| Matter of County of Chautauqua v Elderkin |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 07613 [111 AD3d 1406] |
| November 15, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| In the Matter of the Foreclosure of Tax Liens byProceeding in Rem Pursuant to Article 11, Title 3, of the Real Property Tax Law byCounty of Chautauqua, Respondent, v Merle J. Elderkin,Appellant. |
—[*1] Stephen M. Abdella, County Attorney, Mayville (Kurt D. Gustafson of counsel), forpetitioner-respondent.
Appeal from an order of the Chautauqua County Court (Stephen W. Cass, A.J.),entered May 30, 2012 in a proceeding pursuant to RPTL article 11. The order confirmedthe report of the Referee, dated January 12, 2012.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: In 2008, petitioner commenced an in rem proceeding to foreclose taxliens against, inter alia, 23 parcels purportedly owned by respondent (see RPTL1120). Respondent filed an answer alleging deficiencies in the foreclosure proceeding,and County Court granted petitioner's request to sever those parcels from the proceedingin order to address the merits of respondent's allegations. Petitioner thereaftermoved for summary judgment in the severed proceeding with respect to respondent'sparcels and, before the motion was heard, respondent commenced a bankruptcyproceeding. The Bankruptcy Court granted petitioner's motion seeking to modify theautomatic stay resulting from the bankruptcy proceeding and ordered that the foreclosureproceeding could "proceed to the extent of considering the merits of [petitioner's]pending motion for summary judgment in the [foreclosure proceeding], and determiningthe amount of the delinquent property tax liabilities as they pertain to the [p]roperties."Petitioner thereafter withdrew its motion for summary judgment and, upon the consent ofthe parties, the matter was referred to a referee, who conducted a hearing (seeRPTL 1130 [2]). The Referee concluded that respondent is the owner of the parcels,that certain amounts paid by respondent were properly credited to respondent's taxliability, and that petitioner's witnesses had established the amount of tax liability thathad accrued on respondent's parcels through January 2011. Respondent moved pursuantto CPLR 4403 for an order rejecting the Referee's report. The court instead grantedpetitioner's request to confirm the report with respect to the total amount of respondent'stax liability, and respondent now appeals.[*2]
Although we affirm the order confirming theReferee's report, our reasoning differs from that of the court. The automatic stay wasmodified to permit petitioner to proceed with its motion for summary judgment, whichsought title to respondent's parcels (see RPTL 1136 [2] [a]; [3]; see generallyAnderson v Pease, 284 AD2d 871, 872-873 [2001]). Because respondent contested,inter alia, whether taxes were paid, we conclude that the court properly ordered ahearing. We further conclude that the Referee properly rejected respondent's assertionsthat petitioner failed to prove that respondent was the owner of the parcels and thatpetitioner failed to establish that credits had been applied to reduce respondent's total taxliability. Moreover, inasmuch as petitioner may be obligated to accept partial payments oftaxes for properties affected by the bankruptcy proceeding (see RPTL 1140 [3]),or may be required to cancel tax liens (see RPTL 1140 [4]), the Referee properlyconsidered the total amount of respondent's tax liability, and not only that portion thathad accrued prior to the commencement of the in rem proceeding.Present—Scudder, P.J., Fahey, Peradotto, Lindley and Valentino, JJ.