| Konrad v Brown |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 00415 [91 AD3d 545] |
| Jnury 24, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Evelyn Konrad, Appellant, v William Brown,Respondent. |
—[*1] Scarola Malone & Zubatov LLP, New York (Daniel C. Malone of counsel), forrespondent.
Judgment, Supreme Court, New York County (Carol R. Edmead, J.), entered September 30,2010, dismissing the amended complaint, unanimously affirmed, with costs. Appeal from order,same court and Justice, entered September 14, 2010, which granted defendant's motion forsummary judgment pursuant to CPLR 3211 (c), unanimously dismissed, without costs, assubsumed in the appeal from the judgment. Order, same court and Justice, entered on or aboutFebruary 18, 2011, which granted plaintiff's motion to renew and adhered to the priordetermination, unanimously affirmed, with costs. Appeal from order, same court and Justice,entered on or about April 25, 2011, which denied plaintiff's motion for leave to amend theamended complaint, unanimously dismissed, without costs, as abandoned.
The motion court correctly found that defendant's allegedly defamatory statements in hisletter to the editor were either not susceptible to a defamatory meaning, true or substantially trueor pure opinion. The assertion that plaintiff had made a false statement before an administrativetribunal was substantially true, as shown by the video and transcript of the hearing; this was acomplete defense (see Panghat v NewYork Downtown Hosp., 85 AD3d 473 [2011]). Considered as a whole, in context andbased on its tone and apparent purpose (see Sandals Resorts Intl. Ltd. v Google, Inc., 86 AD3d 32, 42[2011]) as well as the lack of any implication that it was based on undisclosed facts in light ofdefendant's reference to the videotape and transcript (see Steinhilber v Alphonse, 68NY2d 283, 289 [1986]; Guerrero vCarva, 10 AD3d 105, 112 [2004]), it was also pure opinion. Defendant's assertion thatplaintiff had made a false statement in a CPLR article 78 proceeding was both substantially trueand his opinion of the news article reporting such conduct. The assertion that plaintiff, anattorney, had been discharged by a client, was true, as supported by the transcript of plaintiff'squantum meruit fee request wherein she stated that she had been discharged, and, in any event,was not susceptible of a defamatory meaning because defendant did not mention any reason forthe discharge.
The court's alternative ground for dismissal, that plaintiff failed to show malice, was alsoappropriate, as plaintiff was a limited public figure (see Huggins v Moore, 94 NY2d 296,301-302 [1999]) and defendant's statements were based on documents or articles he had read andthus were not made with knowledge of their falsity or reckless disregard of whether or not theywere true (see Kipper v NYP HoldingsCo., Inc., 12 NY3d 348, 353-354 [2009]). Nor did [*2]plaintiff show that defendant's statements were actuated by ill will(see id. at 354 n 4), her conclusory assertions to that effect notwithstanding.
Although the court correctly determined that plaintiff failed to justify her failure to submither purported new evidence in opposition to defendant's motion, and that such evidence wouldnot have warranted a different outcome, the court granted renewal and adhered to its initialdetermination. Accordingly, we need not disturb that result.
We have considered plaintiff's other contentions and find them unavailing.Concur—Tom, J.P., Friedman, DeGrasse, Richter and Manzanet-Daniels, JJ.