20, 29 [2001]). Even assuming, arguendo, that the relationship between plaintiff anddefendant is one of trust and confidence with a duty to counsel and advise, we conclude that therecord fails to establish that defendant's representatives held any of the other employmentqualifications, and thus we decline to expand the continuous representation doctrine to includeunion representatives (see generally Pikev New York Life Ins. Co., 72 AD3d 1043, 1048 [2010]; Eastman Kodak Co. vPrometheus Funding Corp., 283 AD2d 216 [2001]). We have considered plaintiff's furthercontentions with respect to the statute of limitations and conclude that they are without merit.

Plaintiff's remaining contentions are academic in light of our determination.Present—Smith, J.P., Fahey, Peradotto, Carni and Sconiers, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.