| Matter of Cohen (Just Energy Mktg.Corp.—Commissioner of Labor) |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 02984 [117 AD3d 1112] |
| May 1, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of the Claim of Chester J. Cohen,Respondent. Just Energy Marketing Corporation, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. (And Seven Other Related Proceedings.) |
Hiscock & Barclay, Buffalo (Laurence B. Oppenheimer of counsel), forappellant.
Francis J. Smith, Albany, for Chester J. Cohen, respondent.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Dawn A. Foshee ofcounsel), for Commissioner of Labor, respondent.
McCarthy, J. Appeals (1) from decisions of the Unemployment Insurance AppealBoard, filed January 4, 2013, which ruled, among other things, that Just EnergyMarketing Corporation was liable for unemployment insurance contributions based onremuneration paid to claimants and others similarly situated, and (2) from a decision ofsaid Board, filed January 4, 2013, which ruled that claimant Chester J. Cohen wasentitled to receive unemployment insurance benefits.
Just Energy Marketing Corporation, an energy service company that providesresidential and commercial customers with fixed-priced contracts for electricity andnatural gas, is an affiliate of Just Energy New York Corporation (hereinafter collectivelyreferred to as Just Energy). Claimants worked as sales agents for Just Energy. Followingthe termination of their employment, claimants applied for unemployment insurancebenefits. The Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board subsequently ruled that claimantswere employees of Just Energy and [*2]that Just Energywas liable for additional unemployment insurance contributions on remuneration paid toclaimants and other similarly situated agents providing door-to-door solicitation services.Just Energy appeals from those decisions, as well as from a separate decision findingclaimant Chester J. Cohen eligible to receive unemployment insurance benefits.
Initially, whether an employment relationship exists is a factual question for theBoard to resolve and its determination will not be disturbed if supported by substantialevidence (see Matter of Rodriguez [2020 Video Voice Data,Ltd.—Commissioner of Labor], 58 AD3d 929, 929-930 [2009]; Matter of Wannen [Andrew GarrettInc.—Commissioner of Labor], 57 AD3d 1029, 1030 [2008]). The recordestablishes that some indicia of control by Just Energy was mandated by law, such asrequiring the agent to carry a photo identification badge bearing Just Energy's name andlogo, which, alone, is not sufficient to establish an employer-employee relationship.Nevertheless, "it can still be considered as part of the overall determination of controlexercised over" the agents (Matter of Jimenez [C & I Assoc., Inc.—Commissionerof Labor], 74 AD3d 1587, 1589 [2010]). Here, the Board was not convincedthat all the indicia of control that Just Energy exercised over the agents was required byapplicable state law. Specifically, Just Energy advertised for and interviewed the agentsbefore hiring them. Just Energy provided the agent agreement and set the commissionrate, both of which could be changed only by Just Energy. Just Energy provided theagent with the customer contracts. Contracts were required to be submitted on a weeklybasis, approval by Just Energy was required before the contracts became effective, andJust Energy reviewed the contracts and returned them to the agent if any correctionsneeded to be made. Significantly, the agreement precluded the agents from working forany competitor during the term of the contract, as well as for three weeks following thetermination of the agreement. Agents were required to attend two half-day orientationsessions, and received a training manual and code of conduct, which, if not adhered to,could result in termination of the contract. Just Energy would field questions fromagents. Furthermore, any complaints were handled by Just Energy, which couldinvestigate and maintain a file on an agent. Although there is evidence to support acontrary conclusion, we find substantial evidence to support the Board's decision that theextent of the control exercised by Just Energy over the agents evinces anemployer-employee relationship (see Matter of Lamar [Eden Tech., Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor], 109 AD3d 1038, 1039 [2013]).
Next, Just Energy challenges the Board's decision finding Cohen eligible to receiveunemployment insurance benefits, claiming that Cohen created misleading and falsedocuments that he used to solicit contracts. The Board credited Cohen's testimony that hereceived the documents from another agent and that such documents were used by otheragents until such time as Just Energy provided a sales book to the agents. Moreover, theBoard credited Cohen's testimony that he did not use the documents to solicit contracts.Deferring to the Board's credibility determinations, we find that substantial evidencesupports the Board's decision that Cohen did not lose his employment as a result ofdisqualifying misconduct (seeMatter of Saunders [Life Adj. Ctr., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 106 AD3d1317, 1317 [2013]).
Lahtinen, J.P., Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.