Matter of Huszar v Bayview Park Props., LLC
2013 NY Slip Op 05906 [109 AD3d 922]
September 18, 2013
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, October 30, 2013


In the Matter of Thomas Huszar et al.,Respondents,
v
Bayview Park Properties, LLC, et al.,Appellants.

—[*1]Forchelli, Curto, Deegan, Schwartz, Mineo & Terrana, LLP, Uniondale, N.Y.(Danielle Tricolla, Peter R. Mineo, and Eli Elbaum of counsel), for appellants BayviewPark Properties, LLC, and Scott Seeman.

John B. Riordan, Town Attorney, Manhasset, N.Y. (Simone M. Freeman of counsel),for appellants David Mammina, Donal McCarthy, Paul Aloe, Anna Kaplan, and LeslieFrancis.

Westerman Ball Ederer Miller & Sharfstein, LLP, Uniondale, N.Y. (RichardGabriele of counsel), for respondents.

In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review two determinations of theBoard of Zoning Appeals of the Town of North Hempstead, both dated January 12,2011, which, after a hearing, granted the applications of Scott Seeman, on behalf ofBayview Park Properties, LLC, for certain area variances, Bayview Park Properties,LLC, and Scott Seeman appeal, and David Mammina, Donal McCarthy, Paul Aloe, AnnaKaplan, and Leslie Francis separately appeal, as limited by their respective briefs, fromso much of an order and judgment (one paper) of the Supreme Court, Nassau County(DeStefano, J.), entered February 6, 2012, as granted the amended petition and annulledthe determinations.

Ordered that the order and judgment is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law,with one bill of costs to the appellants appearing separately and filing separate briefs, thedeterminations are confirmed, the amended petition is denied, and the proceeding isdismissed on the merits.

The subject premises are owned by Bayview Park Properties, LLC (hereinafterBayview). The premises consist of two tax lots, approximately equal in size and eachwith 50-foot frontage along Bayview Avenue in Port Washington. One lot is vacant,while the other lot is improved with a single-family house. The premises are locatedentirely within the Town of North Hempstead's Residence C District, which, forsingle-family homes, requires a minimum lot width of the average lot width of existinglots within 200 feet on each side of the lot within the same blockfront, or 40 feet,whichever is greater (see North Hempstead Town Code § 70-47.1 [A],[D]).

Scott Seeman is a member of Bayview. On behalf of Bayview, Seeman submitted[*2]two building permit applications to the Town'sDepartment of Building, Safety Inspection, and Enforcement (hereinafter the buildingdepartment), seeking to construct a new house on the vacant lot and maintain the existinghouse on the other lot with the removal of a side porch. The applications listed Bayviewas the owner of the premises and Seeman as the applicant on behalf of Bayview, andwere accompanied by owner's affirmations, architectural plans, a survey, and apartitioning map, each of which referenced Bayview. The building department issued anotice of disapproval, stating that the average lot width within 200 feet of the premiseswas 68.69 feet.

Seeman then applied to the Board of Zoning Appeals of the Town of NorthHempstead (hereinafter the Board) for two area variances. After a public hearing, theBoard issued two determinations granting the requested variances, concluding that thebenefit to the applicant in granting the variances outweighed the detriment to thecommunity.

The petitioners commenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to reviewthe Board's determinations. The Supreme Court granted the amended petition andannulled the determinations, concluding, inter alia, that Seeman had submitted thevariance applications in his individual capacity, and that, because Seeman was notpersonally aggrieved by the building department's notice of disapproval, the Boardlacked jurisdiction over Seeman's variance applications.

The Supreme Court erred in determining that the applications to the Board weremade in Seeman's individual capacity, and, thus, that the Board did not have jurisdictionto grant the requested variances. A duly authorized agent of the owner may submit anapplication to the Board on behalf of the owner, and in such case, the Board hasjurisdiction over the application (see Matter of Hickox v Griffin, 274 App Div792 [1948], revd on other grounds 298 NY 365 [1949]; see generally Matterof Madonia v Board of Zoning Appeals of Inc. Vil. of Lindenhurst, 300 AD2d 588,589 [2002]; Matter of Hoerner v Tormey, 24 AD2d 597 [1965]).

Here, Seeman submitted applications to the building department for building permitsfor the two lots on behalf of Bayview, which was listed as the owner of the lots. Eachapplication was accompanied by an owner's affirmation form which reflected thatBayview was the owner of the property, and that Seeman was Bayview's agent. Theapplications were also accompanied by two sets of architectural plans stating "BayviewPark Properties" in large letters on them, and a survey of the premises and a partitioningmap certified only to Bayview.

All of these documents were before the Board, and the Board was clearly aware thatthe owner of the property was Bayview, and that Seeman was a member of Bayviewacting on its behalf, as reiterated by counsel at the beginning of the hearing. Accordingly,the evidence before the Board established that, in applying for the variances, Seeman wasacting as an agent for Bayview (see Town Law § 267-a [4]; LimitedLiability Company Law § 412 [a]; Matter of Hickox v Griffin, 274 AppDiv at 792; cf. Matter of Madonia v Board of Zoning Appeals of Inc. Vil. ofLindenhurst, 300 AD2d at 589; Matter of Reiss v Keator, 150 AD2d 939,941 [1989]; Matter of Hoerner v Tormey, 24 AD2d at 597).

As to the merits of the applications, "[l]ocal zoning boards are vested with broaddiscretion in considering applications for area variances, and '[c]ourts may set aside azoning board determination only where the record reveals that the board acted illegally orarbitrarily, or abused its discretion, or that it merely succumbed to generalizedcommunity pressure' " (Matterof Roberts v Wright, 70 AD3d 1041, 1042 [2010], quoting Matter of Pecoraro v Board ofAppeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 608, 613 [2004]). A variancedetermination of a zoning board should be sustained if it has a rational basis and is notarbitrary and capricious (seeMatter of Gebbie v Mammina, 13 NY3d 728 [2009]; Matter of Sasso vOsgood, 86 NY2d 374, 384-386 [1995]).

Here, the Board properly balanced the requisite statutory factors, and itsdetermination that the benefit to the applicant of the requested variances outweighed thedetriment to the health, safety, and welfare of the neighborhood or community had arational basis and was not arbitrary and capricious (see Town Law § 267-b[3] [b]; Matter of Sasso v Osgood, 86 NY2d at 385-386; Matter [*3]of Riklis v Board of Zoning Appeals of Town ofHempstead, 243 AD2d 482 [1997]). Among other things, the Board found that,despite a few wide lots in the vicinity of the premises, the majority of lots in theuninterrupted two-block segment of Bayview Avenue in which the subject premises werelocated had a width of 50 feet or less, and, thus, that the variances would not produce anundesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearbyproperties. Accordingly, the Supreme Court should have denied the amended petitionand dismissed the proceeding.

We note that the prior determinations of the Board relied upon by the petitionerswere not considered in the determination of this appeal, as they are dehors theadministrative record (see Matter of Yarbough v Franco, 95 NY2d 342, 347[2000]; Matter of Montalbano v Silva, 204 AD2d 457 [1994]). Mastro, J.P.,Skelos, Leventhal and Chambers, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.