| Matter of Idahosa v Farmingdale State Coll. |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 05417 [97 AD3d 580] |
| July 5, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Omoike Idahosa,Respondent, v Farmingdale State College, Appellant. |
—[*1] Omoike Idahosa, Bronx, N.Y., respondent pro se.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of Farmingdale StateCollege dated May 12, 2010, which, upon a finding that the petitioner engaged in academicdishonesty, dismissed him from the Nursing Program at Farmingdale State College, FarmingdaleState College appeals, (1) from a decision of the Supreme Court, Nassau County (Lally, J.), datedJuly 1, 2011, and (2), as limited by its brief, from so much of a judgment of the same courtentered August 4, 2011, as, upon the decision, granted the petition to the extent of annulling thedetermination dismissing the petitioner from the Nursing Program at Farmingdale State College,and remitted the matter to Farmingdale State College for the imposition of a lesser penalty.
Ordered that the appeal from the decision is dismissed, as no appeal lies from a decision(see Schicchi v J.A. Green Constr. Corp., 100 AD2d 509 [1984]); and it is further,
Ordered that the judgment is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, with costs, thatbranch of the petition which was to review the determination dismissing the petitioner from theNursing Program at Farmingdale State College is denied, and that portion of the proceeding isdismissed.
In April 2010, the petitioner, a student at Farmingdale State College (hereinafter theCollege), was pursuing an associate's degree in nursing. As part of a nursing seminar class, whichincluded an ethics component, the petitioner was required to submit a position paper, whichconstituted 25% of his grade. After the petitioner submitted his paper, his professor determinedthat it had been plagiarized from another student at the College who had submitted the samepaper the previous spring. Disciplinary proceedings were instituted, which resulted in thepetitioner's dismissal from the College's Nursing Program. The petitioner commenced the instantCPLR article 78 proceeding challenging, inter alia, the penalty imposed. The Supreme Courtgranted the petition to the extent of annulling so much of the College's determination asdismissed the petitioner from the Nursing Program, and remitted the matter to the College for theimposition of a lesser penalty.[*2]
An administrative penalty must be upheld unless it is sodisproportionate to the offense as to be shocking to one's sense of fairness, thus constituting anabuse of discretion as a matter of law (see Matter of Ellis v Mahon, 11 NY3d 754, 755 [2008]; Matter of Torrance v Stout, 9 NY3d1022, 1023 [2008]). In other words, both the Supreme Court and this Court "lack[ ] anydiscretionary authority or interest of justice jurisdiction in reviewing the penalty imposed"(Matter of Featherstone v Franco, 95 NY2d 550, 554 [2000]). "[A] result is shocking toone's sense of fairness if the sanction imposed is so grave in its impact on the individualsubjected to it that it is disproportionate to the misconduct, incompetence, failure or turpitude ofthe individual, or to the harm or risk of harm to the agency or institution, or to the publicgenerally visited or threatened by the derelictions of the individuals" (Matter of Pell v Boardof Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck, WestchesterCounty, 34 NY2d 222, 234 [1974]).
Contrary to the Supreme Court's determination, it cannot be concluded, as a matter of law,that the penalty of dismissal is so disproportionate to the petitioner's misconduct as to beshocking to one's sense of fairness, particularly in light of the facts that he was put on notice ofthat possible disciplinary measure, that he continued to deny his plagiarism, and that he providedan implausible explanation for the similarity between his paper and that of the other student (see Matter of Flores v New YorkUniv., 79 AD3d 502 [2010]; see also Matter of Dequito v New School for Gen. Studies, 68 AD3d559 [2009]; Matter of Harper, 223 AD2d 200, 201 [1996]). Accordingly, the petitionshould have been denied and the proceeding dismissed. Balkin, J.P., Eng, Leventhal andChambers, JJ., concur.