Matter of Thomas v New York City Dept. of Educ.
2013 NY Slip Op 01026 [103 AD3d 495]
February 19, 2013
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 27, 2013


In the Matter of Michael P. Thomas,Appellant,
v
New York City Department of Education et al.,Respondents.

—[*1]Hagan, Coury & Associates, Brooklyn (Paul Golden of counsel), for appellant.

Michael A. Cardozo, Corporation Counsel, New York (Elizabeth I. Freedman ofcounsel), for respondents.

Judgment, Supreme Court, New York County (Geoffrey D. Wright, J.), entered April9, 2012, denying the petition seeking to compel respondents to disclose documentsrequested by petitioner pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (FOIL), anddismissing the proceeding brought pursuant to CPLR article 78, unanimously reversed,on the law, without costs, the proceeding reinstated, and the matter remanded for an incamera inspection of the requested documents to determine if redaction could strike anappropriate balance between personal privacy and public policy interests, and whetherrespondents otherwise assert applicable FOIL exemptions.

Petitioner is a public school teacher employed by the Manhattan Center for Scienceand Mathematics (MCSM), which allegedly receives funds under title I, part A of theElementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (ESEA), reauthorized as the No ChildLeft Behind Act of 2001 (20 USC § 6301 et seq.). In August 2010,pursuant to the "No Child Left Behind Written Complaint and Appeal Procedures"adopted by the New York State Education Department, petitioner filed a complaintagainst the administrators of MCSM alleging that: "1. the [school's] 2009-2010Comprehensive Educational Plan (CEP) was not developed with the involvement ofparents and other members of the school community as required by Section 1114 (b) (2)(B) (ii) of Title I, Part A of the ESEA; 2. required components of a schoolwide programthat address the needs of at-risk students were not implemented as required by Section1114 (b) (2) and Section 1118 of Title I, Part A of the ESEA; 3. Title I funds weremisappropriated and were not used to implement the components of a schoolwideprogram as required by Section 1114 (b) (2) (A) (ii) of Title I, Part of the ESEA; and 4.the 2010-2011 CEP did not exist as required by Section 1114 (b) (2) (B) (ii) of Title I,Part A of the ESEA."

Respondent New York City Department of Education (DOE) referred the complaintto its Office of Special Investigations (OSI). After OSI found the allegations to beunsubstantiated, petitioner filed a FOIL request seeking the investigative report andrelated documents.

DOE's Central Record Access Officer (CRAO) denied the FOIL request pursuant toPublic Officers Law § 87 (2) (b) on the ground that all of the OSI records wereexempt from disclosure because they related to unsubstantiated allegations of misconductand their release [*2]would constitute an unwarrantedinvasion of the personal privacy of the employees in question. Respondent Michael Best,General Counsel of DOE, denied petitioner's administrative appeal, finding that theCRAO's determination fell "well within the bounds" of the Committee on OpenGovernment's published advisory opinions denying FOIL requests in the context ofunsubstantiated complaints, and that redaction of identifying details would not protectthe personal privacy of the subject individuals because petitioner filed the underlyingcomplaint and therefore knew the identity of the persons whose details he would haveDOE delete.

The No Child Left Behind Written Complaint and Appeal Procedures expresslycontemplate FOIL requests for Investigative Reports, stating as follows: "Does the StateEducation Department maintain a record of all complaints/appeals? Yes. Copies ofcorrespondence, related documents, investigative reports, and summary reports involvedin the complaint/appeal resolution will be maintained by the State Education Departmentfor five years. Records will be made available to interested parties in accordance with theprovisions of the New York State Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers LawSections 84-89)."

Pursuant to FOIL, government records are presumptively available to the publicunless they are statutorily exempted by Public Officers Law § 87 (2) (seeMatter of Fappiano v New York City Police Dept., 95 NY2d 738, 746 [2001])."Those exemptions are to be narrowly construed, with the burden resting on the agencyto demonstrate that the requested material indeed qualifies for exemption" (Matter ofHanig v State of N.Y. Dept. of Motor Vehs., 79 NY2d 106, 109 [1992]).

Public Officers Law § 87 (2) (b) permits an agency to deny access to adocument, or portion of a document, if disclosure "would constitute an unwarrantedinvasion of personal privacy." "What constitutes an unwarranted invasion of personalprivacy is measured by what would be offensive and objectionable to a reasonable[person] of ordinary sensibilities" (Matter of Beyah v Goord, 309 AD2d 1049,1050 [3d Dept 2003] [internal quotation marks omitted]).

"Public Officers Law § 89 (2) (b) says that an unwarranted invasion ofpersonal privacy includes, but shall not be limited to seven specified kinds of disclosure.In a case, like this one, where none of the seven specifications is applicable, a court mustdecide whether any invasion of privacy . . . is unwarranted by balancing theprivacy interests at stake against the public interest in [the] disclosure of the information"(Matter of Harbatkin v NewYork City Dept. of Records & Info. Servs., 19 NY3d 373, 380 [2012] [internalquotation marks omitted]). However, the section does not create a blanket exemption.Public Officers Law § 89 (2) (c) (i) provides that "[u]nless otherwise provided bythis article, disclosure shall not be construed to constitute an unwarranted invasion ofpersonal privacy pursuant to paragraphs (a) and (b) of this subdivision: . . .when identifying details are deleted."

The federal No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (the NCLB) states as follows: "Thepurpose of this subchapter [20 USC § 6301 et seq.] is to ensure that allchildren have a fair, equal, and significant opportunity to obtain a high-quality educationand reach, at a minimum, proficiency on challenging State academic achievementstandards and state [sic] academic assessments" (20 USC § 6301). Based on thetheory that poverty and low scholastic achievement are closely related, subchapter I, partA of the NCLB, titled "Improving Basic Programs Operated by Local EducationalAgencies," provides federal grants-in-aid to support compensatory education fordisadvantaged children in low-income areas.

Petitioner's FOIL request sought the investigation report relating to his complaintagainst the administrators of MCSM, alleging that, in violation of the ESEA, the school'sCEP was not [*3]developed with the involvement ofparents and other members of the school community, that required components of theCEP were not implemented, and that title I funds were misappropriated. Issues involvingthe expenditure of education funds and the quality of education, and why a governmentagency determined that a complaint concerning a violation of federal law relating theretois allegedly unsubstantiated, are of significant public interest.

Despite this significant public interest, respondents denied the FOIL request in itsentirety, with respondent Best citing a published advisory opinion of the Committee onOpen Government, which states that records related to unsubstantiated allegations ofmisconduct are not relevant to job performance and, therefore, disclosure constitutes anunwarranted, not a permissible, "invasion of personal privacy" (FOIL-AO-10399 [Oct. 31,1997]; see also FOIL-AO-12005 [Mar. 21, 2000]). Acknowledging this policy,Supreme Court affirmed, stating in part that "[s]o long as the subject matter is quasicriminal in nature, as is the claim here, then the entire file of the investigation and theresulting findings, should be regarded as beyond the reach of [FOIL]."

However, advisory opinions issued by the Committee on Open Government "are notbinding authority, but may be considered to be persuasive based on the strength of theirreasoning and analysis" (Matterof TJS of N.Y., Inc. v New York State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 89 AD3d 239,242 n [3d Dept 2011]; see also Matter of Buffalo News v Buffalo Enter. Dev.Corp., 84 NY2d 488, 493 [1994]). There is no statutory blanket exemption forinvestigative records, even where the allegations of misconduct are "quasi criminal" innature or not substantiated, and the ability to withhold records under FOIL can only bebased on the effects of disclosure in conjunction with attendant facts (see Matter ofGould v New York City Police Dept., 89 NY2d 267, 275 [1996] ["blanketexemptions for particular types of documents are inimical to FOIL's policy of opengovernment"]). Indeed, the Committee for Open Government has issued "advisoryopinions regarding agencies' obligations under FOIL and has concluded, inter alia, thatunless exempted under FOIL, the DOI [New York City Department of Investigation]must reveal the names of DOI employees who conducted an investigation once it hasconcluded (FOIL-AO-9399), communications between the DOI and the Department ofState are subject to disclosure (FOIL-AO-4766), 'closing memoranda' prepared by theDOI as a result of an investigation are presumptively accessible to the public(FOIL-AO-9399), and the DOI must disclose all written documents, including reportsand memoranda if sought pursuant to a FOIL request (FOIL-AO- 3656)" (Murphy vCity of New York, 2008 NY Slip Op 31926[U], *18 [2008] [Sup Ct, NY County2008] [DOI has no duty to ensure the confidentiality of its investigative reports, but, as amatter of law, is obligated to make available for public inspection all documents notspecifically exempted under FOIL], affd 59 AD3d 301 [1st Dept 2009]).

For example, FOIL-AO-9399, cited in Murphy, dealt with a request by theDaily News for closing memoranda prepared by the DOI. The advisory opinionexplained that "if a final determination identifies a person who is the subject of a chargeor allegation and the determination is that the charge or allegation has no merit, I believethat an applicant would have the right to obtain the substance of the determination,following the deletion of personally identifiable details. The Daily News may beinterested not only in those cases in which charges have been substantiated, but alsothose in which the charges are found to have been without merit, perhaps as a means ofattempting to ascertain more fully how DOI operates and carries out its official duties."

This reasoning applies equally to petitioner's FOIL request for OSI's investigativereport [*4]and related documents. As the legislaturedeclared in Public Officers Law § 84, "[t]he people's right to know the process ofgovernmental decision-making and to review the documents and statistics leading todeterminations is basic to our society. Access to such information should not be thwartedby shrouding it with the cloak of secrecy or confidentiality."

FOIL-AO-10399, on which respondents rely, does not require otherwise. In thatadvisory opinion, which pertains to the disclosure of records related to an incident ofalleged sexual harassment, the Committee stated as follows: "It is clear that publicemployees enjoy a lesser degree of privacy than others, for it has been found in variouscontexts that public employees are required to be more accountable than others. Further,the courts have found that, as a general rule, records that are relevant to the performanceof a public employee's official duties are available, for disclosure in such instances wouldresult in a permissible rather than an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy.Conversely, to the extent that records are irrelevant to the performance of one's officialduties, it has been found that disclosure would indeed constitute an unwarranted invasionof personal privacy" (internal citations omitted).

Here, the underlying complaint pertains to MCSM's administrators' performance oftheir official duties when using and applying federal funds, and in constructing andimplementing the CEP. Accordingly, this matter should be remanded to the article 78court for an in camera inspection of the documents to determine if redaction could strikean appropriate balance between personal privacy and public interests and which materialcould be properly disclosed (seeMatter of Molloy v New York City Police Dept., 50 AD3d 98, 100-101 [1stDept 2008]; Kwasnik v City of New York, 262 AD2d 171 [1st Dept 1999]). Thecourt should also determine whether portions of the documents may be exempt fromdisclosure as intra- or inter-agency records that are not statistical or factual data (PublicOfficers Law § 87 [2] [g]; see generally Matter of Gould v New York CityPolice Dept., 89 NY2d 267, 275 [1996]). Concur—Mazzarelli, J.P., Andrias,DeGrasse, Richter and Clark, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.