| Spielman v Mehraban |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 02565 [105 AD3d 943] |
| April 17, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| Jonathan Spielman et al.,Appellants-Respondents, v Arielle Mehraban et al., Respondents-Appellants, etal., Defendants. |
—[*1] Dorf & Nelson, LLP, Rye, N.Y. (Jonathan B. Nelson of counsel), forrespondents-appellants.
In an action, inter alia, for a judgment declaring that a right of first refusal containedin a certain deed is enforceable, the plaintiffs appeal from stated portions of an order ofthe Supreme Court, Nassau County (Asarch, J.), dated September 19, 2011, and thedefendants Arielle Mehraban and Kevin Lalezarian cross-appeal, as limited by their brief,from so much of the same order as denied their motion for summary judgment dismissingthe complaint insofar as asserted against them and, in effect, on their counterclaim for ajudgment declaring the subject right of first refusal invalid.
Ordered that the appeal is dismissed, without costs or disbursements; and it is further,
Ordered that the order is affirmed insofar as cross-appealed from, without costs ordisbursements.
The plaintiffs commenced this action to assert their right to purchase certain realproperty pursuant to a right of first refusal (hereinafter the covenant) contained in deedsin the chain of title of the subject property. The subject real property had been conveyedto the defendants Arielle Mehraban and Kevin Lalezarian (hereinafter together theMehraban defendants) by quitclaim deed in 2005. The Mehraban defendantscounterclaimed for a judgment declaring the covenant void or invalid. The Mehrabandefendants moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as assertedagainst them and, in effect, on their counterclaim for a judgment declaring the covenantinvalid. The Supreme Court denied the motion.
Although the plaintiffs did not move the Supreme Court for any relief, and althoughthe court denied the Mehraban defendants' motion for summary judgment, the plaintiffspurportedly appeal from that portion of the order which determined that the doctrines ofres judicata and collateral estoppel did not resolve the subject claims or bar thecounterclaims. "[A party] is not aggrieved by an order which does not grant relief [he orshe] did not request" (Schleckerv Yorktown Elec. & Light. Distribs., Inc., 94 AD3d 855 [2012] [internalquotation marks omitted]). "Merely because the order appealed from contains languageor reasoning that a party deems adverse to its interests does not 'furnish a basis forstanding to take an appeal' " (Castaldi v 39 Winfield Assoc., LLC, 22 [*2]AD3d 780, 781 [2005], quoting Pennsylvania Gen. Ins.Co. v Austin Powder Co., 68 NY2d 465, 472-473 [1986]). Here, the plaintiffs arenot aggrieved by so much of the order as, in denying the Mehraban defendants' motionfor summary judgment and reaching a result which was not adverse to the plaintiffs,determined that a prior judgment did not have res judicata or collateral estoppel effect onthe motion before it (seeCastaldi v 39 Winfield Assoc., LLC, 22 AD3d 780, 781 [2005]). Since theplaintiffs are not aggrieved by the portion of the order from which they appeal, theirappeal must be dismissed. Moreover, this Court declines the plaintiffs' request that itsearch the record and award summary judgment to the plaintiffs.
The Mehraban defendants appeal from so much of the order as denied their motionfor summary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against them and, ineffect, on their counterclaim for a judgment declaring the subject covenant invalid. TheSupreme Court properly denied the Mehraban defendants' motion, as they failed todemonstrate their entitlement to judgment as a matter of law. In support of their motion,they submitted, inter alia, both a 1998 decision and 1998 judgment in a prior litigationinvolving the same covenant, which judgment stated that "the [subject] Covenant is validand enforceable by . . . any subsequent owner of the Dominant Estateagainst . . . any subsequent owner of the Servient Estate." This evidence,rather than eliminating issues of fact, demonstrates that there is a triable issue of fact asto whether the doctrines of res judicata and collateral estoppel are applicable here (see Goldstein v MassachusettsMut. Life Ins. Co., 32 AD3d 821 [2006]). Moreover, the Mehraban defendantsfailed to satisfy their prima facie burden of establishing any other basis, as a matter oflaw, for summary judgment dismissing the complaint or, in effect, on their counterclaimfor a judgment declaring the subject covenant invalid. Therefore, summary judgment wasproperly denied. Dillon, J.P., Balkin, Austin and Sgroi, JJ., concur.
Motion by the appellants-respondents on an appeal and cross appeal from an order ofthe Supreme Court, Nassau County, dated September 19, 2011, inter alia, for this Courtto take judicial notice of certain material from an action entitled Rosenblum vLibow, which had been pending in the Supreme Court, Nassau County, under indexNo. 36662/95. By decision and order on motion of this Court dated August 10, 2012, thebranch of the motion which is for the Court to take judicial notice of certain materialfrom the action entitled Rosenblum v Libow was held in abeyance and referred tothe panel of Justices hearing the appeal for determination upon the argument orsubmission thereof.
Upon the papers filed in support of the motion and the papers filed in oppositionthereto, and upon the argument of the appeal, it is
Ordered that the branch of the motion which is for the Court to take judicial notice ofcertain material from the action entitled Rosenblum v Libow is denied. Dillon,J.P., Balkin, Austin and Sgroi, JJ., concur. [Prior Case History: 2011 NY Slip Op32534(U).]