| Leighton v Lowenberg |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 01161 [103 AD3d 530] |
| February 21, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Patricia Leighton, Appellant, v Marc Lowenberg,D.D.S., et al., Respondents, et al., Defendant. |
—[*1] Martin Clearwater & Bell, LLP, New York (Stewart G. Milch of counsel), forrespondents.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Alice Schlesinger, J.), entered on or aboutJuly 5, 2011, which, in this dental malpractice action, to the extent appealed from aslimited by the briefs, denied plaintiff's motion to amend the complaint to add a cause ofaction for lack of informed consent, granted the dentist defendants' (defendants) motionfor partial summary judgment dismissing plaintiff's gross negligence and breach ofimplied warranty claims and her demand for punitive damages, and denied plaintiff'scross motion for leave to amend the complaint to add a claim for breach of contract andto further particularize facts concerning her claims for lack of informed consent, grossnegligence, and breach of contract, unanimously affirmed, without costs.
The court providently exercised its discretion in denying plaintiff's request for leaveto amend the complaint to add lack of informed consent claims. Plaintiff failed to submitan expert affirmation stating with certainty that the information defendants allegedlyprovided to plaintiff before the dental procedures at issue departed from what areasonable practitioner would have disclosed (see Orphan v Pilnik, 15 NY3d 907, 908 [2010]). Further,the numerous unauthenticated audio recordings upon which plaintiff heavily relies areinsufficient to independently establish the merit of her proposed amendment.
Plaintiff's allegations that defendants negligently placed a veneer on one of her teeth,intentionally misled her to believe that she would receive the "picket fence" dentaltreatment, and gave her precision dentures despite a lack of experience in this area, donot rise to the level of gross negligence, as the alleged conduct does not "smack" ofintentional wrongdoing (seeApple Bank for Sav. v PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 70 AD3d 438, 438 [1stDept 2010] [internal quotation marks omitted]). Plaintiff's allegations do not sufficientlystate anything other than dental malpractice claims. The alleged conduct also "falls shortof showing the high degree of moral turpitude, wanton dishonesty and utter malicenecessary to an award of punitive damages" (Board of Mgrs. of the Waterford Assn., Inc. v Samii, 68 AD3d585, 586 [1st Dept 2009] [internal quotation marks omitted]).[*2]
Plaintiff's proposed breach of contract claim is"legally redundant" of the dental malpractice claim, and plaintiff has failed to show that,within the context of her dental treatment, defendants expressed a specific promise toaccomplish some definite result (Scalisi v New York Univ. Med. Ctr., 24 AD3d 145, 147[1st Dept 2005]). Defendants' alleged promises to make plaintiff look "gorgeous" areinsufficient.
Plaintiff has not shown that there had been a sale within the meaning of the UniformCommercial Code (UCC) so as to give rise to any implied warranties under section 2-315of the UCC. Indeed, the dental items plaintiff identified in her complaint are not "goods"within the meaning of section 2-315. Rather, they are items that were "incidental part[s]of the services rendered" by defendants in the course of plaintiff's dental treatment(see Osborn v Kelley, 61 AD2d 367, 369 [3d Dept 1978]).Concur—Friedman, J.P., Sweeny, Renwick, Freedman and Román, JJ.[Prior Case History: 2011 NY Slip Op 31804(U).]