| Desmangles v Woodside Mgt., Inc. |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 04692 [107 AD3d 551] |
| June 20, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Henry Desmangles, Appellant, v WoodsideManagement, Inc., Respondent. |
—[*1] Abrams, Fensterman, Fensterman, Eisman, Formato, Ferrara & Einiger, LLP, LakeSuccess (Keith J. Singer of counsel), for respondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Melvin L. Schweitzer, J.), entered August17, 2012, which granted defendant's motion to dismiss the first cause of action withoutprejudice, and the second, third, fourth and fifth causes of action with prejudice,unanimously modified, on the law, to grant the motion as to the first cause of action withprejudice, and otherwise affirmed, without costs. The Clerk is directed to enter judgmentdismissing the complaint.
Plaintiff is a taxi driver who leased a medallion from defendant. He alleges thatdefendant overcharged him on his weekly lease, which was subject to an $800 cap(see Rules of City of NY Taxi and Limousine Commn [TLC] [35 RCNY]§ 58-21 [c] [4] [ii]). He alleges that defendant imposed, and collected weekly,certain additional charges that are not permitted (see 35 RCNY 58-21 [c] [5]),over and above the $800 medallion lease fee that defendant was already collecting fromhim.
Plaintiff's fourth and fifth causes of action allege that the overcharges violated thelease cap rule (35 RCNY 58-21 [c] [4]) and a 5% credit card withholding surcharge rule(35 RCNY 58-21 [f] [3]). Upon review of the TLC's legislative scheme and detailedself-enforcement provisions, we conclude that plaintiff has no private right of action andtherefore cannot assert these causes of action (see Sheehy v Big Flats CommunityDay, 73 NY2d 629, 633-634 [1989]).
Plaintiff's first and second causes of action allege breach of contract; however, itappears that plaintiff couched his claims of TLC violations in terms of breach of contractto circumvent the absence of a private right of action. In any event, it is clear from theallegations in the complaint and the lease that plaintiff's breach of contract (first andsecond) causes of action are founded not upon defendant's failure to comply with theterms of the lease as written but upon the unenforceability of the lease insofar as itopenly violated the TLC's lease cap rule (see 35 RCNY 58-21 [a] [1]["Regardless of the terms of the lease, the Owner is responsible for complying with alllaws, rules and regulations governing Owners"]; see Boiadjian v New York City Taxi& Limousine Commn., 243 AD2d 355 [1st Dept 1997], lv denied 91 NY2d814 [1998]; Mystic Cab Corp. v New York City Taxi & Limousine Commn., 243AD2d 353 [1st Dept 1997], lv denied 91 NY2d 814 [1998]). With respect to theadditional charges collected improperly, there was no breach because those charges wereoutside the lease terms.[*2]
The existence of plaintiff's lease, a requirementunder TLC rules (see 35 RCNY 58-21 [h]), precludes his unjust enrichment(third) cause of action (seePappas v Tzolis, 20 NY3d 228, 234 [2012]).
We have considered plaintiff's remaining arguments and find them unavailing.Concur—Tom, J.P., Acosta, Saxe and Freedman, JJ.