Matter of Lebraun H. (Brenda H.)
2013 NY Slip Op 07639 [111 AD3d 1439]
November 15, 2013
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 25, 2013


In the Matter of Lebraun H., an Infant. Erie CountyDepartment of Social Services, Respondent; Brenda H., Appellant. In the Matter ofLinda C., Respondent,
v
Brenda H., Appellant. In the Matter of Brenda H.,Appellant, v Linda C., Respondent. (Appeal No. 1.)

—[*1]David J. Pajak, Alden, for respondent-appellant and petitioner-appellant.

Joseph T. Jarzembek, Buffalo, for petitioner-respondent.

Timothy J. Hennessy, Williamsville, for petitioner-respondent andrespondent-respondent.

Ayoka A. Tucker, Attorney for the Child, Buffalo.

Appeal from an order of the Family Court, Erie County (Margaret O. Szczur, J.),entered October 21, 2011. The order, among other things, determined that the subjectchild had been neglected by respondent-petitioner Brenda H. and granted the petition ofpetitioner-respondent Linda C.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously modified on thelaw by dismissing the petition of Erie County Department of Social Services andvacating the supervised visitation provision, and as modified the order is affirmedwithout costs and the matter is remitted to Family Court, Erie County, to fashion anappropriate schedule of unsupervised visitation for respondent-petitioner Brenda H.[*2]

Memorandum: Petitioner Erie CountyDepartment of Social Services (DSS) commenced a proceeding pursuant to Family CourtAct article 10 alleging that the subject child had been neglected by respondent-petitionerBrenda H., her paternal grandmother (respondent). At or about the same time,petitioner-respondent Linda C., the maternal grandmother (petitioner), commenced aproceeding pursuant to Family Court Act article 6 seeking modification of a prior ordergranting joint custody of the child to her and respondent. The parties and Family Courtagreed to consolidate the proceedings, inasmuch as they anticipated that the evidence at ahearing would overlap to some extent. In appeal No. 1, respondent appeals from an orderdetermining, following a fact-finding hearing, that she neglected the child. The order alsogranted the petition of petitioner by terminating joint custody and placing the child in thesole custody of petitioner with supervised visitation to respondent. In appeal No. 2,respondent appeals from an order, entered following a dispositional hearing, directingthat respondent complete sex offender and parenting treatment programs, and continuingrespondent's supervised visitation with the child.

We agree with respondent in appeal No. 1 that DSS failed to meet its burden ofestablishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the "child's physical, mental oremotional condition has been impaired or is in imminent danger of becoming impaired"as a consequence of respondent's failure to exercise a minimum degree of care (Nicholson v Scoppetta, 3NY3d 357, 368 [2004]). The court's finding of neglect hinges on the testimony ofDSS's expert psychologist that respondent's dismissive response to the child's allegationsthat she had been sexually abused by her eight-year-old cousin put the child at risk ofharm because such response would cause the child to be reluctant to report futureallegations of abusive contact. The evidence did not establish that the child was in factsexually abused, and we therefore conclude that the court erred in finding that respondentis chargeable with neglect for failing to protect the child from actual harm (see Matter of Robert D., 18AD3d 871, 871-872 [2005]). Moreover, the finding of neglect cannot be based uponthe child's possible reaction to future harm. "[A] finding of neglect will not be based on afailure to prevent theoretical future harm which never occurred" (Matter of P.Children, 272 AD2d 211, 212 [2000], lv denied 95 NY2d 770 [2000]).We therefore modify the order in appeal No. 1 by dismissing the neglect petition. As aconsequence of the dismissal of that petition, there is no jurisdictional basis for thedirectives in the dispositional order in appeal No. 2, and we therefore vacate that order(see Matter of Brandon C., 237 AD2d 821, 822 [1997]; Matter of RashaB., 139 AD2d 962, 963 [1988]).

With respect to the court's directives concerning custody and visitation in the order inappeal No. 1, petitioner and respondent agree that modification of the existing custodyarrangement was warranted inasmuch as their acrimonious relationship has rendered jointcustody unworkable and not in the child's best interests (see Matter of Rhubart vRhubart, 15 AD3d 936, 936 [2005]). Upon our review of the evidence in lightof the relevant factors (see generally Friederwitzer v Friederwitzer, 55 NY2d 89,94 [1982]), we conclude that the award of sole custody to petitioner has a sound andsubstantial basis in the record (see Matter of Chilbert v Soler, 77 AD3d 1405, 1406[2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 701 [2011]). We note that the child has never livedprimarily with respondent, and that respondent acknowledges that her relationship withthe child is strained. We reach a contrary conclusion, however, with respect to the court'sdetermination that respondent's visitation with the child should be supervised (see Matter of Ross v Ross, 86AD3d 615, 617 [2011]; Matter of Oliver v Oliver, 284 AD2d 934, 935[2001]). We therefore further modify the order in appeal No. 1 accordingly, and we remitthe matter to Family Court to fashion an appropriate schedule of unsupervised visitationfor respondent. Present—Smith, J.P., Peradotto, Lindley, Valentino and Whalen,JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.