| Matter of Nahum v Mansour |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 05634 [109 AD3d 548] |
| August 14, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Moshe Nahum et al.,Respondents, v Eliezer Mansour, Appellant. |
—[*1]
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 75 to confirm an arbitration award, EliezerMansour appeals from an order of the Supreme Court, Kings County (Sweeney, J.), datedOctober 3, 2012, which granted the petitioners' motion to vacate a prior order of the samecourt dated January 18, 2012, which, upon their failure to appear at a scheduled courtconference, denied their petition to confirm the arbitration award.
Ordered that the order dated October 3, 2012, is reversed, on the law, with costs, andthe petitioners' motion to vacate the order dated January 18, 2012, is denied.
Eliezer Mansour (hereinafter the appellant) contracted with the petitioners forrenovation work on his property. Thereafter, disputes arose between the partiesregarding, inter alia, the quality of the work that had been performed. In an agreementdated February 21, 2010, the parties agreed to submit their disputes to arbitration by arabbinical court. On June 15, 2010, the rabbinical court decided in favor of thepetitioners, and awarded them the sum of $77,800, to be paid by the appellant ininstallments. The appellant allegedly failed to tender any payment, and approximately 13months later, in July 2011, the petitioners commenced this proceeding in the SupremeCourt to confirm the award. The appellant opposed the petition, asserting that theproceeding was time-barred because it had not been commenced within one year after theaward had been issued.
After a number of adjournments, the matter was scheduled for a conference onJanuary 18, 2012; however, the petitioners failed to appear. On the same date, the courtissued an order which stated: "motion to confirm arbitration award is denied; noappearance by movant on the calendar call." In April 2012, the petitioners moved tovacate the January 18, 2012, order, asserting that there was a reasonable excuse for theirnonappearance on that date. In the order appealed from, dated October 3, 2012, theSupreme Court granted the petitioners' motion to vacate the prior order.
To vacate their default in appearing at the scheduled court conference, the petitionerswere required to demonstrate both a reasonable excuse for the failure to appear and apotentially meritorious cause of action (see CPLR 5015 [a] [1]; McClaren v Bell Atl., 30AD3d 569 [2006]; Rubenbauer v Mekelburg, 22 AD3d 826 [2005]; see also Pimento v Rojas, 94AD3d 844 [2012]; Abdul vHirschfield, 71 AD3d 707 [2010]). Here, the Supreme Court providentlyexercised its discretion in determining that the [*2]petitioners' "law office failure" explanation for theirnonappearance constituted a reasonable excuse (see CPLR 2005; Hageman v Home Depot U.S.A.,Inc., 25 AD3d 760 [2006]; Ruppell v Hair Plus Beauty, 288 AD2d 205[2001]; J. Donovan Assoc. v Jacoby & Meyers Law Offs., 256 AD2d 553[1998]).
However, the appellant correctly argues that the proceeding to confirm the arbitrationaward was untimely since it was commenced more than one year after the petitioners hadbeen notified of the award (see CPLR 7510; Elliot v Green Bus Lines, 58NY2d 76, 78 [1983]; Matter ofSalamon v Friedman, 11 AD3d 700, 700 [2004]; see also Matter ofSassower v Greenspan, Kanarek, Jaffe & Funk, 121 AD2d 549 [1986]; cf. Matterof Warner-Chappell Music [Aberbach de Mexico], 224 AD2d 301 [1996]). Undersuch circumstances, the petitioners failed to meet their burden of demonstrating apotentially meritorious cause of action (see Faga v Harrison Cent. School Dist., 40 AD3d 690[2007]; East Is. Assn. v Carbone, 150 AD2d 422, 423 [1989]). Accordingly, theSupreme Court should have denied the motion (see Brownfield v Ferris, 49 AD3d 790 [2008]). Rivera,J.P., Leventhal, Sgroi and Cohen, JJ., concur.