| Matter of Law v Gray |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 02296 [116 AD3d 699] |
| April 2, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Larry Law, Sr.,Respondent, v Shalaine Gray, Appellant. (Proceeding Nos. 1 and 2.) In theMatter of Shalaine Gray, Appellant, v Larry Law, Sr., Respondent. (Proceeding No.3.) |
—[*1] Hector L. Santiago, Richmond Hill, N.Y., for respondent. Toba Beth Stutz, Jamaica, N.Y., attorney for the children.
In related child custody proceedings pursuant to Family Court Act article 6, themother appeals from an order of the Family Court, Queens County (Seiden, Ct. Atty.Ref.), dated December 10, 2012, which, without a hearing, and upon the granting of thefather's application to dismiss her petition for sole custody of the child Lawrence, Jr., ineffect, granted the father's petition for sole custody of that child and, in effect, grantedthe father's separate petition to modify an order of the same court(Richardson-Mendelson, J.), dated January 13, 2009, entered upon the consent of theparties, inter alia, awarding joint legal custody of the child Larry, Jr., to the parties, so asto award the father sole custody of that child.
Ordered that the order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.
An award of custody must be based upon the best interests of the child, and neitherparent has a prima facie right to custody of the child (see Domestic RelationsLaw § 70 [a]; Matter ofPeek v Peek, 79 AD3d 753, 753-754 [2010]). " 'Generally, the determination ofa custody issue can only be resolved after a full and comprehensive hearing, and a carefulanalysis of the applicable factors to be considered in determining what custodyarrangement will further the child's best interests' " (Matter of Zaratzian v Abadir, 105 AD3d 1054, 1054[2013], quoting Matter of Naltyv Kong, 59 AD3d 723, 724 [2009]). "However, 'a hearing will not be necessarywhere the court possesses adequate relevant information to enable it to make an informedand provident determination as to the child's best interest' " (Matter of Zaratzian vAbadir, 105 AD3d at 1054, quoting Matter of Hom v Zullo, 6 AD3d 536, 536 [2004]).
Contrary to the mother's contention, under the circumstances presented here, theFamily Court providently exercised its discretion by, in effect, granting the father'spetition for sole custody of the child Lawrence, Jr., and by, in effect, granting the father'sseparate petition to modify [*2]a prior custody order so asto award him sole custody of the child Larry, Jr. The Family Court possessed adequaterelevant information to enable it, without a hearing, to make an informed and providentdetermination that it was in the best interests of the subject children to award solecustody to the father (see Assiniv Assini, 11 AD3d 417 [2004]; Matter of Porter v Burgey, 266 AD2d552 [1999]).
The mother's remaining contentions are without merit. Eng, P.J., Dillon, Maltese andDuffy, JJ., concur.