Schulz v State of N.Y. Exec.
2013 NY Slip Op 05039 [108 AD3d 856]
July 3, 2013
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 21, 2013


Robert L. Schulz, Appellant, et al.,Plaintiffs,
v
State of New York Executive et al.,Respondents.

—[*1]Robert L. Schulz, Queensbury, appellant pro se.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Victor Paladino of counsel), forrespondents.

Peters, P.J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (McNamara, J.), enteredMarch 14, 2013 in Albany County, which denied plaintiff Robert L. Schulz's motion for,among other things, a preliminary injunction.

On January 14, 2013, at the request of both the Senate and Assembly, GovernorAndrew Cuomo issued a message of necessity, setting forth facts which, in his opinion,necessitated an immediate vote by the Legislature on 2013 NY Senate-Assembly BillS2230, A2388, also known as the Secure Ammunition and Firearms Enforcement Act(hereinafter the SAFE Act). The SAFE Act was passed by the Senate later that day, bythe Assembly on January 15, 2013, and was signed into law by the Governor on January15, 2013 (see L 2013, ch 1).

Plaintiff Robert L. Schulz (hereinafter plaintiff) and numerous others subsequentlycommenced this declaratory judgment action seeking, among other things, to have theSAFE Act declared to be "repugnant" to the NY Constitution and, thus, null and void.Plaintiff then moved for, among other things, a preliminary injunction prohibiting the"taking [of] any action in furtherance of any provision of the [ ] SAFE Act." SupremeCourt denied plaintiff's motion and [*2]plaintiff nowappeals.

We affirm. "The party seeking a preliminary injunction must demonstrate aprobability of success on the merits, danger of irreparable injury in the absence of aninjunction and a balance of equities in its favor" (Nobu Next Door, LLC v Fine Arts Hous., Inc., 4 NY3d839, 840 [2005]; see Doe v Axelrod, 73 NY2d 748, 750 [1988]; UlsterHome Care v Vacco, 255 AD2d 73, 76 [1999]; see generally CPLR 6301).Notably, where, as here, the constitutionality of legislation is challenged, "the burdenbecomes more difficult as there exists an exceedingly strong presumption ofconstitutionality" (Matter of Schulz v State of New York, 217 AD2d 393, 396[1995]). Furthermore, with the decision to grant or deny a request for a preliminaryinjunction committed to the sound discretion of the trial court, our review is "limited towhether Supreme Court has either exceeded or abused its discretion as a matter of law"(id.; see Nobu Next Door, LLC v Fine Arts Hous., Inc., 4 NY3d at 840;Doe v Axelrod, 73 NY2d at 750).

Plaintiff's challenge to the SAFE Act rests largely on his assertion that theGovernor's message of necessity did not comport with NY Constitution, article III,§ 14. That provision requires that bills be "printed and upon the desks of themembers" of the Legislature at least three calendar legislative days before final passage(NY Const, art III, § 14; see Finger Lakes Racing Assn. v New York StateOff-Track Pari-Mutuel Betting Commn., 30 NY2d 207, 219 [1972], appealdismissed 409 US 1031 [1972]). This mandate may be circumvented if the Governor"certifie[s] . . . the facts which in his or her opinion necessitate animmediate vote" on the bill (NY Const, art III, § 14; see Finger Lakes RacingAssn. v New York State Off-Track Pari-Mutuel Betting Commn., 30 NY2d at 219).With regard to a judicial challenge to a message of necessity, so long as some facts arestated, a court may not intervene because "the sufficiency of the facts stated by theGovernor in a certificate of necessity is not subject to judicial review" (Maybee v State of New York,4 NY3d 415, 418 [2005]).

Here, the Governor's message of necessity states: "Some weapons are so dangerous,and some ammunition devices so lethal, that New York State must act without delay toprohibit their continued sale and possession in the State in order to protect its children,first responders and citizens as soon as possible. This bill, if enacted, would do so byimmediately banning the ownership, purchase and sale of assault weapons and largecapacity ammunition feeding devices, and eliminate them from commerce in New YorkState. For this reason, in addition to enacting a comprehensive package of measures thatfurther protects the public, immediate action by the Legislature is imperative. Becausethe bill has not been on your desks in final form for three calendar legislative days, theLeaders of your Honorable bodies have requested this message to permit immediateconsideration of this bill." [*3]As the Governor clearlymade some factual statements,[FN1]judicial review of the certificate of necessity is at an end and NY Constitution, article III,§ 14 provides no basis for this Court to intervene (see id. at 417;Norwick v Rockefeller, 70 Misc 2d 923, 931-934 [1972], affd without op40 AD2d 956 [1972], affd without op 33 NY2d 537 [1973]). The deference ofthe Judiciary to a Governor's views does not leave the legislative branch without aremedy. "[T]he Legislature has its own remedy for an inadequate certificate, since if itdoes not think the Governor's reasons are good ones, it is not required to act in fewerthan three days—or even to consider the bill at all" (Maybee v State of NewYork, 4 NY3d at 420). Accordingly, as plaintiff failed to demonstrate a likelihood ofsuccess on the merits of his claim, his motion for a preliminary injunction was properlydenied (see Doe v Axelrod, 73 NY2d at 751; Matter of McGrath v Town Bd.of Town of N. Greenbush, 254 AD2d 614, 619 [1998], lv denied 93 NY2d803 [1999]).[FN2]

To the extent that they are properly before us, plaintiff's other contentions have beenconsidered and found to be either academic or without merit.

Lahtinen, Stein and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed, withoutcosts.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: To the extent thatplaintiff asserts that the Governor's stated facts were not truthful, his assertion ispremised upon a misreading of the legislation. Although many of its provisions werephased in over various periods of time, the bill itself took effect immediately (seeL 2013, ch 1, § 58) and, more specifically, certain provisions of the SAFE Actconcerning assault weapons and large capacity ammunition feeding devices did go intoeffect immediately (see L 2013, ch 1, §§ 37, 38, 58; ch 57, §1, part FF, §§ 4, 5).

Footnote 2: Plaintiff's assertion thatthe SAFE Act's implications with respect to "a constitutionally protected fundamentalright" warrants a deviation from the normal standard of review is without merit. Plaintiffoffers no support for his apparent proposition that the method of enacting a law could besubject to varying degrees of judicial scrutiny based solely upon certain rights that maybe implicated by the enactments.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.