| People v Coger |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 05423 [108 AD3d 1234] |
| July 19, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| The People of the State of New York, Respondent, vBennie Coger, Appellant. |
—[*1] Joseph V. Cardone, District Attorney, Albion (Katherine Bogan of counsel), forrespondent.
Appeal from an order of the Orleans County Court (James P. Punch, J.), entered June28, 2012. The order determined that defendant is a level three risk pursuant to the SexOffender Registration Act.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously modified on thelaw by determining that defendant is a level two risk pursuant to the Sex OffenderRegistration Act and as modified the order is affirmed without costs.
Memorandum: Defendant appeals from an order determining that he is a level threerisk pursuant to the Sex Offender Registration Act ([SORA] Correction Law §168 et seq.). We agree with defendant that the People failed to prove by therequisite clear and convincing evidence that he had a history of alcohol and drug abuse,i.e., risk factor 11 on the risk assessment instrument (RAI) (see generally §168-n [3]; People v Mingo,12 NY3d 563, 571 [2009]). In the case summary presented by the People at theSORA hearing, the Board of Examiners of Sex Offenders (Board) indicated thatdefendant was assessed with 15 points on the RAI for a history of alcohol and drug abusebecause "Probation identified [defendant's] continued drug and alcohol use asproblematic, and he refused to attend treatment for th[at] problem." The presentenceinvestigation report, upon which the Board relied for the 15-point assessment, statedmerely that "[i]ssues identified by Probation included continued drug and alcohol use"and that defendant refused substance abuse treatment. There is, however, no evidencethat defendant was ever screened for substance abuse issues (cf. People v Madera, 100AD3d 1111, 1112 [2012]; People v Faul, 81 AD3d 1246, 1247 [2011]), "only verylimited information about his alleged prior history of drug and alcohol abuse" (People v Mabee, 69 AD3d820, 820 [2010], lv denied 15 NY3d 703 [2010]), and no information aboutwhat treatment was recommended or why treatment was recommended (seeMadera, 100 AD3d at 1112; Faul, 81 AD3d at 1247). Under thesecircumstances, the case summary alone is insufficient "to satisfy the People's burden ofestablishing that risk factor by clear and convincing evidence" (Madera, 100AD3d at 1112; see Faul, 81 AD3d at 1247-1248; Mabee, 69 AD3d at820; see also People vJudson, 50 AD3d 1242, 1243 [2008]).
Further, defendant's prior convictions for criminal possession and sale of marihuanaand criminal possession of a controlled substance in the seventh degree do not constituteclear and [*2]convincing evidence that defendant useddrugs, let alone that he had a history of abusing them (see Madera, 100 AD3d at1112; People v Irizarry, 36AD3d 473, 473 [2007]; People v Collazo, 7 AD3d 595, 596 [2004]; cf. People v Abrams, 76 AD3d1058, 1058-1059 [2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 703 [2011]; People v Vaughn, 26 AD3d776, 777 [2006]). During the presentence investigation, defendant never admitted tousing drugs or alcohol, and he denied abusing any substances at the SORA hearing (cf. People v Zimmerman, 101AD3d 1677, 1678 [2012]; People v Mundo, 98 AD3d 1292, 1293 [2012], lvdenied 20 NY3d 855 [2013]; People v Urbanski, 74 AD3d 1882, 1883 [2010], lvdenied 15 NY3d 707 [2010]). Defendant's admission that he was intoxicated duringa previous incident, which led to a rape charge that was subsequently dismissed, isinsufficient to establish that his sexual misconduct can "be characterized by repetitiveand compulsive behavior[ ] associated with drugs or alcohol" (Correction Law §168-l [5] [a] [ii]), especially because defendant does not have any other history ofintoxication with respect to his sexual offenses, including the instant offenses (see People v Palmer, 20 NY3d373, 378-379 [2013]; People v Vasquez, 49 AD3d 1282, 1283 [2008]).Consequently, as noted, the People failed to meet their burden of establishing by clearand convincing evidence that defendant had a history of alcohol or drug abuse (seePalmer, 20 NY3d at 378-380; Faul, 81 AD3d at 1247-1248). We thusconclude that County Court erred in assessing 15 points on the RAI for risk factor 11 andthat defendant's score on the RAI must be reduced from 110 to 95, rendering him apresumptive level two risk. We therefore modify the order accordingly.Present—Smith, J.P., Fahey, Peradotto, Carni and Lindley, JJ.