| Matter of Morin v Town of Lake Luzerne |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 07911 [100 AD3d 1197] |
| November 21, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Robert Morin, Appellant, v Town ofLake Luzerne et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent. |
—[*1] Lemire Johnson, LLC, Malta (Christopher R. Lemire of counsel), for Town of Lake Luzerneand another, respondents.
Garry, J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed December 9,2010, which ruled that apportionment applied to claimant's workers' compensation award.
Claimant suffered a work-related back injury on September 1, 2009 and was awardedworkers' compensation benefits. Following claimant's hearing testimony and the submission ofmedical evidence, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge determined, as relevant here, thatclaimant's award should be apportioned 50% to the 2009 work-related injury and 50% to a 2004back injury. A panel of the Workers' Compensation Board affirmed. Claimant appeals.
Initially, we note that " '[a]pportionment of a workers' compensation award presents a factualissue for resolution by the Board and its decision will be upheld so long as it is supported bysubstantial evidence' " (Matter ofAltobelli v Allinger Temporary Servs., Inc., 70 AD3d 1083, 1084 [2010], quoting Matter of Mandziara v Lowe's HomeCtrs., 41 AD3d 1020, 1020-1021 [2007]). However, apportionment is inapplicable as amatter of law when the preexisting condition was not due to a compensable injury and theclaimant was fully employed and capable [*2]of effectivelyperforming his or her job duties notwithstanding the preexisting condition (see Matter of Monroe v Town ofChester, 42 AD3d 862, 865 [2007]; Matter of Bremner v New Venture Gear, 31 AD3d 848, 848[2006]); apportionment applies "only in cases where the prior condition constitutes a disability ina compensation sense" (Matter of Nye vIBM Corp., 2 AD3d 1164, 1164 [2003] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted];see Matter of Mandziara v Lowe's Home Ctrs., 41 AD3d at 1021).
At the time of claimant's 2004 back injury, his treating chiropractor indicated that claimant'scondition was not due to his employment. Claimant was out of work for several monthsfollowing that injury, but he subsequently underwent a comprehensive preemployment physicalexamination prior to commencing his employment as a mechanic with the Town of Lake Luzernein 2005. Claimant was thereafter employed full time and was able to fully perform his job forover four years before the September 2009 work-related injury. The Town's medical expertopined that apportionment was appropriate due to the similarity of the symptoms and pathologyof the 2004 and 2009 injuries, but we note that "the dispositive issue is not whether a claimant'spreexisting condition was symptomatic but, rather, whether such condition was disabling"(Matter of Bruno v Kelly Temp Serv., 301 AD2d 730, 731 [2003]; accord Matter ofHogan v Hilltop Manor of Niskayuna, 303 AD2d 822, 823 [2003]). Accordingly, the Board'sdecision to apportion claimant's workers' compensation award was unsupported and must bereversed (see Matter of Nye v IBM Corp., 2 AD3d at 1165; Matter of Montana vOrion Bus Indus., 303 AD2d 820, 821 [2003]).
Mercure, J.P., Malone Jr., Kavanagh and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision isreversed, without costs, and matter remitted to the Workers' Compensation Board for furtherproceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.