| Matter of Brennan |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 08563 [112 AD3d 1248] |
| December 26, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Estate of James J. Brennan, AlsoKnown as James John Brennan, Deceased. Kevin F. Brennan, as Temporary Executor ofJames J. Brennan, Deceased, Appellant. Francis O'Dowd,Respondent. |
—[*1] Douglas M. Jones, Goshen, for respondent.
Spain, J. Appeal from an order of the Surrogate's Court of Greene County (Pulver Jr.,S.), entered November 9, 2012, which, among other things, granted respondent's motionto revoke the preliminary letters testamentary issued to petitioner and appoint respondentas temporary administrator of the estate of James J. Brennan.
James J. Brennan (hereinafter decedent) died testate on January 4, 2009. Petitionerand respondent were among his nephews, and decedent named petitioner as executor ofhis estate. Petitioner sought to probate the will and was issued preliminary letterstestamentary by Surrogate's Court (see SCPA 1412). Objections were filed to thewill by, among others, respondent. Thereafter, respondent moved for various relief,including the revocation of petitioner's preliminary letters (see SCPA 711 [2]). InNovember 2012, the court initially found, based on the papers submitted, that respondenthad met his burden of showing that petitioner had wasted or improperly applied theassets of the estate and that the hostility between the parties threatened to interfere withthe administration of the estate, and revoked petitioner's preliminary letters and issuedtemporary letters of administration to respondent (see SCPA 901 [1]). [*2]Petitioner appeals and argues, among other things, that thecourt erred in failing to conduct a hearing prior to rendering its decision. We stayed theorder of the court pending appeal (2013 NY Slip Op 62038[U] [2013]).
A trial in the probate proceeding was conducted during the pendency of this appeal,following which, by decree dated December 13, 2013, Surrogate's Court dismissed theobjections, admitted decedent's will to probate and issued letters testamentary topetitioner (see SCPA 1414 [1]). This recent decree operates to automaticallyrevoke and extinguish respondent's authority under the temporary letters ofadministration (see SCPA 1413; Matter of Durban, 175 App Div 688,689 [1916], affd 220 NY 589 [1917]; Hastings v Tousey, 123 App Div480, 482-483 [1908]). Thus, petitioner is no longer aggrieved. While respondent remainsconcerned over the alleged dissipation of estate assets, petitioner is a fiduciary in his roleas executor and may, for good cause and at any time, be compelled by the court to file anaccounting (see SCPA 2205, 2206). Under these circumstances, the appeal ismoot, and we do not perceive this case as falling within the exception to the mootnessdoctrine (see Matter of Hearst Corp. v Clyne, 50 NY2d 707, 714-715 [1980];Matter of Horton, 255 AD2d 642, 643 [1998]; Matter of O'Brien, 204AD2d 983, 983-984 [1994]). Accordingly, the appeal should be dismissed.
Stein, J.P., McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the appeal is dismissed,without costs.