| Matter of Pavone v DiNapoli |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 00921 [114 AD3d 1012] |
| February 13, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Robert Pavone,Petitioner, v Thomas P. DiNapoli, as State Comptroller,Respondent. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (William E. Storrs of counsel), forrespondent.
Lahtinen, J.P. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court byorder of the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination ofrespondent which denied petitioner's applications for performance of duty and accidentaldisability retirement benefits.
In 2008, petitioner, a police chief, applied for accidental and performance of dutydisability retirement benefits, claiming that he is permanently disabled due to lower backinjuries and acute anxiety stemming from three incidents occurring in 1986, 1994 and1998. After the initial denial of his applications, petitioner requested a hearing andredetermination. At the hearing, petitioner conceded that the 1986 and 1994 incidentswere not accidents within the meaning of the Retirement and Social Security Law.Additionally, the New York State and Local Police and Fire Retirement System concededthat the 1998 incident, whereupon petitioner alleged that he sustained back injuries whenhis chair collapsed under him, was an accident within the meaning of the appropriatestatutory provision. Subsequently, the Hearing Officer recommended that petitioner'sapplications be denied on the basis that he failed to meet his burden of proving that hewas permanently incapacitated from performing his employment duties. Respondentaccepted the Hearing Officer's findings and denied the applications, prompting thecommencement of this CPLR article 78 proceeding.[*2]
We confirm. "As an applicant for accidental andperformance of duty disability retirement benefits, petitioner bore the burden of provingthat he is permanently incapacitated from performing his job duties" (Matter of Cantelmo v New YorkState Comptroller, 105 AD3d 1306, 1307 [2013] [internal quotation marks andcitation omitted]; see Matter ofCamera v DiNapoli, 92 AD3d 1019, 1020 [2012]). Here, the record reflects thatthe Hearing Officer reviewed the reports and testimony of numerous physicians whoexamined petitioner and noted the inconsistency regarding their conclusions as to, amongother things, the degree of petitioner's disability, objective findings as to pain, his abilityto continue working and permanency. Ultimately, the Hearing Officer credited thereports of physicians Mark Kramer and John Mazella, who examined petitioner on behalfof the Retirement System. Notably, in concluding that petitioner could still function as apolice chief, Kramer reported that, despite petitioner's numerous injuries to his lowerback, his medical examination in 2000 failed to disclose significant objective findingsand petitioner's complaints of pain were not substantiated by diagnostic tests.Additionally, based upon his examination of petitioner in 2009 and review of his relevanthistory and records, Mazella diagnosed petitioner with, among other things, a lumbarstrain/sprain without clinical radiculitis and osteoarthritis in his left hip and concludedthat petitioner is not permanently incapacitated from the performance of his duties as aresult of either of these conditions. "Under circumstances such as these, whereconflicting medical evidence is presented, respondent is vested with the authority toresolve such conflict and to credit the opinion of one expert over that of another"(Matter of Camera v DiNapoli, 92 AD3d at 1020 [internal quotation marks andcitation omitted]; see Matter ofBrowne v DiNapoli, 85 AD3d 1535, 1536 [2011]). Thus, regardless of thepresence of proof in the record that could support a contrary conclusion, inasmuch asthere is substantial evidence supporting respondent's determination, we find no basis todisturb it (see Matter of Ortiz vDiNapoli, 98 AD3d 1224, 1225 [2012]; Matter of Browne v DiNapoli,85 AD3d at 1536).
Petitioner's remaining contentions have been examined and found to be unpersuasiveunder the circumstances.
Stein, McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.