Matter of Mannarino v Goodbee
2013 NY Slip Op 05653 [109 AD3d 683]
August 15, 2013
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 25, 2013


In the Matter of Scott A. Mannarino, Respondent, v ReginaGoodbee, Respondent, and Albany County Board of Elections,Appellant.

—[*1]Thomas Marcelle, County Attorney, Albany (D. Steve Rahmas of counsel), forappellant.

John E. Sweeney, Latham, for Scott A. Mannarino, respondent.

Per Curiam. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Connolly, J.), enteredAugust 6, 2013 in Albany County, which granted petitioner's application, in a proceedingpursuant to Election Law § 16-102, to declare valid the designating petitionnaming petitioner as the Democratic Party candidate for the public office of Member ofthe City of Albany Common Council from the First Ward in the September 10, 2013primary election.

Petitioner filed a designating petition with respondent Albany County Board ofElections seeking the nomination as the Democratic Party candidate for the office ofMember of the City of Albany Common Council from the First Ward in the September10, 2013 primary election. Respondent Regina Goodbee filed general objections andspecifications challenging specific sheets of the petition and seeking to invalidatenumerous signatures contained therein. With the exception of one sheet of the petition,the Board sustained the objections and invalidated a number of the signatures, leavingpetitioner with an insufficient number of signatures for the nomination. Petitioner thencommenced this proceeding pursuant to Election [*2]Law§ 16-102 to validate the designating petition. Following a hearing on the specificchallenges to the petition, Supreme Court found that 138 of the signatures on thechallenged sheets of the petition were valid and that this number, together with the 83signatures that the parties had stipulated were valid, totaled 221 and exceeded the 145signatures needed. Accordingly, the court granted petitioner's application and validatedthe designating petition. This appeal by the Board ensued.[FN1]

The objections at the crux of this appeal relate to the description of the politicaloffice being sought, the identification of the political party to which the political officerelates and the spelling of petitioner's name on various sheets of the designating petition.Addressing these issues in turn, "Election Law § 6-132 (1) requires that each sheetof the designating petition state the public office or party position sought by thecandidate" (Matter of Dunlea v New York State Bd. of Elections, 275 AD2d 589,590 [2000]; see Matter of Hicksv Walsh, 76 AD3d 773, 774 [2010]). Upon our review of the sheets of thedesignating petition at issue,[FN2]we find no merit to the claim that the title of the office is incomprehensible or otherwiseinadequately set forth. The majority of the challenged sheets adequately describe the titleof the office as either "Member Common Council 1 Ward City of Albany," "MemberCommon Council Ward 1 City of Albany," "Member of Common Council 1 Ward Cityof Albany NY" or "Member Common Council 1 Ward City of Albany NY."Furthermore, although certain sheets describe the office as "Council, Council," theycontain other necessary identifying information so as to avoid confusion. In short, eachof the challenged descriptions is " 'sufficiently informative . . . so as topreclude any reasonable probability of confusing or deceiving the signers, voters orboard of elections' " (Matter of Dipple v Devine, 218 AD2d 918, 918-919[1995], lv denied 86 NY2d 704 [1995], quoting Matter of Donnelly vMcNab, 83 AD2d 896 [1981], lv denied 54 NY2d 603 [1981]).

Turning to the description of the political party, the term "Democratic" appears onvarious sheets of the petition as "Demoratic," "Demotatic" and "Demacatic." These minormisspellings, however, would not tend to confuse the signatories as to the political partyinvolved and nothing in the record indicates an intent to do so (see Matter of Cohn vSuffolk County Bd. of Elections, 109 AD3d 538, 538 [2013]; see generallyMatter of Ferris v Sadowski, 45 NY2d 815, 817 [1978]). Similarly, althoughpetitioner's last name is spelled on one sheet of the petition as "Mannaurino" and onanother as "Mannano," there has been no showing of any intention to mislead or confuse,nor is there any evidence that the inaccuracy would or did tend to mislead signatories asto the identity of the candidate (see Matter of Harfmann v Sachs, 138 AD2d 551,551 [1988], lv denied 71 NY2d 803 [1988]; see also Matter of Militzok vWeintraub, 29 NY2d 658, 659 [1971], affg on op below 37 AD2d 774[1971]; Matter of Strasser v Eisenberg, 307 AD2d 1053, 1054 [2003],affd 100 NY2d 590[*3][2003]). As for thoseobjections predicated on petitioner's name being incomprehensible, they are simply notsubstantiated by the record.

In view of the foregoing, Supreme Court properly concluded that, with the exceptionof the signatures contained on the sheet of the designating petition with the missing wardnumber (see n 2, supra), the remaining 138 signatures should be counted,bringing the total to 221, which is substantially more than the 145 needed.Notwithstanding the Board's claim to the contrary, petitioner met his burden ofdemonstrating that his designating petition should be validated under the circumstancespresented here (compare Matter of Mielnicki v New York State Bd. of Elections,224 AD2d 819, 820 [1996], lv denied 87 NY2d 809 [1996]; Matter ofGoldstein v Carlsen, 59 AD2d 642, 643 [1977], affd 42 NY2d 993 [1977]).We have considered the Board's remaining contentions and find them to be unavailing.

Peters, P.J., McCarthy, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the order isaffirmed, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: Contrary to petitioner'scontention, Election Law § 16-102 has no bearing on the Board's ability to bringthis appeal, as that statute sets forth those individuals who can initiate aproceeding to challenge the nomination or designation of any candidate for anypublic office or party position.

Footnote 2: Although SupremeCourt invalidated the signatures appearing on one sheet of the petition in which the wardnumber is missing, the adequacy of that description is not at issue on this appeal.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.