| Matter of Menditto v Collier |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 08845 [101 AD3d 1409] |
| December 20, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Cristina Menditto, Respondent, v Andrew Collier,Appellant. |
—[*1] Bartlett, Pontiff, Stewart & Rhodes, PC, Glens Falls (Karla Williams Buettner of counsel),for respondent. Jeffrey E. McMorris, Glens Falls, attorney for the child.
Malone Jr., J. Appeal from an order of the Family Court of Warren County (Breen, J.), filedNovember 30, 2011, which, in a proceeding pursuant to Family Ct Act article 6, among otherthings, denied respondent's motion to vacate a default judgment entered against him.
Petitioner (hereinafter the mother) and respondent (hereinafter the father) are the parents of ason (born in 2010). In May 2011, upon agreement of the parties, Family Court entered an orderthat granted the parties joint legal custody. The mother was awarded primary physical custodyand the father was granted unsupervised visitation from 9:00 a.m. Monday until 9:00 a.m.Wednesday, and on certain holidays. The father was also ordered to complete all substance abusetreatments recommended by the Behavioral Health Services' Center for Recovery, and aparenting skills class through the YMCA. Three months later, when the father did not providesatisfactory responses to the mother's requests to verify his participation in the requiredprograms, the mother filed a violation petition seeking to limit his visitation.
At the first appearance on the violation petition, Family Court adjourned to permit the fatherto secure counsel. When neither the father, nor counsel on his behalf, appeared at the [*2]appointed time on the next appearance date, the court granted themother's oral application for a default judgment. Later that same day, the father appeared atFamily Court and wrote a letter to the court—which was treated as a motion to vacate thedefault—alleging that he had failed to appear earlier due to car trouble.
Before the motion to vacate came on to be heard, Family Court issued a written order on thedefault judgment that modified custody by limiting the father to supervised visitation from 4:00p.m. to 7:00 p.m. on Mondays and Tuesdays, with no provision for holidays. Thereafter, at thehearing on the motion to vacate the default, the father appeared with counsel, who requested thatthe motion be amended to include materials that would allegedly demonstrate his participation inthe required programs and, thus, establish a meritorious defense. Family Court denied thatrequest, and also denied the motion to vacate the default judgment. The father now appeals.
Initially, we are not persuaded by the mother's argument that the appeal has been renderedmoot by Family Court's dismissal of a subsequent petition brought by the father to modify thecustody order entered on default. The court's decision to dismiss the modification petition restedin part upon matters that arose after the default judgment was entered and after the motion tovacate the default was denied. Thus, the issues raised in this appeal are not moot (see Matterof Hearst Corp. v Clyne, 50 NY2d 707, 714 [1980]).
On the merits, we agree with the father that Family Court abused its discretion when itdenied his motion to vacate the default judgment (see CPLR 5015 [a] [1]; Matter of Womack v Rosario, 50AD3d 1212, 1213 [2008]). The record demonstrates that he was present at the courthouseand moved to vacate the default just hours after his scheduled appearance, he offered areasonable excuse for his failure to appear on time, the documents he sought to introduce made aprima facie showing that he was engaged in the mandated services, and no prejudice accrued tothe mother, as she was on notice that he intended to oppose the violation petition (see Matterof Buel v Buel, 263 AD2d 561, 563 [1999]; Matter of Waite v Whalen, 215 AD2d922, 923-924 [1995]). Moreover, and of paramount importance in this custody case, FamilyCourt failed to make any findings relative to the best interests of the child, which it was requiredto do prior to changing an established custody arrangement (see Matter of Donahue vBuisch, 265 AD2d 601, 603 [1999]). Accordingly, we must vacate the default judgmententered in favor of petitioner.
Mercure, J.P., Spain, Stein and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is reversed, onthe law, without costs, motion granted, default judgment vacated, and matter remitted to theFamily Court of Warren County for further proceedings not inconsistent with this Court'sdecision.