11 King Ctr. Corp. v City of Middletown
2014 NY Slip Op 01706 [115 AD3d 785]
March 19, 2014
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 30, 2014


11 King Center Corp., Appellant,
v
City ofMiddletown et al., Respondents. (Action No. 1.) 11 King Center Corp. et al., Appellants,v City of Middletown et al., Respondents. (Action No. 2.)

—[*1]Tarshis, Catania, Liberth, Mahon & Milligram, PLLC, Newburgh, N.Y. (JosephG. McKay of counsel), for appellants.

Richard Guertin, Corporation Counsel, Middletown, N.Y., for respondents.

In two related actions, inter alia, for a judgment declaring that the plaintiff 11 KingCenter Corp. is the owner of certain real property and that it is entitled to redeem theproperty, and to reform a deed to reflect its ownership of the property, the plaintiffsappeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Orange County (Bartlett, J.), dated March16, 2012, which granted the defendants' motion pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) to dismissthe complaints in both actions.

Ordered that the order is modified, on the law, (1) by deleting the provision thereofgranting those branches of the defendants' motion which were to dismiss the first andthird causes of action in action No. 1, the first and third causes of action in action No. 2,and so much of the second cause of action in action No. 1, and the second cause of actionin action No. 2, as sought declaratory relief, and substituting therefor a provision denyingthose branches of the motion, and (2) by adding provisions thereto deeming thosebranches of the motion to be for a judgment declaring that the plaintiff 11 King CenterCorp. is not the owner of the subject real property, and thereupon granting thosebranches of the motion; as so modified, the order is affirmed, with costs to thedefendants, and the matter is remitted to the Supreme Court, Orange County, for theentry of a judgment, inter alia, declaring that the plaintiff 11 King Center Corp. is not theowner of the subject real property.

The plaintiff 11 King Center Corp. commenced action No. 1 against the City ofMiddletown and certain "John Doe" defendants (hereinafter collectively the citydefendants). The plaintiff 11 King Center Corp., along with its purported mortgagee,David Pfeifer, commenced action No. 2 against the city defendants. The complaints inboth actions sought, among other things, a judgment declaring that 11 King Center Corp.is the owner of real property located at 11-15 King Street in Middletown, despite the factthat another entity, King Center Corp., is identified on [*2]the deed as the owner. The plaintiffs alleged that 11 KingCenter Corp. is not listed as the owner of record of the property because of a merescrivener's error, and that the deed should be reformed accordingly, that 11 King CenterCorp. should be permitted to redeem the property out of foreclosure, and that theconveyance of the property to the City pursuant to a tax sale resulting from the failure ofthe owner of record to pay certain taxes and assessments was void or fraudulent underDebtor and Creditor Law § 276. The City defendants moved pursuant to CPLR3211 (a) to dismiss the complaints, and the Supreme Court granted the motion.

"A motion pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) to dismiss the complaint on the groundthat the action is barred by documentary evidence may be granted only where thedocumentary evidence utterly refutes the plaintiff's factual allegations, therebyconclusively establishing a defense as a matter of law" (Mendelovitz v Cohen, 37AD3d 670, 670 [2007]; see Goshen v Mutual Life Ins. Co. of N.Y., 98NY2d 314, 326 [2002]). Here, the city defendants' documentary evidence conclusivelyestablished, as a matter of law, that the plaintiff corporation was not the owner of recordof the subject property.

The city defendants also conclusively established a defense to the cause of actionseeking to reform the deed based upon an alleged scrivener's error. To reform a writteninstrument based upon mutual mistake or fraud, the proponent of reformation must show,by clear and convincing evidence, "not only that mistake or fraud exists, but exactly whatwas really agreed upon between the parties" (George Backer Mgt. Corp. v AcmeQuilting Co., 46 NY2d 211, 219 [1978]; see Chimart Assoc. v Paul, 66NY2d 570, 574 [1986]; M.S.B.Dev. Co., Inc. v Lopes, 38 AD3d 723, 725 [2007]; Lacoparra v Bellino,296 AD2d 480, 481 [2002]). The documentary evidence submitted by the city defendantsestablished that the plaintiff corporation did not exist at the time the deed allegedlyintended to convey title to it was executed. Therefore, there was no basis to reform thedeed to reflect that 11 King Center Corp. was the owner of the subject property, or forrelated declaratory or injunctive relief.

Accordingly, 11 King Center Corp. is not entitled to a declaration that it is the ownerof the subject property or that it was entitled to redeem the property, or a judgmentreforming the deed. Likewise, 11 King Center Corp. is not entitled to injunctive reliefenjoining the city defendants from selling, transferring, or otherwise hypothecating thesubject property.

Nevertheless, the Supreme Court improperly granted those branches of the citydefendants' motion which were to dismiss the causes of action for declaratory reliefmerely because 11 King Center Corp. is not entitled to the declaration it sought (seeLanza v Wagner, 11 NY2d 317, 334 [1962], appeal dismissed 371 US 74[1962], cert denied 371 US 901 [1962]). Since the record before the SupremeCourt was sufficient to resolve all issues of fact such that the rights of the parties can bedetermined as a matter of law, the Supreme Court should have denied those branches ofthe motion which were to dismiss the causes of action which were for declaratory relief,and instead entered a judgment declaring that 11 King Center Corp. is not the owner ofthe subject property (seeMinovici v Belkin BV, 109 AD3d 520, 524 [2013]; Benson v Deutsche Bank Natl.Trust, Inc., 109 AD3d 495, 498 [2013]).

Since this is, in part, a declaratory judgment action, the matter must be remitted to theSupreme Court, Orange County, for the entry of a judgment, inter alia, declaring that 11King Center Corp. is not the owner of the subject property (see Lanza v Wagner,11 NY2d at 334). Skelos, J.P., Dickerson, Leventhal and Miller, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.