| Matter of Jackson (County of Nassau Civ. Serv.Commn.—Commissioner of Labor) |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 05372 [97 AD3d 889] |
| July 5, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Paula R. Jackson, Respondent. Countyof Nassau Civil Service Commission, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. |
—[*1] James W. Cooper, Warrensburg, for Paula R. Jackson, respondent.
Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filed March 11,2011, which ruled that claimant was entitled to receive unemployment insurance benefits.
Claimant worked as a correction officer at the Nassau County Correctional Facility forapproximately 11 years. In 2008, she began a personal relationship with a man who was laterincarcerated at that facility. Claimant continued to have a personal relationship with thisindividual following his incarceration and communicated with him on her cell phone. This was incontravention of the employer's policy prohibiting corrections personnel from fraternizing withinmates. As a result, claimant was discharged from her position. She was initially disqualifiedfrom receiving unemployment insurance benefits on the ground that her employment wasterminated due to misconduct, and this determination was later upheld by an Administrative LawJudge following a hearing. The Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, however, reversed thisdecision and ruled that claimant was entitled to receive benefits because her activities did notconstitute misconduct, but rather an error of judgment. The employer appeals.
We affirm. Initially, we note that whether a claimant has engaged in disqualifyingmisconduct is a factual issue for the Board to resolve and its determination will not be disturbedif supported by substantial evidence (seeMatter of Irons [TLC W., LLC—Commissioner of Labor], 79 AD3d 1511, 1512[2010]; Matter of Reilly [TransitionalServs. for N.Y., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 76 AD3d 738, 739 [2010]).Notably, "not every mistake, exercise of poor judgment or discharge for cause will rise to thelevel of misconduct" (Matter of Bush[St. Luke's Cornwall Hosp.—Commissioner of Labor], 60 AD3d 1179, 1180[2009]; see Matter of Pfohl [Hunter'sHope Found., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 9 AD3d 729, 730 [2004]). Here,various allegations of misconduct were made against claimant in the notice of personnel actionprecipitating her termination and a misdemeanor complaint was apparently filed against herbased upon these allegations. However, the only proof presented at the hearing concerningclaimant's continuing relationship with the male inmate was that she conversed with him on hercell phone. Notably, the corrections captain who testified on behalf of the employer was unableto provide details of the conversations or the evidence providing the basis for the otherallegations of misconduct set forth in the notice of personnel action and criminal complaint.While claimant's activity in making the phone calls violated the employer's policy prohibitingcorrections personnel from having personal conversations with inmates, claimant testified thatshe was unaware of this policy. Based upon the limited record before us, we conclude thatsubstantial evidence supports the Board's finding that claimant's actions, albeit inappropriate, didnot rise to the level of misconduct disqualifying her from receiving unemployment insurancebenefits. Therefore, we decline to disturb its decision.
Mercure, J.P., Lahtinen, Kavanagh, McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that thedecision is affirmed, without costs.