| Mahoney v AMC Entertainment, Inc. |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 01242 [103 AD3d 855] |
| February 27, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| Michelle Mahoney, Appellant, v AMCEntertainment, Inc., et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Carroll McNulty & Kull LLC, New York, N.Y. (Catherine Pignataro of counsel), forrespondent.
In an action to recover damages for personal injuries, the plaintiff appeals from anorder of the Supreme Court, Kings County (Silber, J.), dated November 17, 2011, whichgranted that branch of the defendants' motion which was for summary judgmentdismissing the complaint.
Ordered that the order is reversed, on the law, with costs, and that branch of thedefendants' motion which was for summary judgment dismissing the complaint is denied.
A defendant who moves for summary judgment in a slip-and-fall case has the initialburden of making a prima facie showing that it neither created the hazardous conditionnor had actual or constructive notice of its existence for a sufficient length of time todiscover and remedy it (seeKnack v Red Lobster 286, N & D Rests., Inc., 98 AD3d 473 [2012]; Amendola v City of NewYork, 89 AD3d 775 [2011]; Alami v 215 E. 68th St., L.P., 88 AD3d 924, 924-925[2011]; Schiano v Mijul,Inc., 79 AD3d 726 [2010]; Walsh v Super Value, Inc., 76 AD3d 371, 375 [2010]; Gambino v City of New York,60 AD3d 627 [2009]). "To meet its initial burden on the issue of . . .constructive notice, the defendant must offer some evidence as to when the area inquestion was last cleaned or inspected relative to the time when the plaintiff fell" (Birnbaum v New York RacingAssn., Inc., 57 AD3d 598, 598-599 [2008]; see Mei Xiao Guo v Quong Big Realty Corp., 81 AD3d610, 611 [2011]). Mere reference to general cleaning practices, with no evidenceregarding any specific cleaning or inspection of the area in question, is insufficient toestablish a lack of constructive notice (see Goodyear v Putnam/Northern Westchester Bd. of Coop. Educ.Servs., 86 AD3d 551 [2011]; Schiano v Mijul, Inc., 79 AD3d at726-727; Farrell v Waldbaum's,Inc., 73 AD3d 846, 847 [2010]; Birnbaum v New York Racing Assn.,Inc., 57 AD3d at 598-599; cf. Perez v New York City Hous. Auth., 75 AD3d 629, 630[2010]).
Here, with respect to constructive notice, the defendants failed to meet their primafacie burden. At best, the deposition testimony of the defendants' employee, CornellRichard, established merely his general cleaning practices, as well as those of thedefendants' other employees, regarding the area around the concession stand where theplaintiff slipped and fell due to the presence of a puddle of liquid. He admitted he had noidea, specifically, when the last time [*2]on the date ofthe plaintiff's accident, he, or anyone else, had inspected the floor where the accidentoccurred. Contrary to the Supreme Court's determination, the evidence submitted by thedefendants did not establish that the puddle existed for such a short period of time thatthe defendants would not have been expected to discover and clean it up.
While a landowner has a duty to maintain its premises in a reasonably safe manner(see Basso v Miller, 40 NY2d 233 [1976]), it does not have a duty to protectagainst an open and obvious condition, which, as a matter of law, is not inherentlydangerous (see Cupo vKarfunkel, 1 AD3d 48 [2003]). Here, the defendants failed to meet their initialburden of establishing their entitlement to judgment as a matter of law on this theory,since the evidence submitted by the defendants did not establish, prima facie, that thecondition was open and obvious and not inherently dangerous (see Gordon v Pitney Bowes Mgt.Servs., Inc., 94 AD3d 813 [2012]; Clark v AMF Bowling Ctrs., Inc., 83 AD3d 761 [2011]; see also Klee v Cablevision Sys.Corp., 77 AD3d 794 [2010]; Villano v Strathmore Terrace Homeowners Assn., Inc., 76AD3d 1061 [2010]; Grgichv City of New York, 2 AD3d 680 [2003]).
Accordingly, that branch of the defendants' motion which was for summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint should have been denied. Eng, P.J., Rivera, Lott andMiller, JJ., concur.