Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig.
2012 NY Slip Op 06551 [99 AD3d 410]
October 2, 2012
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 28, 2012


In the Matter of New York City Asbestos Litigation. LawrenceBernard et al., Respondents,
v
Brookfield Properties Corp. et al., Defendants, andColgate-Palmolive Company, Appellant. Lori Konopka-Sauer et al., Respondents, vColgate-Palmolive Company, Appellant. Arlene Feinberg et al., Respondents, v ColgatePalmolive Company, Appellant, et al., Defendant.

—[*1]Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP, New York (Faith E. Gay of counsel), forappellant.

Levy, Phillips & Konigsberg, New York (James M. Kramer of counsel), for LawrenceBernard, Marilyn Bernard, Lori Konopka-Sauer and Richard Konopka, respondents.

Seeger Weiss LLP, New York (Laurence V. Nassif of counsel), for Arlene Feinberg andJacob Feinberg, respondents.

[*2]Order, Supreme Court, New York County (MartinShulman, J.), entered March 1, 2012, which granted plaintiffs' motion to consolidate theirrespective actions for joint trial, unanimously affirmed, without costs.

Plaintiffs attempt to hold defendant Colgate-Palmolive liable for the alleged presence ofmesothelioma-causing asbestos in the consumer cosmetic talcum powder product called"Cashmere Bouquet." The IAS court providently exercised its discretion in consolidating theseactions for joint trial, as they involve common questions of law and fact (see CPLR 602[a]; Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig. [Brooklyn Nav. Shipyard Cases], 188AD2d 214, 224-225 [1993], affd 82 NY2d 821 [1993]).

Defendant has not established that it will be prejudiced by consolidation of the cases.Contrary to defendant's contention, these cases do not present a novel scientific theory. Indeed,that a link has not yet been established between consumer talcum powder andmesothelioma-causing asbestos does not render plaintiffs' theory an immature tort, particularlywhere the link has been established in the use of industrial talc (see e.g. R.T. Vanderbilt Co.,Inc. v Franklin, 290 SW3d 654 [Ky Ct App 2009]).

We reject defendant's contention that separate trials are required because a different state'slaw will apply to each plaintiff. Defendant has not yet asked the IAS court to undertake achoice-of-law analysis on the issue of causation; thus, it would be premature to deny the motionon this ground. In any event, even if the IAS court concludes that the laws of the different statesmust apply to the different plaintiffs, New York, Oregon, and Florida (the states at issue) havethe same standard with regard to proving causation in asbestos-exposure cases (see e.g. Diel vFlintkote Co., 204 AD2d 53, 54 [1994]; Purcell v Asbestos Corp., Ltd., 153 Or App415, 422-423, 959 P2d 89, 94 [1998], lv denied 329 Or 438, 994 P2d 126 [1999];Reaves v Armstrong World Indus., Inc., 569 So 2d 1307, 1309 [Fla Dist Ct App 1990],lv denied 581 So 2d 166 [Fla 1991]). Moreover, defendant has not demonstrated why thepurported differences in the various states' laws cannot be cured with appropriate juryinstructions.

Nor are separate trials required because of factual differences in plaintiffs' cases. Theindividual issues do not predominate over the common questions of law and fact—namely,whether asbestos was present in the consumer talcum product used by plaintiffs and whetherdefendant should have been aware of its presence. Under these circumstances, the IAS courtrightly concluded that the facts here are on all fours with the criteria set forth in Malcolm vNational Gypsum Co. (995 F2d 346, 350-352 [2d Cir 1993]), as there is a common disease, a[*3]common defendant and a common type of exposure by thethree plaintiffs.

We have considered defendant's remaining arguments and find them unavailing.Concur—Sweeny, J.P., Catterson, Acosta, Freedman and Román, JJ. [PriorCase History: 2012 NY Slip Op 30426(U).]


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.