| Matter of Druyan v Village Bd. of Trustees of the Vil. of CayugaHgts. |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 04808 [96 AD3d 1207] |
| June 14, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Ann Druyan et al., Appellants, v Village Board ofTrustees of The Village of Cayuga Heights, Respondent. |
—[*1] Williams, Clune & Stevens, Ithaca (John Alden Stevens of counsel), forrespondent.
Lahtinen, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Rumsey, J.), entered September16, 2011 in Tompkins County, which, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, dismissed thepetition.
Petitioners seek to annul the plan approved by respondent to reduce the deer population inthe Village of Cayuga Heights, Tompkins County. The Village is 1.85 square miles in size, withabout 3,200 residents and had an estimated deer population of 160 to 200. For a decade or more,there had been various concerns expressed about problems related to the growing deerpopulation, including increased damage to vegetation and gardens, collisions with vehicles andpotential for Lyme disease. In 2008, the Village commissioned a deer remediation advisorycommittee (hereinafter DRAC) to study the problem and propose a course of action. The DRACissued a report in June 2009 recommending, among other things, attempting to reduce the deerherd size to about 60 by a three-phase approach using sterilization, followed by culling, and thenongoing monitoring and maintenance using both sterilization and culling.
Respondent declared that it would act as lead agency pursuant to the State EnvironmentalQuality Review Act (see ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]), issued a positive declarationand prepared a detailed draft environment impact statement (hereinafter DEIS). The [*2]DEIS, although more specific than the DRAC report, proposed asimilar phased options approach, except that it recommended a target deer population of 30rather than 60. A public hearing was held in December 2010 and written comments werereceived following the hearing. Respondent produced a final environment impact statement(hereinafter FEIS), which responded to the numerous public comments. In April 2011,respondent issued SEQRA findings and approved the phased deer remediation plan.
Petitioners commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seeking to, among other things,annul respondent's deer remediation plan. Supreme Court granted the parties' request to treatrespondent's subsequent motion to dismiss as one for summary judgment and, in a thoroughwritten decision, granted the motion and dismissed the petition (Matter of Druyan v VillageBd. of Trustees of the Vil. of Cayuga Hgts., 33 Misc 3d 1203[A], 2011 NY Slip Op51772[U] [2011]). Petitioners appeal.
We affirm. "Judicial review of an agency determination under SEQRA is limited to 'whetherthe agency identified the relevant areas of environmental concern, took a "hard look" at them,and made a "reasoned elaboration" of the basis for its determination' " (Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd.of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d 219, 231-232 [2007], quoting Matter of Jackson vNew York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986]; accord Matter of Shop-Rite Supermarkets,Inc. v Planning Bd. of the Town of Wawarsing, 82 AD3d 1384, 1385 [2011], lvdenied 17 NY3d 705 [2011]). "An agency complying with SEQRA need not investigateevery conceivable environmental problem; it may, within reasonable limits, use its discretion inselecting which ones are relevant" (Matter of Save the Pine Bush, Inc. v Common Council of City ofAlbany, 13 NY3d 297, 307 [2009] [citation omitted]). "It is not the province of thecourts to second-guess thoughtful agency decisionmaking and, accordingly, an agency decisionshould be annulled only if it is arbitrary, capricious or unsupported by the evidence" (Matterof Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d at 232).
Petitioners' arguments include that respondent failed to gather critical information such ascurrent deer population, the rate of migration of new deer into the Village and the extent ofdamage to landscape caused by the deer population. The DEIS estimate of the deer populationwas supported by a study conducted by a Cornell University professor in 2006, together withprojected growth rate since that study. Respondent addressed in its FEIS public commentsregarding migrating deer, which would be monitored with current technology as well as newtechnology that might become available. With respect to vegetation, the DEIS noted that thecurrent deer population would consume 500 to 1,200 pounds of vegetation daily resulting in anoticeable impact on the landscape.
We are unpersuaded by petitioners' contention that respondent failed to provide sufficientdata for informed public comment and failed to take a hard look at important adverse impacts ofthe plan. The DEIS was detailed in describing the problem, the proposed solution, the potentialimpacts, and the alternative approaches. Moreover, the DEIS was similar in its recommendationsto the DRAC report, which had been issued and made public over a year before the DEIS wasissued. There was ample information and sufficient time to comment, as reflected by over 60comments received. The comments were sufficiently addressed in the FEIS. The issues ofhumane treatment of the deer problem as well as asserted potential impact on human health wereadequately considered.
The remaining issues have been considered and are unavailing.[*3]
Peters, P.J., Spain, Kavanagh and McCarthy, JJ., concur.Ordered that the judgment is affirmed, without costs. [Prior Case History: 33 Misc 3d1203(A), 2011 NY Slip Op 51772(U).]