| Matter of Deboue v Fischer |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 05024 [108 AD3d 818] |
| July 3, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Eric Deboue, Petitioner, v BrianFischer, as Commissioner of Corrections and Community Supervision,Respondent. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Kate Nepveu of counsel), forrespondent.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of respondentwhich directed that petitioner be placed in administrative segregation.
While an inmate at Marcy Correctional Facility in Oneida County, petitioner wasserved with an administrative segregation recommendation based upon, among otherthings, his alleged aggressive and undermining behavior toward an Imam, a prisonchaplain, which created a negative atmosphere within the prison facility's Muslimcommunity. Following a hearing, it was determined that petitioner's continued presencein the general population would pose a threat to the safety and security of the facility.The determination was upheld on administrative appeal, prompting the commencementof this proceeding.
Initially, petitioner claims that he was improperly denied his right to call a witness atthe hearing who he claims was crucial to his defense of retaliation. Specifically,petitioner attempted to call an inmate witness who was allegedly present during aconversation between petitioner and the Imam, in which the Imam reportedly admittedinitiating the administrative segregation recommendation as a means of retaliationagainst petitioner. Although this witness agreed to testify, the Hearing Officer denied therequest for this witness on the basis that the conversation took place after the incidentthat is the subject of the administrative segregation recommendation. Under thecircumstances presented, we conclude that the testimony of this witness was notirrelevant and thus the request was improperly denied (see Matter of H'Shaka vFischer, 100 [*2]AD3d 1056, 1057 [2012];Matter of Blake v Coughlin, 189 AD2d 1016, 1017 [1993]; see also 7NYCRR 254.5 [a]). As such, the Hearing Officer's ruling constituted a violation ofpetitioner's conditional, regulatory right to call witnesses (see Matter of Rondon vSelsky, 274 AD2d 713, 714 [2000]).
Petitioner has, however, been released on parole supervision and is now under thesupervision of the Division of Parole (see Executive Law art 12-B), rather thanincarcerated and in the custody of the Department of Corrections and CommunitySupervision. While his release from administrative segregation and incarceration hasrendered moot his request for release from that segregation, it does not render moot hisrequest for expungement of this determination from his institutional record (seeMatter of Cross v Selsky, 271 AD2d 815, 816 [2000]). While ordinarily the remedyfor this nonconstitutional error is to remit for a new hearing,[FN*]even where petitioner has been removed from administrative segregation or been movedto a different facility (see Matter of H'Shaka v Fischer, 100 AD3d at 1057;Matter of Rondon v Selsky, 274 AD2d at 714), remittal for a rehearing is notfeasible here and, thus, we direct expungement of the determination from his institutionalrecord. The expungement of petitioner's records is without prejudice to respondentreconsidering the underlying facts in a de novo administrative segregation hearing shouldpetitioner be reincarcerated (see 7 NYCRR 301.4).
Peters, P.J., Lahtinen, Spain and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Adjudged that thedetermination is annulled, without costs, petition granted and respondent is directed toexpunge all references to this matter from petitioner's institutional record.
Footnote *: Remittal for a rehearingrather than expungement is generally permissible where, as here, substantial evidenceotherwise supports the determination (see Matter of Laureano v Kuhlmann, 75NY2d 141, 148-149 [1990]; Matter of Hillard v Coughlin, 187 AD2d 136,139-140 [1993], lv denied 82 NY2d 651 [1993]; compare Matter of Hartje vCoughlin, 70 NY2d 866 [1987]).