Union Carbide Corp. v Affiliated FM Ins. Co.
2012 NY Slip Op 08409 [101 AD3d 434]
December 6, 2012
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 6, 2013


Union Carbide Corporation, Respondent,
v
Affiliated FMInsurance Company et al., Defendants, and Columbia Casualty Company et al.,Appellants.

—[*1]Ford Marrin Esposito Witmeyer & Gleser, LLP, New York (Catherine B. Altier ofcounsel), for Columbia Casualty Company and Continental Casualty Company, appellants.

Litchfield Cavo LLP, New York (Edward Fogarty, Jr., and Brian M. Reid of the bar of theState of Illinois, admitted pro hac vice, of counsel), for Argonaut Insurance Company, appellant.

Proskauer Rose LLP, Chicago, IL (Steven R. Gilford of the bar of the State of Illinois,admitted pro hac vice, of counsel), for respondent.

Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Charles E. Ramos, J.), entered January 4, 2011,which granted plaintiff's motion for partial summary judgment striking defendant ArgonautInsurance Company's defense that there should be no insurance coverage because plaintiffexpected or intended the bodily injury claims that resulted from exposure to its asbestos products,and denied Argonaut's motion for summary judgment on the same issue, unanimously affirmed,with costs.

Plaintiff met its burden of establishing that the damages at issue were the result of an"occurrence" and thus that defendant's policy provided coverage (see Consolidated EdisonCo. of N.Y. v Allstate Ins. Co., 98 NY2d 208, 220 [2002]). Indeed, the record supportsplaintiff's contention that, although it was aware of some risk involved in the utilization ofasbestos, at all times relevant to this appeal, it believed that its asbestos products could be usedsafely under the right conditions. Plaintiff also offered, as further proof of any lack of intent,evidence that it published regulatory information in trade periodicals and provided informationregarding the dangers of asbestos, as well as guidance concerning its proper usage, to its clientsand potential customers (see Santoro ex rel. Santoro v Donnelly, 340 F Supp 2d 464, 486[SD NY 2004] [New York law presumes that users will heed warnings provided with aproduct]). In addition, plaintiff presented evidence that, during the relevant time period, thefederal government shared plaintiff's belief that asbestos could be used safely and, to that end,promulgated regulations designed to control, monitor and record asbestos usage—but,importantly, did not ban it.[*2]

Since plaintiff established coverage, the burden shifted todefendants to show that, pursuant to the policy's exclusion, plaintiff intended the damages(see Consolidated Edison, 98 NY2d at 220; Continental Cas. Co. v Rapid-AmericanCorp., 80 NY2d 640, 649 [1993]). Defendants have failed in this regard. Defendants assertedthat plaintiff intended the damages because it knew that asbestos would cause injuries and thatclaims would be filed against it. The record, however, shows that plaintiff was merely aware thatasbestos could cause injuries and that claims could be filed. Plaintiff's "calculated risk" inmanufacturing and selling its products despite its awareness of possible injuries and claims doesnot amount to an expectation of damage (Continental Cas., 80 NY2d at 649).

Defendants' collateral estoppel argument based on a California jury verdict also fails. Thenature of the jury instructions in the California case renders it impossible to discern exactlywhich facts, or acts of plaintiff, played a part in the jury's decision, or upon exactly which portionof the jury instruction (i.e., malice, oppression or fraud) the jury based its punitive damagesaward. As such, defendants cannot show an "an identity of issue which has necessarily beendecided in the prior action and is decisive of the present action" (Schwartz v Public Adm'r ofCounty of Bronx, 24 NY2d 65, 71 [1969]).

We have considered defendants' remaining arguments and find them unavailing.Concur—Gonzalez, P.J., Sweeny, Richter, Román and Clark, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.