| Matter of Eighth Jud. Dist. Asbestos Litig. |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 01048 [92 AD3d 1259] |
| February 10, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| In the Matter of Eighth Judicial District Asbestos Litigation.Stephen Drabczyk, as Executor of Ronald Drabczyk, Deceased, Respondent, v FisherControls International, LLC, Appellant. |
—[*1]Belluck & Fox, LLP, New York City (Seth A. Dymond of counsel) and Joyce & JoyceAssociates, Barnstable, Massachusetts, for plaintiff-respondent.
Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Erie County (John P. Lane, J.H.O.), enteredSeptember 17, 2010. The judgment awarded plaintiff money damages upon a jury verdict.
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously modified on the lawby vacating the award of punitive damages and as modified the judgment is affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Defendant appeals from a judgment awarding plaintiff compensatory andpunitive damages in this wrongful death action based upon the exposure of plaintiff's decedent toasbestos contained in valves produced by defendant. The evidence presented at trial establishedthat, in the course of his employment from 1970 until 1996, decedent repaired and refurbishedvalves produced by defendant. Approximately one half of the valves that defendant sold todecendent's employer contained asbestos. The evidence further established that decedent wasexposed to asbestos from other sources, both in his work environment beginning in 1965 and inprior employment in the 1950s and 1960s. The jury apportioned 5% of the liability for damagesfor decedent's pain and suffering to defendant. Following the verdict on liability, the jurydetermined that defendant acted with reckless disregard for decedent's safety and thus thatdefendant's liability was not limited to 5% of the verdict (see CPLR 1601 [1]; 1602 [7]).The jury thereafter awarded plaintiff punitive damages.
Although we agree with defendant that Supreme Court erred in charging the jury thatdefendant could be liable for decedent's exposure to asbestos contained in products used inconjunction with defendant's valves (see generally Rastelli v Goodyear Tire & RubberCo., 79 [*2]NY2d 289, 297-298 [1992]), we neverthelessconclude that the error is harmless.
We reject defendant's contention that there is no valid line of reasoning and permissibleinferences that could lead a rational jury to conclude that defendant acted with reckless disregardfor decedent's safety by failing to warn him of the dangers associated with the use of its productscontaining asbestos (see generally Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig., 89 NY2d955, 956 [1997], affg 225 AD2d 414 [1996]; Cohen v Hallmark Cards, 45 NY2d493, 499 [1978]). We recognize that the Court of Appeals declined to determine whether thereckless disregard standard or a higher standard applies to the issue of punitive damages (seeNew York City Asbestos Litig., 89 NY2d at 957). We therefore conclude that, because thejury found that defendant acted with reckless disregard for decedent's safety, the court did notabuse its discretion by charging the jury on the issue of punitive damages.
Although the determination whether to award punitive damages and in what amount thosedamages should be awarded generally rests within the sound discretion of the trier of fact, thisCourt may nevertheless exercise its own discretion in reviewing the determination (seeNardelli v Stamberg, 44 NY2d 500, 503-504 [1978]). We conclude that the evidence doesnot establish "this to be one of the 'singularly rare cases' where punitive damages are warranted"(New York City Asbestos Litig., 225 AD2d at 415). Plaintiff's expert testified that heused transmission electronic microscopy to establish that the level of asbestos to which decedentmay have been exposed from defendant's products exceeded the Occupational Safety and HealthAdministration (OSHA) standards established in 1976 and revised in 1986. That technology,however, was not available in the 1970s and 1980s. The measurements taken by plaintiff's expertusing contrast microscopy were well below the OSHA standards of 1986. We therefore concludethat plaintiff failed to establish that defendant " 'engaged in outrageous or oppressive intentionalmisconduct or [acted] with reckless or wanton disregard of [the] safety or rights' " of decedent(Ross v Louise Wise Servs., Inc., 8NY3d 478, 489 [2007]). We therefore modify the judgment by vacating the award ofpunitive damages.
In light of our determination, we do not address defendant's remaining contentionsconcerning the award of punitive damages. Present—Scudder, P.J., Centra, Fahey, Carniand Sconiers, JJ.