Briody v Melecio
2012 NY Slip Op 00601 [91 AD3d 1328]
January 31, 2012
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 29, 2012


Barbara Briody, Respondent,
v
Christen L. Melecio, Appellant.

[*1]Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Monroe County (Matthew A. Rosenbaum, J.),entered April 5, 2011 in a personal injury action. The order, insofar as appealed from, denied inpart the motion of defendant for summary judgment.

It is hereby ordered that the order insofar as appealed from is unanimously reversed onthe law without costs, the motion is granted in its entirety and the complaint is dismissed.

Memorandum: Plaintiff commenced this action seeking damages for injuries shesustained when the vehicle she was driving was rear-ended by a vehicle driven by defendant. Weconclude that Supreme Court erred in denying in part defendant's motion seeking summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint on the ground that plaintiff did not sustain a serious injurywithin the meaning of Insurance Law 5102 (d). Defendant met her initial burden of establishingthat plaintiff did not sustain a serious injury under the permanent consequential limitation of useand significant limitation of use categories, and plaintiff failed to raise a triable issue of fact inopposition (see generally Zuckerman v City of New York, 49 NY2d 557, 562 [1980]). Wetherefore reverse the order insofar as appealed from, grant defendant's motion in its entirety anddismiss the complaint.

Contrary to plaintiff's contention, defendant may establish her entitlement to judgment asa matter of law by submitting the medical records provided by counsel for plaintiff (see Wiegandv Schunck, 294 AD2d 839 [2002]). In support of her motion, defendant also submitted theaffidavit of an orthopedic surgeon who reviewed plaintiff's medical records at the request ofdefendant. That expert concluded that the only objective medical findings with respect to anyalleged injury related to a preexisting degenerative condition of the spine. "[W]ith persuasiveevidence that plaintiff's alleged pain and injuries were related to a preexisting condition, plaintiffhad the burden to come forward with evidence addressing defendant's claimed lack of causation"and, here, plaintiff failed to meet that burden (Carrasco v Mendez, 4 NY3d 566, 580 [2005]; seeHartman-Jweid v Overbaugh, 70 AD3d 1399, 1400 [2010]). [*2]Although plaintiff submitted theaffirmation of her treating neurosurgeon in opposition to the motion, his affirmation did notaddress the conclusion of defendant's expert that the changes in the spine of plaintiff weredegenerative in nature (see Marsh v City of New York, 61 AD3d 552 [2009]; Valentin v Pomilla,59 AD3d 184, 186 [2009]). Plaintiff's expert asserted that a central disc protrusion in the cervicalspine at C5-6 and C6-C7 was a "new" injury resulting from the motor vehicle accident inquestion. Defendant's expert, however, established that such injury was revealed on a CT scantaken of plaintiff's cervical spine several years prior to the accident, after plaintiff had fallendown a flight of stairs and fractured a cervical vertebrae at C6. The affirmation of plaintiff'sexpert did not discuss that CT scan but, rather, it compared plaintiff's condition following thesubject accident to an MRI report dated the year prior to the CT scan. In addition, the reports ofan orthopedic surgeon submitted by plaintiff failed to address defendant's evidence of apreexisting degenerative condition and the results of the CT scan. We therefore conclude thatplaintiff's "submissions in opposition to the motion did not 'adequately address how [her] currentmedical problems, in light of [her] past medical history, are causally related to the subjectaccident' " (Anania v Verdgeline, 45 AD3d 1473, 1474 [2007]; see D'Angelo v Litterer, 87 AD3d1357 [2011]).

In light of our determination, we need not address defendant's remaining contentions.Present Smith, J.P., Fahey, Carni, Sconiers and Gorski, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.