| Illinois Natl. Ins. Co. v Zurich Am. Ins. Co. |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 04881 [107 AD3d 608] |
| June 27, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Illinois National Insurance Company,Respondent-Appellant, v Zurich American Insurance Company,Appellant-Respondent, et al., Defendants. |
—[*1] Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Brooklyn (Charmagne A. Padua of counsel), forrespondent-appellant.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Donna M. Mills, J.), entered January 20,2012, which granted plaintiff Illinois National Insurance Company's motion for summaryjudgment, denied defendant Zurich American Insurance Company's cross motion forsummary judgment, and declared that Zurich is obligated to defend and indemnifynonparty Schiavone Construction Co., Inc./Granite Halmar Construction Company Inc.(Schiavone) in an underlying personal injury action, and order, same court and Justice,entered April 23, 2012, which denied Zurich's motion for leave to renew the priormotions, unanimously affirmed, with costs.
Nonparty Schiavone is a defendant in an underlying personal injury action broughtby defendant Robert Boyd, an employee of one of Schiavone's subcontractors, defendantHayward Baker, Inc., who was injured when a drilling rig fell on him while he wasworking on a construction site. As part of the terms of the subcontract betweenSchiavone and Hayward Baker, Schiavone was to be named as an additional insuredunder the policy Hayward Baker obtained from defendant Zurich. Hayward Bakercomplied with this requirement.
After Boyd's injury, Schiavone received notice of his claim in a letter from Boyd'scounsel on March 29, 2007. The letter named only Boyd and accused Schiavone ofnegligence. Schiavone and its insurer, plaintiff Illinois National, undertook aninvestigation of the claim, eventually determining the Zurich was the proper insurer. OnJune 29, 2007, Illinois National demanded that Zurich defend and indemnify Schiavonein the underlying action. Zurich disclaimed coverage on the ground of late notice.
The motion court correctly determined that, under the standard "grouping ofcontacts" analysis, New York law, rather than Maryland law, applies in this case (seeZurich Ins. Co. v Shearson Lehman Hutton, 84 NY2d 309, 317 [1994] [internalquotation marks omitted]). Indeed, the subcontract between Hayward Baker andSchiavone involved construction services at a site located in New York, Schiavoneformed a joint venture in New York to perform those services, [*2]the accident and resulting litigation occurred in New York,Zurich asserts that it is a New York corporation with a home office in New York, IllinoisNational is licensed to do business in New York, and the demand letters and responseswere sent from the parties' New York offices (id. at 317-318).
Illinois National, in arguing that Maryland law applies, heavily relies on this Court'sdecision in CertainUnderwriters at Lloyd's, London v Foster Wheeler Corp. (36 AD3d 17 [1st Dept2006], affd 9 NY3d 928 [2007]). Foster Wheeler, however, is notapplicable to the facts of this case, as it involved asbestos claims that were spreadthroughout multiple jurisdictions in the United States (see 36 AD3d at 19). Here,Schiavone was added to the Zurich policy as an additional insured to cover a specificrisk, the risk arising from Hayward Baker's performance of its subcontract for work at aNew York site. While, in theory, the Zurich policy provides to Keller, Hayward Baker'sparent company, insurance covering risks in multiple states, it is clear that the partiesunderstood, in adding Schiavone as an additional insured, that the "principal location ofthe insured risk" was in New York, where the work took place (id. at 21-22).Accordingly, New York law should apply.
The motion court correctly declared that Zurich is required to defend and indemnifySchiavone. Schiavone's three-month delay in notifying Zurich of the underlying claim isexcusable, given that Schiavone needed to investigate the claim in order to determinebasic facts, such as where the claim occurred, the nature of the injury, and the insurerresponsible for covering the claim (see State of New York v American Natl. Fire Ins.Co., 193 AD2d 996, 998 [3d Dept 1993]).
The motion court properly denied Zurich's motion for leave to renew, as Zurichfailed to proffer a reasonable excuse for not presenting the allegedly new facts on theinitial motions (see CPLR 2221 [e]; Sullivan v Harnisch, 100 AD3d 513, 514 [1st Dept 2012]).
We have considered the appealing parties' remaining arguments for affirmative reliefand find them unavailing. Concur—Gonzalez, P.J., Renwick, DeGrasse andFeinman, JJ.