| Matter of ISS Action Sec. v New York City Commn. on HumanRights |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 01324 [114 AD3d 943] |
| February 26, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of ISS Action Security,Appellant, v New York City Commission on Human Rights, Respondent, et al.,Respondent. |
—[*1] Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York, N.Y. (Kristin M. Helmers andMichael J. Pastor of counsel), for respondent-respondent.
In a proceeding pursuant to the Administrative Code of the City of New York§ 8-123 to review a determination of the New York City Commission on HumanRights dated June 26, 2011, which adopted the findings and recommendations of anAdministrative Law Judge dated April 12, 2011, made after a hearing, finding that thepetitioner unlawfully discriminated against the complainant on the basis of a disability,and awarded the complainant damages in the total sum of $20,360 and imposed a civilpenalty in the sum of $15,000, the petitioner appeals from an order and judgment (onepaper) of the Supreme Court, Queens County (Agate, J.), entered April 27, 2012, which,inter alia, in effect, confirmed the determination, denied the petition, dismissed theproceeding, and granted the, in effect, cross petition of the New York City Commissionon Human Rights to enforce the determination.
Ordered that the order and judgment is modified, on the facts and in the exercise ofdiscretion, (1) by deleting the provision thereof, in effect, confirming the determination,denying the petition, and dismissing the proceeding, and substituting therefor a provisiongranting the petition to the extent of reducing the amount of the civil penalty imposed inthe determination from the sum of $15,000 to the sum of $5,000, and otherwiseconfirming the determination, denying the petition, and dismissing the proceeding, and(2) by deleting the provision thereof granting the, in effect, cross petition to enforce thedetermination, and substituting therefor a provision granting the, in effect, cross petitionto the extent of enforcing the determination as modified in accordance with theforegoing, and otherwise denying the, in effect, cross petition; as so modified, the orderand judgment is affirmed, with costs to the respondent New York City Commission onHuman Rights.
The determination of the New York City Commission on Human Rights that thepetitioner unlawfully discriminated against the complainant on the basis of a disability bydenying the complainant entry into a certain building for which the petitioner providedsecurity services, and by subjecting the complainant to public ridicule, was supported bysubstantial evidence (see Matter of Brooklyn Hosp. Med. Ctr. v DeLeon, 208AD2d 624 [1994]). It is not the function of the reviewing court to weigh the evidence orassess the credibility of the testimony presented before the administrative [*2]agency (see Matter of Hartley Catering, Inc. v New York State Div. ofHuman Rights, 66 AD3d 1022, 1023 [2009]; Matter of Cold Spring HarborTeachers Assn. v New York State Pub. Empl. Relations Bd., 12 AD3d 442,443-444 [2004]; Matter of Romaine v Cuevas, 305 AD2d 968 [2003]; Matterof De Vito v Kinsella, 234 AD2d 640, 642 [1996]).
Furthermore, the award in the sum of $20,000 to the complainant for mental anguishwas reasonably related to the wrongdoing, was supported by substantial evidence, andwas consistent with similar awards (see Matter of Hartley Catering, Inc. v New YorkState Div. of Human Rights, 66 AD3d at 1023-1024; Matter of School Bd. ofEduc. of Chapel of Redeemer Lutheran Church v New York City Commn. on HumanRights, 188 AD2d 653, 654 [1992]), and the award of actual damages in the sum of$360 to the complainant was supported by the evidence. However the civil penaltyimposed in the sum of $15,000 was excessive (see Administrative Code §8-126 [a]; Matter of 119-121 E. 97th St. Corp. v New York City Commn. on HumanRights, 220 AD2d 79, 88-89 [1996]). Under the circumstances of this case, we deema civil penalty in the sum of $5,000 to be "just and proper" (Administrative Code §8-123 [c]). Skelos, J.P., Chambers, Hall and Miller, JJ., concur.