| Matter of Hwang v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State ofN.Y. |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 02429 [105 AD3d 1151] |
| April 11, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Wang Y. Hwang, Petitioner, v Tax AppealsTribunal of the State of New York et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Robert M. Goldfarb of counsel),for Commissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.
Lahtinen, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuantto Tax Law § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunalwhich sustained a sales and use tax assessment imposed under Tax Law article 28.
Petitioner owns a restaurant in the City of Rochester, Monroe County. In January2007, the Audit Division of the Department of Taxation and Finance notified petitionerthat it was going to conduct a sales tax audit for the period March 2004 to November2006. The Division found that the records maintained and produced by petitioner wereinadequate to perform the audit. Accordingly, it conducted a one-day indirect auditobservation test on September 15, 2007. Using information from that observation, theDivision determined that petitioner had significantly underreported cash sales. Inparticular, the auditors compared the percentage of cash sales (35.83) to that of creditcard sales (64.17) and, since it had a reliable record of credit card sales for the auditperiod (which it adjusted for tips), it used the percentages from the one-day indirect auditto estimate cash sales for the audit period. Based on this information, the Division issueda notice of determination in January 2008 assessing petitioner with an unpaid tax of$27,041.95, together with interest of $9,378.20 and a penalty of $7,211.79. Following a[*2]hearing, an Administrative Law Judge upheld thedetermination and, thereafter, respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal affirmed. Thisproceeding ensued with petitioner asserting that it had maintained adequate records and,thus, there was no reason for an indirect audit, the indirect method used was notreasonable, and no penalty should have been assessed.
Our review is limited. "If the Tribunal's determination is rationally based upon andsupported by substantial evidence, it must be confirmed, even if it is reasonably possibleto reach a different conclusion" (Matter of CS Integrated, LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of State ofN.Y., 19 AD3d 886, 889 [2005] [internal quotation marks and citationomitted]). Where a taxpayer maintains and produces records adequate for an audit, thoserecords must be utilized, as the Division cannot ignore the taxpayer's records (seeMatter of King Crab Rest. v Chu, 134 AD2d 51, 52-53 [1987]). However, we have"consistently held [that the] use of a test period to estimate sales tax is proper when thetaxpayer's records for the audit period are insufficient" (Matter of Vebol Edibles vState of N.Y. Tax Appeals Trib., 162 AD2d 765, 766 [1990], lv denied 77NY2d 803 [1991]).
The Division requested various information for its audit including, among otherthings, guest checks and cash register tapes. Lee Hwang, petitioner's wife andbookkeeper, testified that the cash register was used only for cash transactions. Further,the Division presented proof that, despite cash register tapes having, among otherdeficiencies, missing and incorrect dates, its auditors nonetheless entered guest checksinto a spreadsheet and attempted to reconcile register tapes and guest checks, but theywere unable to do so. Petitioner's accountant acknowledged that the guest checks couldnot be adequately tied into the register tapes. The guest checks also reflected deficienciesin that there were large gaps in the numbers on the checks, instances of smaller gaps inthe numbers within individual books of checks, days where the guest checks weremissing entirely, and undated guest checks. Petitioner's wife explained that guest checkbooks were not necessarily used in sequence (resulting in the large gaps) and that smallergaps could have resulted from voided checks and business customers sometimes keepingthe checks for their records. The Tribunal did not find credible the explanations for allthe gaps and missing records, and those gaps could not be adequately filled or explainedby using other available information.
Unlike Matter of King Crab Rest. v Chu (supra), upon whichpetitioner relies, this record reflects that the Division made ample efforts to attempt toconduct the audit based upon petitioner's records. Substantial evidence supports theTribunal's determination that it was not possible for the Division to independently verifypetitioner's taxable sales for the pertinent period from the records supplied to it bypetitioner. With regard to petitioner's challenge to the receipt into evidence at the hearingof the Division's spreadsheets, we note that a timely objection was not made and, in anyevent, strict rules of evidence do not apply (see e.g. Matter of Club Marakesh v TaxCommn. of State of N.Y., 151 AD2d 908, 910 [1989], lv denied 74 NY2d616 [1989]).
Where, as here, a taxpayer fails to maintain sufficient records, the Division mayresort to an indirect audit and the taxpayer challenging such an audit has the "burden ofestablishing by clear and convincing evidence that the audit method or tax assessment[was] erroneous" (Matter of Lombard v Commissioner of Taxation & Fin., 197AD2d 799, 800 [1993]; see Matter of Karay Rest. Corp. v Tax Appeals Trib.,274 AD2d 854, 856 [2000], lv denied 96 NY2d 702 [2001]). Although a longeraudit period might have produced a more accurate representation of petitioner's businessactivity, nonetheless petitioner failed to meet its heavy burden of establishing theunreasonableness or inaccuracy of the length used and method employed by the [*3]Division in its indirect audit under the circumstances(see Matter of Lombard v Commissioner of Taxation & Fin., 197 AD2d at799-800; Matter of Sarantopoulos v Tax Appeals Trib., 186 AD2d 878, 879[1992]; Matter of Club Marakesh v Tax Commn. of State of N.Y., 151 AD2d at910).
Petitioner, who had previously been indirectly audited under similar circumstances,failed to sustain his burden of establishing that the assessment of a penalty was improper(see Matter of S. H. B. Super Mkts. v Chu, 135 AD2d 1048, 1050-1051 [1987]).
Peters, P.J., Stein and Spain, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.