| Ortiz v City of New York |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 03030 [105 AD3d 674] |
| April 30, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| William Ortiz, Respondent, v City of New York,Appellant. |
—[*1]
Cronin & Byczek, LLP, Lake Success (Linda M. Cronin of counsel), forrespondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Arthur F. Engoron, J.), entered February23, 2012, which denied defendant's motion to dismiss the complaint, reversed, on thelaw, without costs, and the motion granted. The Clerk is directed to enter judgmentaccordingly.
Plaintiff failed to sufficiently allege a cause of action under the State and CityHuman Rights Laws (see Executive Law § 296; Administrative Code ofthe City of New York § 8-107; cf. Vig v New York Hairspray Co., L.P., 67 AD3d 140 [1stDept 2009]). There is no dispute that because plaintiff was not reinstated as a policeofficer until after one year from his voluntary retirement, he was not entitled to receivereinstatement at his previous salary and seniority levels. Although he alleged that hisapplication for reinstatement, made within one year of his retirement, was not promptlyexpedited, he did not specifically allege that the application was intentionally delayed orthat racial discrimination was the reason for the failure to expedite the application(see e.g. McDowell v North Shore-Long Is. Jewish Health Sys., Inc., 788 F Supp2d 78, 81-83 [ED NY 2011]). Concur—Tom, J.P., Andrias and Saxe, JJ.
Abdus-Salaam and Gische, JJ., dissent in a memorandum by Abdus-Salaam, J., asfollows: I would affirm.
In this litigation by a Hispanic New York City police officer alleging discriminationbased upon national origin, the complaint includes allegations that after plaintiff retired,he timely sought reinstatement; that although he timely sought reinstatement within ayear of retirement he was reinstated without retaining his seniority and salary whilesimilarly situated Caucasian officers were reinstated with their seniority and salary; andthat these acts by the City of New York were in violation of his rights pursuant to theState and City Human Rights Laws (see Executive Law § 296;Administrative Code of the City of New York § 8-107). "On a CPLR 3211 motionto dismiss, the court will 'accept the facts as alleged in the complaint as true, accordplaintiff[ ] the benefit of every possible favorable inference, and determine only whetherthe facts as alleged fit within any cognizable legal theory' " (Nonnon v City of New York, 9NY3d 825, 827 [*2][2007]). Additionally,"employment discrimination cases are themselves generally reviewed under noticepleading standards" (Vig v NewYork Hairspray Co., L.P., 67 AD3d 140, 145 [1st Dept 2009]). In "[a]pplyingthese liberal pleading standards" (id. at 145), the motion court properly foundthat plaintiff has stated causes of action for employment discrimination under both theState and City Human Rights Laws.