| Matter of G&C Transp., Inc. v McGrane |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 05742 [97 AD3d 817] |
| July 25, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of G&C Transportation, Inc., et al.,Appellants, v Jean-Ann McGrane et al., Respondents. |
—[*1]
Tarshis, Catania, Liberth, Mahon & Milligram, PLLC, Newburgh, N.Y. (Michael E. Cataniaof counsel), for respondents.
In a hybrid proceeding, in effect, pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination ofthe City Council of the City of Newburgh dated February 25, 2008, adopting City of NewburghOrdinance No. 3-2008, which amended chapter 272 of the City of Newburgh Code ofOrdinances, and action, inter alia, in effect, for a judgment declaring that chapter 272 of the Cityof Newburgh Code of Ordinances, as amended by Ordinance No. 11-2010, is invalid on theground that it is unconstitutional, the petitioners/plaintiffs appeal from an order and judgment(one paper) of the Supreme Court, Orange County (Ecker, J.), dated June 24, 2011, which deniedtheir motion for summary judgment, granted the respondents/defendants' cross motion forsummary judgment and declared that chapter 272 of the City of Newburgh Code of Ordinances,as amended by City of Newburgh Ordinance No. 11-2010, is valid, constitutional, andenforceable.
Ordered that the order and judgment is affirmed, with costs.
City of Newburgh Ordinance No. 3-2008 (hereinafter the ordinance), amended, in itsentirety, chapter 272 of the City of Newburgh Code of Ordinances, which pertained to theregulation of taxicab services within the City of Newburgh. City of Newburgh Ordinance No.11-2010 further amended the ordinance. The petitioners/plaintiffs, who provide taxicab servicesin the city, challenged various provisions of the ordinance and, after its subsequent amendment,now challenge the same provisions of the amended ordinance. The petitioners/plaintiffs arguegenerally that the ordinance and amended ordinance were enacted in excess of the regulatorypowers vested in the respondents/defendants, and that the ordinance and amended ordinanceviolate the New York and United States Constitutions and, therefore, must be declared invalid.
A local ordinance is cloaked with the same strong presumption of constitutionality as astatute (see Town of Huntington v Park Shore Country Day Camp of Dix Hills, 47 NY2d61, 65 [1979]; Marcus Assoc. v Town of Huntington, 45 NY2d 501, 505 [1978]). It needonly be determined whether the ordinance in question is a reasonable measure for achieving validgoals of the municipality (see Bobka v Town of Huntington, 143 AD2d 381, 383-384[1988]).
Contrary to the contention of the petitioners/plaintiffs, the ordinance and amended [*2]ordinance are reasonably related to the legitimate stated purposes ofbetter serving and protecting local residents, visitors, and legitimate taxi companies from, amongother things, unlicensed and underinsured taxicab drivers. The petitioners/plaintiffs' conclusorysubmissions do not sustain their burden of establishing beyond a reasonable doubt that theordinance and the amended ordinance were not reasonably or rationally related to thoselegitimate stated purposes (see Vecchio v Griffin, 143 AD2d 1003, 1004 [1988];Bobka v Town of Huntington, 143 AD2d 381, 383-384 [1988]). Accordingly, since thepetitioners/plaintiffs failed to sustain their burden of establishing the unconstitutionality of theordinance or amended ordinance beyond a reasonable doubt, the Supreme Court properly, interalia, declared that the amended ordinance is valid, constitutional, and enforceable.
The petitioners/plaintiffs' remaining contentions are without merit. Skelos, J.P., Dickerson,Leventhal and Roman, JJ., concur.