Matter of Aska v United Jewish Appeal
2013 NY Slip Op 05263 [108 AD3d 897]
July 11, 2013
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 21, 2013


In the Matter of the Claim of Fernella Aska,Respondent,
v
United Jewish Appeal et al., Appellants. Workers' CompenstaionBoard, Respondent.

—[*1]Michael Miliano, State Insurance Fund, New York City (David J. Schatten ofcounsel), for United Jewish Appeal and another, appellants.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Steven Segall of counsel),for Workers' Compensation Board, respondent.

Spain, J. Appeals (1) from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filedDecember 20, 2011, which ruled that the employer's workers' compensation carrier isdirected to pay claimant certain benefits plus penalties pursuant to Workers'Compensation Law § 25 (3) (f), and (2) from a decision of said Board, filed April23, 2012, which denied the carrier's request for reconsideration and/or full Board review.

In 2005, claimant was injured in a work-related accident and was awarded workers'compensation benefits. Claimant thereafter commenced a third-party action, which wassettled with the consent of the employer's workers' compensation carrier in 2008. InFebruary 2010, claimant and the employer entered into a stipulation that wasincorporated into a decision of the Workers' Compensation Law Judge providing thatclaimant suffered a 29% schedule loss of use of her left foot. The resulting total awardwas $16,886.17, with a $4,211.06 credit to the carrier for claimant's third-party recoveryand $3,298 reimbursement to the disability benefits carrier. The remainder, less counselfees, was to be paid by the carrier directly to claimant. The carrier failed to make timelypayment of the total due claimant and, after a hearing, the Workers' Compensation LawJudge determined that claimant was owed $7,977.11 plus a penalty in the amount of$1,595.42. Upon review, the Workers' Compensation Board affirmed. The carrier'ssubsequent request for reconsideration and/or full Board review was denied. Theemployer and carrier (hereinafter collectively referred to as the carrier) appeal from bothdecisions.

The carrier does not dispute the application of a 20% penalty based upon its latepayment of the award to claimant pursuant to Workers' Compensation Law § 25(3) (f) (see Matter of Malone vBernhardt Paving, 2 NY3d 756, 757 [2004]; Matter of Keser v New YorkState Elmira Psychiatric Ctr., 92 NY2d 100, 103 [1998]). However, the carriermaintains that it was entitled to take a credit against the award for prior payments ofbenefits. It is clear from the binding stipulation and Workers' Compensation Law Judgedecision of February 2010 that, after the credits and reimbursements specified, claimantwas to receive $9,377.11, less counsel fees of $1,400, for a total of $7,977.11 (see Matter of Mickens v New YorkCity Tr. Auth., 32 AD3d 1128, 1129 [2006]; 12 NYCRR 300.5 [b] [2]). Thereis nothing in the stipulation or, indeed, the record indicating that the partiesexpected—or had any reasonable grounds to expect—that claimant's awardwould be further reduced by the amount of these prior payments of compensation.Moreover, as the Board noted, the carrier was reimbursed for its prior payments ofcompensation from claimant's third-party recovery, satisfying the carrier's lien and"erasing these payments." Accordingly, we find that substantial evidence supports theBoard's decision (see Matter ofDeich v City of White Plains, 12 AD3d 928, 929 [2004]; Employer: YeshiaUniv., 2006 WL 3336904, *3, 2006 NY Wrk Comp LEXIS 9588, *6-7 [WCB No.0051 6928, Oct. 26, 2006]). Inasmuch as the underlying decision is supported bysubstantial evidence, we also conclude that the Board's denial of the request forreconsideration and/or full Board review was not arbitrary and capricious or otherwise anabuse of discretion (see Matterof Washburn v Bob Hooey Constr. Co., 39 AD3d 956, 958 [2007]; Matter of Cagle v Judge MotorCorp., 31 AD3d 1016, 1018 [2006], lv dismissed 7 NY3d 922 [2006]).

Rose, J.P., Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions are affirmed,without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.