Matter of Swartz v New York State Dept. of Health
2012 NY Slip Op 04809 [96 AD3d 1209]
June 14, 2012
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 1, 2012


In the Matter of Sharon Swartz, Also Known as Sharon Townsend,Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Kenneth Swartz, Deceased,Petitioner,
v
New York State Department of Health et al.,Respondents.

—[*1]Eric A. Bare, Vestal, for petitioner.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Victor Paladino of counsel), forrespondents.

Malone Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order ofthe Supreme Court, entered in Broome County) to review a determination of respondentDepartment of Health which denied Kenneth Swartz's request for Medicaid assistance.

In October 2006, petitioner moved into her parents' home to care for them and, on November6, 2006, she, her father (hereinafter decedent) and her mother signed a "Personal Services-CareAgreement," pursuant to which petitioner was to act as a personal care aide,homemaker/housekeeper and a companion for her parents on a 24-hour basis. The contractrequired petitioner to maintain contemporaneous records of the dates and nature of all of theservices that she provided and, in exchange for those services, petitioner was to be paid on anhourly basis at a rate of $17, $16.50 or $15.50, depending on the type of service provided. [*2]Petitioner provided services to her parents until decedent entered anursing home in April 2007.[FN1]Because petitioner had never received any pay pursuant to the contract, when decedent's housewas sold in February 2008, she received $51,940.50 out of the profits of the sale, representing theamount she claimed was owed to her under the contract.

Meanwhile, decedent had applied for Medicaid assistance upon his admission to the nursinghome facility. His application was denied by the Broome County Department of Social Services(hereinafter the agency) on the basis that his eligibility was subject to a penalty period of 5.8months due to certain transfers of assets, including the transfer to petitioner after the sale of hishouse, which had been made during the applicable "look-back" period. Specifically, the agencydetermined that, although $51,940.50 had been transferred to petitioner, the fair market value ofthe services that she provided—and for which she could provide detailed contemporaneousdocumentation—was $15,883.76, leaving a disqualifying transfer amount of $36,056.74.Decedent requested a hearing, following which respondent Department of Health (hereinafterrespondent) upheld the agency's determination. Petitioner thereafter commenced this proceedingchallenging respondent's determination, which was transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court.[FN2]

Petitioner bears the burden of establishing eligibility for Medicaid benefits and respondent'sdetermination in that regard will not be disturbed so long as it is supported by substantialevidence in the record (see Matter ofBarbato v New York State Dept. of Health, 65 AD3d 821, 823 [2009], lv denied13 NY3d 712 [2009]; Matter of Rogersv Novello, 26 AD3d 580, 581 [2006]). It is well settled that certain transfers of assetsfor less than fair market value during the applicable look-back period renders an applicantineligible for nursing facility benefits (see Social Services Law § 366 [5];Matter of Rogers v Novello, 26 AD3d at 581).

In this case, substantial evidence supports respondent's determination that decedenttransferred more than $36,000 in assets to petitioner for less than fair market value and was,therefore, ineligible for benefits for a period of 5.8 months. Although petitioner contends thatrespondent improperly disallowed credit for services that she rendered during nighttime hours,the record contains no detailed contemporaneously-prepared records documenting the servicesthat she allegedly provided each night of the week between the hours of 10:45 p.m. and 6:00 a.m.Instead, petitioner maintained a general care plan that did not contain any specific informationregarding the services that were allegedly provided during that time period each night.Accordingly, respondent's determination to disallow those hours in its calculation of the fairmarket value of the services that petitioner provided is supported by substantial evidence in therecord.

With respect to the hours of service for which respondent credited petitioner, substantial[*3]evidence supports respondent's determination to disallowpetitioner's claimed hourly rate of $15.50, which she alleged was the rate a local home healthcareagency would have charged for those services in 2009. According to the testimony of anexaminer from the agency and statistics compiled by the US Department of Labor, the meanhourly wage rate for a personal home healthcare aide in this state was $9.22. This conflictingevidence regarding the appropriate wage rate to be applied presented a credibility determinationfor respondent to resolve, and we perceive no basis upon which to disturb its decision to applythe lower rate of pay (see generallyMatter of Community Related Servs., Inc. v Carpenter-Palumbo, 84 AD3d 1450, 1455[2011], lv denied 17 NY3d 717 [2011]).

To the extent not specifically addressed, petitioner's remaining contentions have beenconsidered and found to be without merit.

Rose, J.P., Stein, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: Apparently, petitioner's motherdied sometime before April 2007.

Footnote 2: Petitioner commenced theproceeding individually and as power of attorney for decedent. After decedent died during thependency of this proceeding, Supreme Court "substituted" (see generally CPLR 1015,1021) petitioner in her fiduciary capacity as administrator of decedent's estate.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.