Matter of Fulton v Chase
2014 NY Slip Op 01489 [115 AD3d 1033]
March 6, 2014
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 30, 2014


In the Matter of Alvin Fulton, Petitioner,
v
P.Chase, as Hearing Officer, et al., Respondents.

—[*1]Alvin Fulton, Dannemora, petitioner pro se.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Kathleen M. Treasure of counsel),for respondents.

Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Warren County) to review two determinations of theSuperintendent of Clinton Correctional Facility which found petitioner guilty of violatingcertain prison disciplinary rules.

Petitioner addressed a letter to a female correction officer using her first name andwas warned that he was not to continue to engage in such conduct. He wrote her anotherletter apologizing for his behavior in the law library. As a result, he was charged in amisbehavior report with harassment and refusing a direct order. Following a tier IIdisciplinary hearing, he was found guilty of the charges, and the determination wasaffirmed on administrative appeal.

A few days after the first misbehavior report was written, petitioner was in the lawlibrary and requested a copy of his legal work. When the correction officer on duty in thelibrary denied his request because petitioner did not have money in his inmate account,petitioner began to argue with the officer. Petitioner disregarded the officer's order tokeep his voice down and became disruptive, causing other inmates in the library to stopworking. As a result, he was charged in a second misbehavior report with creating adisturbance and refusing a direct order. Following a tier II disciplinary hearing, he wasfound guilty of these charges, and this determination was affirmed on administrativeappeal. Petitioner then commenced this CPLR [*2]article78 proceeding challenging both determinations.

First addressing the determination finding petitioner guilty of creating a disturbanceand refusing a direct order, we conclude that the second misbehavior report, togetherwith the testimony provided by correction officials at the second hearing, providesubstantial evidence supporting the determination of guilt (see Matter of Bookman vFischer, 107 AD3d 1260, 1260 [2013]; Matter of Amaker v Bezio, 98 AD3d 1146, 1146 [2012]).Although petitioner asserts that he was improperly denied the testimony of certaininmates and/or their refusal forms, this claim has not been preserved for our review dueto his failure to raise it at the second hearing (see Matter of Madden v Griffin, 109 AD3d 1060, 1061[2013], lv denied 22 NY3d 860 [2014]; Matter of Encarnacion v Bellnier, 89 AD3d 1301, 1301[2011]).

We reach a different conclusion, however, with respect to the determination findingpetitioner guilty of harassment and refusing a direct order in regard to a letter he sent to afemale correction officer. As relevant here, the disciplinary rule relative to harassmentprohibits inmates from "writing or otherwise communicating messages of a personalnature to an employee" (7 NYCRR 270.2 [B] [8] [ii]), and we do not find the language atissue here to be of a personal nature so as to establish a violation (compare Matter of Wells vDubray, 53 AD3d 966, 967 [2008]; Matter of Van Bramer v Selsky, 303AD2d 808, 808-809 [2003]). Moreover, while petitioner was previously admonished forwriting a letter that addressed the officer by her first name, the letter at issue did not doso. Consequently, there is no basis for the determination finding petitioner guilty ofviolating a direct order by sending this letter. In view of the foregoing, we conclude thatthe determination finding petitioner guilty of harassment and refusing a direct order ascharged in the first misbehavior report is not supported by substantial evidence and mustbe annulled (see e.g. Matter ofFarooq v Fischer, 99 AD3d 709, 711 [2012]; Matter of Kempsey v Fischer,98 AD3d 1155, 1156 [2012]). In view of our disposition, we need not addresspetitioner's remaining claims.

Peters, P.J., Stein, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determinationfinding petitioner guilty of harassment and refusing a direct order is annulled, withoutcosts, petition granted to that extent, and the Superintendent of Clinton CorrectionalFacility is directed to expunge all references thereto from petitioner's institutional record.Adjudged that the determination finding petitioner guilty of creating a disturbance andrefusing a direct order is confirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed to that extent.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.