| Matter of Riverso v Rockland County Solid Waste Mgt. Auth. |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 04347 [96 AD3d 764] |
| June 6, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Raphael Riverso, Petitioner, v RocklandCounty Solid Waste Management Authority, Respondent. |
—[*1] Pannone Lopes Devereaux & West LLC, White Plains, N.Y. (Thomas R. Gonnella andKimberlea Shaw Rea of counsel), for respondent.
Proceeding pursuant to EDPL 207 to review a determination of the Rockland County SolidWaste Management Authority dated May 26, 2011, made after a public hearing, authorizing thecondemnation of certain real property.
Adjudged that the petition is granted, on the law, with costs, the determination is rejected,and the matter is remitted to the Rockland County Solid Waste Management Authority toconduct an appropriate environmental review pursuant to the State Environmental QualityReview Act (ECL art 8) in accordance herewith.
The Clarkstown Solid Waste Management Facilities (hereinafter the Clarkstown Facility)comprise, among other things, a concrete/asphalt crushing operation, a wood mulching operation,and a leaf composting operation. The western portion of the Clarkstown Facility is also the site ofthe former Clarkstown Sanitary Landfill (hereinafter the landfill). The landfill operations hadencroached onto approximately 1.5 acres of a 7-acre parcel of real property owned by thepetitioner Raphael Riverso, situated immediately to the north of the landfill. In 1989 the Town ofClarkstown and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (hereinafter theDEC) entered into an Order on Consent, which declared the area to be environmentallyhazardous, and required the Town to address the situation in accordance with a remediation planwhich was to be approved and supervised by the DEC. In 1995 a remediation plan approved bythe DEC required, inter alia, that the Town cap the landfill, along with the 1.5-acre portion ofRiverso's property (hereinafter the property). Although the 1995 DEC plan obligated the Town toobtain authorizations, easements, or rights-of-entry that were necessary to carry out suchremediation, the Town did not obtain access to the property, and neither the property nor theadjacent portion of the landfill was ever remediated.
After the Rockland County Solid Waste Management Authority (hereinafter the Authority)purchased the Clarkstown Facility from the Town in 2009, the Authority attemptedunsuccessfully to purchase the property from Riverso in order to expand and reconfigure itsoperations, and to provide the Town with access to the landfill portion for remediation.Eventually, the Authority initiated procedures to condemn the property and, after a publichearing, the Authority [*2]issued a determination authorizingsuch condemnation. As part of the condemnation process, the Authority also issued a negativedeclaration pursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8; hereinafterSEQRA), finding that the acquisition would not have a significant adverse impact on theenvironment, and that, accordingly, a draft environmental impact statement need not be prepared.Thereafter, Riverso commenced the instant proceeding pursuant to EDPL 207 to review thatdetermination.
The petitioner correctly contends that the Authority failed to comply with SEQRA inconnection with the proposed condemnation and proposed land acquisition. "No agency involvedin an action may undertake, fund or approve the action until it has complied with the provisionsof SEQR[A]" (6 NYCRR 617.3 [a]). A proceeding to acquire property through condemnation isan action under the EDPL which triggers environmental review under SEQRA (see Matter of Gyrodyne Co. of Am., Inc. vState Univ. of N.Y. at Stony Brook, 17 AD3d 675 [2005]). Strict compliance withSEQRA is required (see Matter of New York City Coalition to End Lead Poisoning vVallone, 100 NY2d 337, 347-348 [2003]).
The record reveals that the Authority did not properly "identif[y] the relevant areas ofenvironmental concern" and, thus, did not take a "hard look" at them (Matter of ChemicalSpecialties Mfrs. Assn. v Jorling, 85 NY2d 382, 397 [1995]). Specifically, the Authority'sfindings do not address the environmental concerns pertaining to the land outside of the 1.5-acreproperty immediately adjacent to the landfill. Additionally, the Authority, as part of its review,did not conduct an investigation into the effects of the condemnation and acquisition upon thegroundwater on the remainder of Riverso's land, since that step had already been taken inconnection with the 1989 Order on Consent. However, the passage of more than 10 years sincethat investigation has been conducted necessitates further review under SEQRA to ensure that nonew environmental concerns exist (see 6 NYCRR 617.9 [a] [7] [i]; Matter ofDoremus v Town of Oyster Bay, 274 AD2d 390 [2000]).
The petitioner also correctly contends that, under the circumstances presented here, theAuthority improperly segmented its SEQRA review process both by time and by geography(see 6 NYCRR 617.2 [ag]; 617.3 [g] [1]; Matter of Long Is. Pine Barrens Socy. vPlanning Bd. of Town of Brookhaven, 80 NY2d 500, 513 [1992]; Matter of Village ofTarrytown v Planning Bd. of Vil. of Sleepy Hollow, 292 AD2d 617, 620-621 [2002]).Contrary to the Authority's contention, the fact that it had no "concrete" plans for the expansionof its operations on the property did not relieve it of the requirement to conduct an environmentalreview of the entirety of Riverso's land. Indeed, deferring such review would result in the verysegmentation of environmental review which is disfavored under SEQRA (see Matter of Savethe Pine Bush v City of Albany, 70 NY2d 193, 200 [1987]; Matter of Concerned Citizensfor Envt. v Zagata, 243 AD2d 20, 22 [1998]; Matter of Farrington Close CondominiumBd. of Mgrs. v Incorporated Vil. of Southampton, 205 AD2d 623, 626 [1994]; Matter ofLong Is. Pine Barrens Socy. v Planning Bd. of Town of Brookhaven, 204 AD2d 548,550-551 [1994]).
Accordingly, since there was a failure to properly comply with SEQRA, the determinationand findings must be rejected, and the matter remitted to the Authority to undertake theappropriate review (see Matter of Munash v Town Bd. of Town of E. Hampton, 297AD2d 345 [2002]).
In light of our conclusion herein, we do not reach any of the parties' remaining contentions.Skelos, J.P., Dickerson, Eng and Sgroi, JJ., concur.