| New York Cent. Lines, LLC v State of New York |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 08704 [101 AD3d 966] |
| December 19, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| New York Central Lines, LLC,Respondent-Appellant, v State of New York,Appellant-Respondent. |
—[*1] Goldstein, Rikon & Rikon, P.C., New York, N.Y. (Jonathan Houghton of counsel), forrespondent-appellant.
In a claim to recover damages arising from, inter alia, a partial taking of certain real property,the State of New York appeals, as limited by its brief, on the ground of excessiveness, from somuch of a judgment of the Court of Claims (Marin, J.), dated January 11, 2011, as, upon adecision of the same court dated August 26, 2010, made after a nonjury trial, in effect, awardedthe claimant the principal sum of $12,104,106 in damages for the permanent takings in fee andby easement, and the claimant cross-appeals, as limited by its brief, on the ground of inadequacy,from so much of the same judgment as only awarded it this sum for the permanent takings in feeand by easement.
Ordered that the judgment is affirmed insofar as appealed from, without costs ordisbursements; and it is further,
Ordered that the judgment is reversed insofar as cross-appealed from, on the law and thefacts, without costs or disbursements, and the matter is remitted to the Court of Claims for adetermination as to the appropriate corridor factor to apply to the $12,104,106 "across-the-fence"estimate of the value of the subject property as furnished by the claimant's expert, for thevaluation and calculation of 5% of the market value of certain subject parcels of real propertydesignated as Parcels 130A, 193F, 194J, and 195H, based on the "across-the-fence" value ofthese parcels as set forth in the claimant's expert's supplemental report, which shall includeapplication of the appropriate corridor factor, representing direct damages for the State's taking ofpermanent easements over these parcels, and for the entry of an appropriate amended judgmentthereafter.
In January 2000, the State of New York appropriated, partially in fee and partially throughpermanent easement, several parcels of the claimant's real property (hereinafter the appropriatedproperty) for the purpose of expanding the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway. The appropriatedproperty was part of a rail corridor owned by the claimant. In June 2000, the claimant filed aclaim in the Court of Claims to recover damages for the taking of the appropriated property. TheState appeals, on the ground of excessiveness, and the claimant cross-appeals, on the ground of[*2]inadequacy, from so much of the judgment of the Court ofClaims, made after a nonjury trial, as awarded damages for the permanent takings, both in feeand by easement.
"The measure of damages in a case involving the partial taking of real property is thedifference between the value of the entirety of the premises before the taking and the value of theremainder after the taking" (GyrodyneCo. of Am., Inc. v State of New York, 89 AD3d 988, 989 [2011]; see Diocese ofBuffalo v State of New York, 24 NY2d 320, 323 [1969]; Chester Indus. Park Assoc., LLP v State of New York, 65 AD3d513 [2009]). "The measure of damages must reflect the fair market value of the property inits highest and best use on the date of the taking, regardless of whether the property is being putto such use at the time" (Gyrodyne Co. of Am., Inc. v State of New York, 89 AD3d at989 [internal quotation marks omitted]).
At a nonjury trial on the issue of damages, the claimant and the State each presented thetestimony of experts with regard to valuation of the appropriated property. The experts agreedthat the highest and best use of the appropriated property was as a rail corridor. They disagreed,however, as to the proper method for valuation.
The State's expert advocated a cost, or reproduction cost less depreciation, approach tovaluation, which is employed in valuing "specialty" properties (see generally Matter of AlliedCorp. v Town of Camillus, 80 NY2d 351, 357 [1992]; Matter of Al Turi Landfill, Inc. v Town of Goshen, 93 AD3d 786[2012]). However, the Court of Claims properly rejected this approach because, inter alia, theevidence demonstrated that the appropriated property did not constitute a specialty property.Additionally, the Court of Claims properly rejected the State's lump-sum reduction of the marketvalue of the appropriated property to 15% of the estimated value. Since the opinion of the State'sexpert as to this particular issue was not supported with sufficient facts, figures, and calculations,his opinion in this regard lacked probative value (see Matter of County of Dutchess [285 MillSt.], 186 AD2d 891, 891-892 [1992]; Matter of Northville Indus. Corp. v Board ofAssessors of Town of Riverhead, 143 AD2d 135, 136 [1988]).
"Having rejected the State's appraisal, the trial court was bound to either accept the claimant'sappraisal or explain the basis for any departure" (Gyrodyne Co. of Am., Inc. v State of NewYork, 89 AD3d at 989; see Matter of City of New York [Reiss], 55 NY2d 885, 886[1982]; Matter of City of New York v Estate of Levine, 196 AD2d 654, 655 [1993]).
The claimant's expert, Charles W. Rex III, specialized in the appraisal of rail corridors. Inoffering his testimony and appraisal, he relied on, among other things, a number of scholarlyarticles on corridor valuation in support of his opinion as to the proper methodology for corridorvaluation (see e.g. Charles F. Seymour, The Continuing Evolution of CorridorAppraising [Back to the Basics], Right of Way, May/June 2002 at 12-20; Arthur G. Rahn,The Enhancement Factor in Transportation Corridor Sales and Appraisals, Appraisal J.,Jan. 1999 at 89-92; John P. Dolman and Charles F. Seymour, Valuation ofTransportation/Communication Corridors, Appraisal J., Oct. 1978 at 509-522).
Rex valued the appropriated property pursuant to a comparable sales approach, which "isgenerally the preferred measure of a property's value for assessment" (Matter of Allied Corp.v Town of Camillus, 80 NY2d at 356; see Matter of Al Turi Landfill, Inc. v Town ofGoshen, 93 AD3d at 792). The specific comparable sales approach advocated by Rex wasthe "corridor valuation" method, which is, at its essence, a two-step process. First, the"across-the-fence" value (hereinafter the ATF value) of the land is estimated based on, amongother things, the location of the corridor and market conditions. The ATF value is then multipliedby a "corridor factor." According to Rex, the "purpose of the corridor factor is to convert [ATF]value into the value of the corridor. Into market value. The corridor factor measures theimportance of the corridor." In other words, when a property's highest and best use is as acorridor, and the property is to remain as a corridor, that property will generally sell for morethan the ATF value of the land, and the corridor factor figures this into the valuation.
The Court of Claims, in its decision dated August 26, 2010, upon which the judgment wasentered, properly "accept[ed] the validity of the comparable sales method" advocated by Rex[*3]on behalf of the claimant. However, the court elected not toapply any corridor factor in reviewing the valuation. The Court of Claims' determination in thisregard was neither "supported by [the] evidence [nor] adequately explained by the court"(Matter of City of New York [Reiss], 55 NY2d at 886). Accordingly, we must remit thematter for a determination as to the appropriate corridor factor to be applied to the ATF value asestimated by the claimant's expert, and for the entry of an appropriate amended judgmentthereafter.
We also agree with the claimant that the Court of Claims erred in failing to award it directdamages for the State's taking of permanent easements over those parcels of real propertydesignated as Parcels 130A, 193F, 194J, and 195H. Rex testified, as supported by hissupplemental appraisal report, that the State's acquisition of those permanent easements caused aloss of 50% of the value of those parcels. The State's appraiser testified, as supported by hisreport, that the State's acquisition of permanent easements only caused a 5% loss of their overallvalue. The Court of Claims, however, found no loss in value with respect to these parcels.
As a general matter, "[u]pon a condemnation of a permanent easement, the landowner isentitled to the difference in value of the premises without the burden of the easement and withthe burden of the easement, together with the further direct and consequential damage, if any,occasioned to the lot arising from the use of the easement" (City of Yonkers v A. & J.Cianciulli, Inc., 117 NYS2d 792, 794 [1952]; see Matter of City of New York, 269NY 64, 69-70 [1935]; Donaloio v State of New York, 99 AD2d 335, 338 [1984],affd 64 NY2d 811 [1985]). Upon the taking of a permanent easement, the damages mustbe determined based upon what the condemnor has the right to do under the terms of theeasement as appropriated (see Morton v State of New York, 8 AD2d 49, 52 [1959]). Onthe evidence before the Court of Claims, we conclude that the State is correct that the claimant isentitled to 5% of the market value of the aforementioned parcels for the State's taking of thesepermanent easements. Accordingly, upon remittal, the Court of Claims shall determine thisamount, based on the ATF value of these parcels, as set forth in Rex's supplemental report, andshall include, in its calculations, what it deems to be the appropriate corridor factor. Mastro, J.P.,Skelos, Florio and Dickerson, JJ., concur.