Ortega v Liberty Holdings, LLC
2013 NY Slip Op 07947 [111 AD3d 904]
November 27, 2013
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 25, 2013


Edgar Ortega, Respondent,
v
Liberty Holdings,LLC, Appellant, et al., Defendants.

—[*1]D'Agostino, Levine, Landesman & Lederman, LLP, New York, N.Y. (Bruce H.Lederman and Christopher M. Tarnok of counsel), for appellant.

Michael A. Cervini, Elmhurst, N.Y. (Robin Mary Heaney of counsel), forrespondent.

In an action to recover damages for personal injuries, the defendant LibertyHoldings, LLC, appeals, as limited by its brief, from so much of an order of the SupremeCourt, Queens County (Markey, J.), entered November 5, 2012, as denied its motion forsummary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against it.

Ordered that the order is affirmed insofar as appealed from, with costs.

On June 10, 2011, the plaintiff allegedly was injured while working at a constructionsite in Lake Success (hereinafter the premises). While the plaintiff was atop a ladder,performing certain work on a wall, part of the wall collapsed onto the ladder. At the timeof the accident, the plaintiff was employed by Marcus Park, LLC (hereinafter MarcusPark).

The plaintiff commenced this action against the defendant Liberty Holdings, LLC(hereinafter Liberty), and others. He alleged, inter alia, that Liberty owned, operated,managed, maintained, and controlled the premises, and was the general contractor for theconstruction project. The plaintiff asserted causes of action to recover damages forcommon-law negligence and violations of Labor Law §§ 200, 240 (1) and241 (1).

Prior to the completion of discovery, Liberty moved for summary judgmentdismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against it, arguing that it neither was theplaintiff's employer nor held legal title to the premises on the date of the plaintiff'saccident. The Supreme Court denied Liberty's motion.

A party moving for summary judgment bears the initial burden of affirmativelyestablishing its entitlement to judgment as a matter of law (see Zuckerman v City ofNew York, 49 NY2d 557, 562 [1980]). Where a party fails to do so, the motion willbe denied, regardless of the sufficiency of the opposing papers (see Winegrad v NewYork Univ. Med. Ctr., 64 NY2d 851, 853 [1985]).

The prima facie showing that a defendant must affirmatively make on a motion for[*2]summary judgment is governed by the allegations ofliability made by the plaintiff in the pleadings (see Miller v Village of E. Hampton, 98 AD3d 1007,1008-1009 [2012]; Braver vVillage of Cedarhurst, 94 AD3d 933 [2012]; Foster v Herbert Slepoy Corp.,76 AD3d 210, 214 [2010]; Wall v Flushing Hosp. Med. Ctr., 78 AD3d 1043, 1045[2010]; Koi Hou Chan vYeung, 66 AD3d 642, 643 [2009]). In the instant action, in addition to allegingthat Liberty owned the premises, the plaintiff alleged, inter alia, that Liberty operated,managed, maintained, and controlled the premises, and was the general contractor for theconstruction project.

"To establish a prima facie case of negligence, a plaintiff must establish the existenceof a duty owed by a defendant to the plaintiff, a breach of that duty, and that such breachwas a proximate cause of injury to the plaintiff. [L]iability for a dangerous condition onproperty is generally predicated upon ownership, occupancy, control or special use of theproperty" (Nappi v IncorporatedVil. of Lynbrook, 19 AD3d 565, 566 [2005] [internal quotation marks andcitation omitted]; see Cerrato vRapistan Demag Corp., 84 AD3d 714, 716 [2011]; Sanchez v 1710 Broadway,Inc., 79 AD3d 845, 846 [2010]; Gover v Mastic Beach Prop. Owners Assn., 57 AD3d 729,730 [2008]). "Where none of these factors [is] present, a party cannot be held liable forinjuries caused by the allegedly defective condition" (Gover v Mastic Beach Prop.Owners Assn., 57 AD3d at 730). Here, Liberty established, prima facie, that it wasnot the record owner of the premises on the date of the plaintiff's accident, by producinga deed to the premises that was delivered and recorded prior to the accident, andtransferred ownership to Marcus Park (see Real Property Law § 291;Hernandez v Chen, 273 AD2d 274 [2000]; Woroniecki v Tzitzikalakis,255 AD2d 509, 509-510 [1998]). However, Liberty's evidentiary submissions did notaddress the issues of Liberty's occupancy, control, and special use of the premises at thetime of the accident. Accordingly, Liberty failed to demonstrate its entitlement tojudgment as a matter of law with respect to the cause of action to recover damages forcommon-law negligence.

Likewise, Liberty failed to demonstrate its prima facie entitlement to judgment as amatter of law with respect to the plaintiff's Labor Law claims. Labor Law § 200 isa codification of the common-law duty of an owner or general contractor to provideworkers with a safe place to work (see Rizzuto v L.A. Wenger Contr. Co., 91NY2d 343, 352 [1998]; Cun-EnLin v Holy Family Monuments, 18 AD3d 800, 801 [2005]). Labor Law§§ 240 and 241 impose certain nondelegable safety duties on generalcontractors, owners, and their agents (see Jock v Fien, 80 NY2d 965, 967-968[1992]; Cannon v Putnam, 76 NY2d 644, 646 [1990]). While Libertyestablished, prima facie, that Marcus Park was the plaintiff's employer and the recordowner of the premises at the time of the plaintiff's accident, Liberty failed to establish,prima facie, that it was not the general contractor for the construction project (see generally Weitz v AnzekConstr. Corp., 65 AD3d 678, 680 [2009]).

As Liberty failed to meet its prima facie burden with regard to any of the causes ofaction contained in the complaint, the Supreme Court properly denied Liberty's motion,without regard to the sufficiency of the papers offered in opposition (see Alvarez vProspect Hosp., 68 NY2d 320 [1986]; Winegrad v New York Univ. Med.Ctr., 64 NY2d at 853; Postv County of Suffolk, 80 AD3d 682, 685 [2011]). Rivera, J.P., Angiolillo, Halland Cohen, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.