| Matter of Schyberg v Peterson |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 02406 [105 AD3d 857] |
| April 10, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Robert Schyberg,Appellant, v Christine M. Peterson, Respondent. |
—[*1] Jessica Bacal, Katonah, N.Y., attorney for the children.
In a proceeding pursuant to Family Court Act article 6, the father appeals from anorder of the Family Court, Westchester County (Greenwald, J.), entered October 20,2011, which, without a hearing, denied his petition, in effect, inter alia, for sole physicalcustody of the subject children, and, sua sponte, in effect, inter alia, awarded solephysical custody of the subject children to the mother and certain visitation to him.
Ordered that the order is reversed, on the law, without costs or disbursements, andthe matter is remitted to the Family Court, Westchester County, for an evidentiaryhearing, to be held forthwith, on the issue of physical custody and visitation with respectto the subject children and for a determination of the present best interests of the childrenin accordance herewith; and it is further,
Ordered that pending the hearing and determination, the provisions of the orderentered October 20, 2011, regarding custody and visitation of the subject children, shallremain in effect.
The father commenced this proceeding, in effect, inter alia, for sole physical custodyof the subject children. The Family Court denied, without a hearing, the father's petitionand, sua sponte, in effect, inter alia, awarded sole physical custody of the subject childrento the mother and certain visitation to him.
"The paramount concern in any custody or visitation determination is the bestinterests of the child, under the totality of the circumstances" (Galanti v Kraus, 85 AD3d723, 724 [2011]; see Matter of Wilson v McGlinchey, 2 NY3d 375, 380-381[2004]). Generally an evidentiary hearing is necessary in determining issues of custody orvisitation (see Matter of Hom vZullo, 6 AD3d 536 [2004]). However, a hearing may not be necessary where"the court possesses adequate relevant information to enable it to make an informed andprovident determination as to the child[ren's] best interest" (id.; see Matter of New v Sharma,91 AD3d 652, 653 [2012]).
Here, the Family Court did not possess adequate relevant information to enable it tomake an informed and provident determination as to the children's best interest so as torender a hearing unnecessary. Indeed, the court was not involved when the parties agreedto the existing [*2]custody and parenting agreement, andonly became involved in this proceeding after the prior Family Court Judge in this matterretired. Furthermore, although the court had the recommendations of an expert before it,the recommendations of experts are but one factor to be considered (see Matter of Nikolic vIngrassia, 47 AD3d 819, 821 [2008]), and "are not determinative and do notusurp the judgment of the trial judge" (id. at 821; see Matter of Kozlowski vMangialino, 36 AD3d 916, 917 [2007]; Neuman v Neuman, 19 AD3d 383, 384 [2005]).Accordingly, the Family Court erred in denying the father's petition and, inter alia,awarding sole physical custody to the mother without first holding an evidentiary hearingon the issue of physical custody and visitation so that it could make an independentdetermination as to the best interests of the children on the basis of the evidencepresented at such a hearing (seeGoldstein v Goldstein, 68 AD3d 717, 720-721 [2009]; Matter of Gurewich vGurewich, 58 AD3d 628, 629 [2009]).
The father's remaining contentions either are not properly before this Court, as theyraise issues that were not decided in the order appealed from, or need not be reached inlight of our determination.
Accordingly, we remit the matter to the Family Court, Westchester County, for anevidentiary hearing, to be held forthwith, on the issue of physical custody and visitationwith respect to the subject children and for a determination of the present best interests ofthe children. In the interim and until further order of the Family Court, the provisions ofthe order entered October 20, 2011, regarding custody and visitation of the subjectchildren shall remain in effect. Mastro, J.P., Rivera, Hall and Miller, JJ., concur.