Gould v E.E. Austin & Son, Inc.
2014 NY Slip Op 00836 [114 AD3d 1208]
February 7, 2014
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 26, 2014


Ned W. Gould, Appellant, v E.E. Austin & Son, Inc., et al.,Respondents.

—[*1]Maxwell Murphy, LLC, Buffalo (Alan D. Voos of counsel), forplaintiff-appellant.

Lippman O'Connor, Buffalo (Thomas D. Seaman of counsel), fordefendants-respondents.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Cattaraugus County (Michael L. Nenno,A.J.), entered January 7, 2013. The order, inter alia, denied the motion of plaintiff forpartial summary judgment on the issue of liability with respect to the Labor Law §240 (1) claim.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.

Memorandum: Plaintiff commenced this Labor Law and common-law negligenceaction seeking damages for injuries he allegedly sustained while performing masonrywork at the Cattaraugus-Little Valley Central School District High School. DefendantCattaraugus-Little Valley Central School District hired defendant E.E. Austin & Son,Inc. as the general contractor on the project, and that defendant hired Casler Masonry,which employed plaintiff, to perform certain masonry work on the project. According toplaintiff, he was working on a ladder leading up to scaffolding erected in the auditoriumwhen an unsecured tub of mortar that was located in an elevated position on a forklift felland struck him on the head, shoulder, back and leg, thereby injuring him. Supreme Courtproperly denied plaintiff's motion for partial summary judgment on the issue of liabilitywith respect to the Labor Law § 240 (1) claim.

It is well settled that, "[t]o be entitled to a judgment on liability for a violation ofsection 240 (1) of the Labor Law, [a] plaintiff [is] required to prove, as a matter of law,not only a violation of the section, but also that the violation was a proximate cause ofhis [or her] injuries" (Rossi v Main-South Hotel Assoc., 168 AD2d 964, 964[1990]; see Blake vNeighborhood Hous. Servs. of N.Y. City, 1 NY3d 280, 287 [2003], citingDuda v Rouse Constr. Corp., 32 NY2d 405, 410 [1973]; Danielewicz v Klewin Bldg. Co.,Inc., 39 AD3d 1194, 1194-1195 [2007]), and it is further well settled that "anaccident alone does not establish a [section] 240 (1) violation or causation"(Blake, 1 NY3d at 289). We note at the outset that the court properly determinedthat plaintiff established a violation of section 240 (1) (see Williams v Town ofPittstown, 100 AD3d 1250, 1251 [2012]; Minchala v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J., 67 AD3d 978, 978[2009]). We conclude that, by submitting the [*2]affidavit of a coworker with personal knowledge of thefacts (see Vetrano v J.Kokolakis Contr., Inc., 100 AD3d 984, 986 [2012]), and "relying on [his own]deposition testimony, [plaintiff] established, prima facie, that [section] 240 (1) wasviolated and that the violation was a proximate cause of [his] injuries" (Lopez-Dones v 601 W. Assoc.,LLC, 98 AD3d 476, 479 [2012]; see generally Kirbis v LPCiminelli, Inc., 90 AD3d 1581,1582 [2011]).

We further conclude, however, that the court properly denied plaintiff's motionbecause defendants raised a triable issue of fact whether plaintiff's alleged injuries werecaused by the falling mortar tub (see Jones v West 56th St. Assoc., 33 AD3d 551, 551-552[2006]; see generally Zuckerman v City of New York, 49 NY2d 557, 562[1980]). Defendants submitted evidence establishing that plaintiff told his supervisorimmediately after the incident that he was not injured, continued to work for theremainder of the regular workday, worked full days over the following week, and nevercomplained of any alleged injuries associated with the mortar tub falling on him. Indeed,the evidence in the record, including plaintiff's certified medical records and anindependent medical examination (IME) report, which was prepared by a physician whoexamined plaintiff and was submitted by defendants in opposition to the motion,demonstrates that plaintiff sought medical treatment and stopped working only aftersuffering an abdominal injury while lifting buckets of mortar one week after the mortartub struck him. Even then, plaintiff did not mention to any medical professional that amortar tub had struck him, and did not report any injuries attributable thereto, until2½ months after the incident (see Jones, 33 AD3d at 551-552). Moreover,the physician who conducted the IME of plaintiff concluded, based on his examinationof plaintiff, that the injuries of which plaintiff complained were degenerative in nature,and that plaintiff did not sustain any injuries when the mortar tub struck him.Present—Scudder, P.J., Fahey, Peradotto, Carni and Valentino, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.