| Matter of Green v Bradt |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 00441 [91 AD3d 1235] |
| Jnury 26, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Shawn Green, Petitioner, v Mark L. Bradt, asSuperintendent of Elmira Correctional Facility, Respondent. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Laura Etlinger of counsel), forrespondent.
Rose, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Chemung County) to review (1) a determination of the Central OfficeReview Committee denying petitioner's grievance, and (2) a determination of respondent whichfound petitioner guilty of violating a prison disciplinary rule.
In December 2009, petitioner, a prison inmate, filed a grievance seeking to, among otherthings, modify restrictions on the items of clothing that inmates are permitted to wear whilebeing transported to other facilities during cold weather months. Specifically, while the relevantdirectives permit the wearing of a winter coat where appropriate, petitioner sought revision of thepolicy to permit inmates to bring and wear "a sweater, winter socks, hat as well as [thermalunderwear]." Ultimately, in April 2010, the Central Office Review Committee (hereinafterCORC) denied petitioner's grievance, ruling that petitioner failed to present "any compellingreasons to revise departmental policy regarding clothing."
In a misbehavior report dated April 8, 2010, petitioner was charged with failing to dispose ofa plastic spoon upon departure from the mess hall, refusing a direct order and creating adisturbance. These charges stemmed from an incident whereby a correction officer observed[*2]that petitioner failed to drop his spoon into the bucket setaside for that purpose after his meal, causing him to order petitioner to comply. According to themisbehavior report, petitioner "became vocally loud [and] argument[ative] and proceeded to exitthe mess hall into [a] corridor." Petitioner was then frisked and, when no contraband was found,he was escorted back to his cell. Following a tier II disciplinary hearing, petitioner was foundguilty of creating a disturbance. The determination of guilt was affirmed on administrativeappeal.
Petitioner subsequently commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding challenging CORC'sdetermination denying the grievance, as well as respondent's determination finding him guilty ofcreating a disturbance. Thereafter, petitioner served upon the Attorney General an"amended/supplemental verified petition," which used the same index number as the aboveproceeding and sought to add entirely new causes of action challenging the results of twounrelated disciplinary hearings held after the events described in the original verified petition.Supreme Court denied that request, and transferred the proceeding to this Court pursuant toCPLR 7804 (g).
Initially, we are unpersuaded by petitioner's contention that the denial of his grievance mustbe overturned. It is beyond dispute that, "[t]o prevail, petitioner must demonstrate that [CORC's]determination was arbitrary and capricious or without a rational basis" (Matter of Simmons v New York StateDept. of Correctional Servs., 82 AD3d 1382, 1383 [2011] [internal quotation marks andcitation omitted]). Here, the grievance determination, as well as our in camera review of therelevant directives, confirms that the denial of petitioner's grievance was rationally based uponlegitimate security and identification concerns and limitations on storage. Winter coats areallowed when appropriate, and respondent further noted that inmates may wear additionalclothing during transport based upon documented medical needs. Under these circumstances, wefind no basis to disturb CORC's denial of petitioner's grievance.
Turning to the determination finding petitioner guilty of creating a disturbance, themisbehavior report standing alone was sufficient to provide substantial evidence to support thatfinding (see People ex rel. Vega v Smith, 66 NY2d 130, 140 [1985]; Matter of Rizzuto v Murphy, 3 AD3d801, 802 [2004]; Matter of Daum v Goord, 274 AD2d 715, 716 [2000]). Whilepetitioner claims that the record does not support the Hearing Officer's finding that the incidentoccurred in front of other inmates, we note that the misbehavior report specifically charges that aloud exchange took place in the mess hall. As for petitioner's assertion that he was, among otherthings, improperly restricted from calling a witness, the record discloses that petitioner respondedin the negative at the end of the hearing when he was asked whether he chose to call anywitnesses or had any procedural objections. Accordingly, any issues in that regard were waived(see Matter of Cornwall v Fischer,74 AD3d 1507, 1509 [2010]).
The remaining issues raised by petitioner have been examined and found to be lacking inmerit, including his claim that Supreme Court erred in denying his request to serve an"amended/supplemental verified petition" seeking to add challenges to unrelated disciplinaryproceedings. We find no abuse of the court's discretion in that regard, inasmuch as "the newcauses of action asserted impermissibly expand[ed] the scope of the original proceeding" (Matter of Miller v Goord, 1 AD3d647, 648 [2003]).
Mercure, A.P.J., Peters, Lahtinen and Garry, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determinationsare confirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.