| Matter of Schaller v Town of New Paltz Zoning Bd. ofAppeals |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 05027 [108 AD3d 821] |
| July 3, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Robert W. Schaller et al., Appellants, vTown of New Paltz Zoning Board of Appeals et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] DiStasi, Moriello & Murphy, Highland (Joseph M. Moriello of counsel), for Town ofNew Paltz Zoning Board of Appeals, respondent. Jacobowitz & Gubits, LLP, Walden (George W. Lithco of counsel), for Town ofNew Paltz Planning Board, respondent. Graff Law LLC, Kingston (Wayne L. Graff of counsel), for New Paltz HospitalityLLC and another, respondents.
McCarthy, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Cahill, J.), enteredApril 3, 2012 in Ulster County, which dismissed petitioner's amended application, in aproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, to review, among other things, a determinationof respondent Town of New Paltz Planning Board granting conditional site plan approvalto respondent New Paltz Hospitality LLC.
In 2008, respondent New Paltz Hospitality LLC (hereinafter the applicant) applied torespondent Town of New Paltz Planning Board and respondent Town of New PaltzZoning Board of Appeals (hereinafter the ZBA) for land use and zoning varianceapprovals required to construct a hotel on a parcel of property owned by respondentUlster Rock, Inc., where an abandoned warehouse was located. The Planning Boarddeclared itself lead agency for environmental review under the State EnvironmentalQuality Review Act (see ECL art 8[*2][hereinafter SEQRA]) and, after determining that therewould be no adverse environmental impact, issued a conditional negative declaration.Thereafter, the ZBA conditionally approved the applicant's request for a six-foot heightvariance to provide for an aesthetically pleasing pitched roof, which would also permitthe incorporation of environmentally-friendly energy conservation features.
Petitioners, who are the owners and operators of a motel on land adjacent to theproposed project site, commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding challenging, amongother things, the Planning Board's issuance of the negative declaration and the ZBA'sgrant of the height variance. The Planning Board subsequently granted conditional siteplan approval,[FN*]and petitioners amended their petition to additionally challenge that approval. SupremeCourt dismissed the amended petition and this appeal ensued.
Initially, the Planning Board satisfied its obligations under SEQRA. " 'Judicialreview of an agency determination under SEQRA is limited to whether the [lead] agencyidentified the relevant areas of environmental concern, took a hard look at them, andmade a reasoned elaboration of the basis for its determination' " (Matter of Shop-Rite Supermarkets,Inc. v Planning Bd. of the Town of Wawarsing, 82 AD3d 1384, 1385 [2011],lv denied 17 NY3d 705 [2011], quoting Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town ofSoutheast, 9 NY3d 219, 231-232 [2007] [citations omitted]). "While judicialreview must be meaningful, the courts may not substitute their judgment for that of theagency for it is not their role to 'weigh the desirability of any action or [to] choose amongalternatives' " (Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d 561, 570 [1990], quoting Matter ofJackson v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 416 [1986]). The leadagency's determination will only be annulled if it is arbitrary, capricious or unsupportedby the evidence (see CPLR 7803 [3]; Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v PlanningBd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d at 232; Matter of Troy Sand & Gravel Co., Inc. v Town of Nassau, 82AD3d 1377, 1378 [2011]).
Here, a review of the record establishes that the Planning Board conducted atwo-year coordinated SEQRA review of the application which included, among otherthings, consultation with traffic engineers; review of the expanded long formenvironmental assessment form, visual assessment form, traffic studies and relatedsubmissions; compliance with the comprehensive master plan, an architectural study, awater system and sewage report, and drainage and storm water impact studies;consideration of input from various interested agencies, as well as public comments andconcerns received from public hearings and Planning Board meetings, and submissionsby interested parties. The Planning Board conditioned the negative declaration on theapplicant's compliance with various mitigating measures designed to minimize potentialenvironmental impacts, including constructing turn lanes, upgrading traffic signals,adding traffic signage, retention of certain trees for aesthetic purposes and constructionof a previously approved water line loop/extension for water supply and sewer purposes.The Planning Board specifically noted the various environmental impacts it considered inreaching its determination and it took a hard look before concluding that the projectwould not have a significant impact on [*3]theenvironment. The Planning Board also provided detailed reasoning and elaboration forits determination in the negative declaration with regard to the lack of significant impactson traffic and transportation, aesthetics resources, water and sewage resources,endangered species, historic resources, community character and services, and energyresources. Under these circumstances, the Planning Board complied with the proceduraland substantive requirements of SEQRA (see 6 NYCRR 617.7) and, accordingly,its determination is not arbitrary or capricious (see Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. vPlanning Bd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d at 232; Matter of Basha Kill Area Assn. vPlanning Bd. of Town of Mamakating, 46 AD3d 1309, 1312 [2007], lvdenied 10 NY3d 712 [2008]).
The ZBA's determination to grant the variance is also valid. In determining whetherto grant a variance, the local zoning board must " 'engage in a balancing test, weighingthe proposed benefit to [the applicant] against the possible detriment to the health, safetyand welfare of the community, as well as consider the five statutory factors enumeratedin Town Law § 267-b (3)' " (Matter of Mary T. Probst Family Trust v Zoning Bd. of Appeals ofTown of Horicon, 79 AD3d 1427, 1428 [2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 708[2011], quoting Matter ofFriends of the Shawangunks, Inc. v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Gardiner, 56AD3d 883, 886 [2008]). "Local zoning boards have broad discretion in consideringapplications for variances, and judicial review is limited to determinating whether theaction taken by the board was illegal, arbitrary or an abuse of discretion" (Matter ofIfrah v Utschig, 98 NY2d 304, 308 [2002] [citation omitted]; accord Matter of Russo v City ofAlbany Zoning Bd., 78 AD3d 1277, 1279 [2010]).
Here, the ZBA addressed the requisite statutory factors in approving the proposedsix-foot height variance after a review of various qualified recommendations, studies andpublic input. In balancing the benefits to the applicant against the possible detriment tothe community, the ZBA specifically referred to documentation in support of itsconclusions that, among other things, the variance was not substantial when compared tothe nearby buildings, would improve the physical and environmental condition andcharacter of the neighborhood, and was the minimum variance required to promoteenergy efficiency for both the applicant and the community. As substantial evidence inthe record supports the rationale for the ZBA's determination granting the variance, itwill not be disturbed (see Matterof Sarat v Town of Preble Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 93 AD3d 921, 922 [2012];Matter of Defreestville AreaNeighborhood Assn., Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 16 AD3d715, 724-725 [2005]).
With regard to the conditional site plan approval, petitioners' assertion that theproposed project constitutes an out-of-district user that is ineligible for receipt of sanitarysewer service from the Village of New Paltz is raised for the first time on appeal and,therefore, is unpreserved for our review (see Matter of Henry v Wetzler, 82NY2d 859, 862 [1993], cert denied 511 US 1126 [1994]; Matter of Mary T.Probst Family Trust v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Horicon, 79 AD3d at1427-1428).
Peters, P.J., Lahtinen and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,without costs.
Footnote *: The Planning Boardgranted site plan approval for the building design that included a six-foot heightvariance, as well as an alternative design eliminating the six-foot height variance in orderfor the applicant to proceed in the event that the ZBA approval was deemed invalid.