| Matter of Ward v City of New York |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 07569 [111 AD3d 498] |
| November 14, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| In the Matter of Elaine D. Ward, Petitioner, v Cityof New York et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Michael A. Cardozo, Corporation Counsel, New York (Drake A. Colley of counsel),for respondents.
In a proceeding brought pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court byorder of the Supreme Court, New York County [Donna M. Mills, J.], entered on or aboutMarch 1, 2012), seeking to annul a determination of respondent the New York CityDepartment of Buildings (DOB), dated September 13, 2011, which, after a hearing,revoked petitioner's master plumbing license upon a finding that she engaged in conductthat violated the New York City Building Code, the petition is unanimously granted inpart, to the extent of annulling the penalty of license revocation, and remanding thematter to the agency for imposition of a lesser penalty, and the determination otherwiseconfirmed, without costs.
Substantial evidence supports respondent's determination that petitioner violatedsection 26-142 of the Administrative Code of the City of New York, also known as the1968 Building Code, since renumbered as section 28-408.1 of the Administrative Codeof the City of New York, when she applied for a plumbing permit for work at a property,knowing that the owner had hired her to supervise his own worker, rather than one underher direct supervision or employ as required under the Code (see Matter of Purdy vKreisberg, 47 NY2d 354, 358 [1979]; CPLR 7803 [4]). There is no merit topetitioner's contention that DOB's failure to establish exactly which portion of the workwas performed by the owner's worker as opposed to the superseding licensed masterplumber, whose subsequent permit application indicated that he took full responsibilityfor the entire project, meant that DOB failed to establish that the worker impermissiblyperformed work under petitioner's permit. Rather, the administrative law judgespecifically relied upon petitioner's admissions during her sworn interviews with DOB'sinvestigators that she took the job and obtained the permit knowing that the ownerinsisted on using his own worker, and that she supervised his work on the project untilshe was fired for telling the owner that the work was not up to code and would requirecorrective measures by her company's employees.
However, we find that the penalty of revocation was excessive upon considering thefollowing factors: the license is petitioner's sole means of livelihood; this was the onlyinstance of misconduct in an otherwise unblemished history as a licensed master plumbersince 2001; there was no resultant harm to the public or the agency; and petitionerseemingly acknowledged the potential for harm when she informed the owner that hisworker's performance was [*2]inadequate and proposedthat her workers correct the violations (see Matter of Pell v Board of Educ. of UnionFree School Dist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck, Westchester County,34 NY2d 222, 234-235 [1974]; cf. Matter of Maggiore v Department of Bldgs. ofCity of N.Y., 294 AD2d 304 [1st Dept 2002]). We note that the record demonstratedthat DOB's precedent indicates that in several other instances where licensees havecommitted similar acts of misconduct by performing work prohibited by the Code and/orsubmitting false reports or documents to DOB, which potentially placed the public atgreater risk of harm than the misconduct at issue here, the agency imposed far less severepenalties. Concur—Tom, J.P., Mazzarelli, Freedman, Richter and Feinman, JJ.