Madison Mut. Ins. Co. v Expert Chimney Servs., Inc.
2013 NY Slip Op 01113 [103 AD3d 995]
February 21, 2013
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 27, 2013


Madison Mutual Insurance Company, as Subrogee of EricC. Jerabek et al., Appellant, v Expert Chimney Services, Inc., et al., Defendants, andGreenhomes America, LLC, Sued Herein as Greenhomes America by En-Therm,Respondent.

—[*1]Mura & Storm, PLLC, Buffalo (Kris E. Lawrence of counsel), for appellant.

Duke, Holzman, Photiadis & Gresens, LLP, Buffalo (Howard E. Berger of counsel),for respondent.

Rose, J.P. Appeal from a supplemental order of the Supreme Court (Cerio Jr., J.),entered March 1, 2012 in Madison County, which, among other things, granted a motionby defendant Greenhomes America, LLC to compel certain discovery.

On December 11, 2009, a home owned by plaintiff's insureds, Eric C. Jerabek andJanice M. Jerabek, was damaged by fire. On that date, plaintiff hired Gordon Ivory tocommence a cause and origin investigation of the fire and, several days later, plaintiffadditionally engaged investigator Gary Hauf for that purpose. Plaintiff ultimately paidthe fire loss claim under a homeowner's policy issued to the Jerabeks. In February 2010,plaintiff retained counsel and, in February 2011, commenced this subrogation actionagainst defendants alleging various claims of negligence, breach of contract and breachof warranty. Following joinder of issue, defendant [*2]Greenhomes America, LLC (hereinafter defendant) servedplaintiff with interrogatories and a notice to produce.

Dissatisfied with certain of plaintiff's responses to these disclosure demands,defendant moved to compel plaintiff "to serve further and complete responses." In anorder entered December 22, 2011, Supreme Court, among other things, denieddefendant's motion to compel with respect to the disputed interrogatories. As for thenotice to produce, however, the court ordered plaintiff to submit a privilege log pursuantto CPLR 3122 (b). Plaintiff prepared and submitted such a log, noting its refusal todisclose 15 documents consisting of emails, a diagram and the investigative reportssubmitted by Ivory and Hauf on the basis that they were "material prepared inanticipation of litigation." Defendant then responded with its written objections, plaintiffopposed them and, in an order entered March 1, 2012, Supreme Court granteddefendant's motion to produce the withheld 15 documents. This appeal by plaintiffensued, and we now affirm.

Although plaintiff initially argues that Supreme Court characterized the subject caseas a liability action in its December 2011 order and then unfairly changed its position inits March 2012 order to recognize plaintiff's status as a property insurer, plaintiff'sreference is to language specifically employed by the court in that part of its earlierdecision denying defendant's motion to compel a response to the interrogatories.Accordingly, it is not binding on this appeal from the March 2012 order. Further, it bearsnoting that even liability insurers undertaking the defense of their insured are required tomeet appropriate burdens of proof in order to resist disclosure (see Claverack Coop.Ins. Co. v Nielsen, 296 AD2d 789, 789 [2002]).

Plaintiff also argues that Supreme Court abused its discretion when, after reviewingthe privilege log, it directed disclosure of the disputed discovery items from plaintiff'sclaim file. We cannot agree. Significantly, CPLR 3101 (a) provides for "full disclosure ofall matter material and necessary in the prosecution or defense of an action," and theparty claiming immunity from disclosure has the initial burden of showing that thematerials being sought were prepared solely and exclusively for litigation purposes(see CPLR 3101 [d] [2]; 148 Magnolia, LLC v Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 62 AD3d486, 487 [2009]; Martino v Kalbacher, 225 AD2d 862, 863 [1996];Carden v Allstate Ins. Co., 105 AD2d 1048, 1049 [1984]). "[T]his burden cannotbe satisfied with wholly conclusory allegations" (Claverack Coop. Ins. Co. vNielsen, 296 AD2d at 789; see Brooklyn Union Gas Co. v American Home Assur. Co., 23AD3d 190, 191 [2005]). Further, we note that mixed or "[m]ultipurpose reports arenot free from disclosure" (Carden v Allstate Ins. Co., 105 AD2d at 1049).

Here, Supreme Court correctly held that plaintiff failed in its initial burden ofdemonstrating that the disputed materials were immune from discovery. Plaintiff hassubmitted no affidavits or other information from anyone with first-hand knowledge thatwould support a conclusion that the investigative reports and other disputed documentsin the file were prepared solely for use in this subrogation action. Instead, plaintiffprovided only conclusory affidavits and documents from its counsel, not based onfirst-hand knowledge, that are insufficient to satisfy the required standard (seeClaverack Coop. Ins. Co. v Nielsen, 296 AD2d at 789; Agovino v Taco Bell5083, 225 AD2d 569, 571 [1996]; Martino v Kalbacher, 225 AD2d at 863).Counsel's references to various copies of emails and letters in the record do not, asplaintiff argues, conclusively demonstrate that the disputed materials were only related tofuture litigation and "not also used to evaluate [the insureds'] claim or that retention of anindependent investigator was other than [the] ordinary course of business practice whenconfronted with a fire [*3]loss" (Carden v AllstateIns. Co., 105 AD2d at 1049).[FN*]Given the court's broad discretionary authority to regulate discovery (see 148Magnolia, LLC v Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 62 AD3d at 487; BrooklynUnion Gas Co. v American Home Assur. Co., 23 AD3d at 190), we find no basis forreversal.

Plaintiff's remaining contentions have been examined and found to be lacking inmerit.

Spain, Stein and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Ordered that the supplemental order isaffirmed, with costs.

Footnotes


Footnote *: We note that whileplaintiff's privilege log indicates that Hauf's report was not issued until December2010—after plaintiff retained counsel in February 2010—the onlyinformation in the record before us indicates that Hauf's actual investigation wasperformed in conjunction with that of Ivory, prior to the retention of counsel.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.