Solomons v Douglas Elliman LLC
2012 NY Slip Op 02577 [94 AD3d 468]
April 5, 2012
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, May 23, 2012


Paul Solomons, Respondent,
v
Douglas Elliman LLC,Doing Business as Prudential Douglas Elliman, et al., Defendants, and Old BrownsvilleRenaissance Corp., Appellant.

—[*1]Gleich, Siegel & Farkas, Great Neck (Lawrence W. Farkas of counsel), for appellant.

Giskan Solotaroff Anderson & Stewart LLP, New York (Amanda Masters of counsel), forrespondent.

Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Judith J. Gische, J.), entered December 13, 2010,which denied the motion by defendant Old Brownsville Renaissance Corp. (OBRC) to dismissplaintiff's complaint as against it, unanimously affirmed, without costs.

Plaintiff, who is disabled and receives Section 8 housing assistance, alleged in the firstamended complaint that OBRC and other property owners and real estate brokers violated theNew York City Human Rights Law by refusing to rent apartments to him (seeAdministrative Code of the City of New York § 8-107 [5]). The first amendedcomplaint further alleged that the apartment plaintiff allegedly tried to rent from OBRC was in abuilding containing six or more housing units, and accordingly the exemption for buildings withfive or fewer apartments did not apply (see Administrative Code § 8-107 [5] [a][1]; [o]).

OBRC moved for dismissal on the ground that the subject building only contained fourapartments. In support, OBRC submitted the affidavit of its president, Tessie Travin, and a copyof the October 1990 certificate of occupancy for the building.

However, in his opposition papers, plaintiff raised a new theory of liability—namely,that the number of units in the subject building was not dispositive because another provision ofthe Human Rights Law provides that it applies to "any person who has the right to sell, rent orlease or approve the sale, rental or lease" of at least one housing accommodation in New YorkCity with six or more units (Administrative Code § 8-107 [5] [o] [ii]). Plaintiff alleged thatTravin owned another apartment building in New York City with six units and a third buildingwith 12 units. The motion court agreed with plaintiff and denied OBRC's dismissal motion on theground that "the [number] of apartments [in the subject building] is really irrelevant" because thestatute "still applies to an owner [that] has at least one housing accommodation with 6 or moreunits."

OBRC contends that it was improper for plaintiff to raise a new theory of liability in his[*2]opposition papers. It also points out that plaintiff did notname Travin as a defendant in this case, that plaintiff submitted evidence in the opposition papersindicating that other corporations, instead of Travin, own the two buildings with six or moreunits, and that plaintiff did not link OBRC or Travin with the other corporate owners.

OBRC's dismissal motion was properly denied because, at this stage, neither Travin'saffidavit nor the certificate of occupancy is sufficient to rebut plaintiff's claim that the subjectbuilding contains at least six units. A motion to dismiss under CPLR 3211, when based ondocumentary evidence, is granted only if that evidence "utterly refutes plaintiff's factualallegations, conclusively establishing a defense as a matter of law" (Goshen v Mutual LifeIns. Co. of N.Y., 98 NY2d 314, 326 [2002]). The affidavit of Travin, "which do[es] no morethan assert the inaccuracy of plaintiff['s] allegations, may not be considered, in the context of amotion to dismiss, for the purpose of determining whether there is evidentiary support for thecomplaint" (Tsimerman v Janoff, 40AD3d 242 [2007]). In addition, the 22-year-old certificate of occupancy does notconclusively prove how many apartments were in the building when plaintiff tried to rent in it.

We also note that an addition to the record indicates that, after this appeal was filed, themotion court granted plaintiff leave to amend the complaint to add Travin as a defendant andassert direct claims against her; thus, this appeal may be premature.

We have examined OBRC's additional claims and find them without merit.Concur—Andrias, J.P., Saxe, Acosta, Freedman and Richter, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.