Newell v Ellis Hosp.
2014 NY Slip Op 02992 [117 AD3d 1139]
May 1, 2014
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 2, 2014


[*1]
 Danielle Newell, Appellant, v Ellis Hospital et al.,Defendants, and Danilo Cosico et al., Respondents.

Law Office of Gregory J. Teresi, PLLC, Albany (John D. Hoggan Jr. of Law Officeof John Hoggan, PLLC, of counsel), for appellant.

Feldman, Kleidman & Coffey LLP, Fishkill (Marsha Solomon Weiss ofcounsel), for Danilo Cosico, respondent.

O'Connor, O'Connor, Bresee & First, PC, Albany (Michele M. Monserrate ofcounsel), for Hakan Attaroglu, respondent.

McCarthy, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Lynch, J.), enteredFebruary 27, 2013 in Albany County, which, among other things, granted motions bydefendants Danilo Cosico and Hakan Attaroglu to dismiss the complaint againstthem.

Following a surgery performed on June 25, 2009 at defendant Bellevue Women'sCare Center, plaintiff was injured when she fell from the operating table either while orafter being extubated. She commenced this action three years later, on June 25, 2012.Defendant Hakan Attaroglu, the anesthesiologist, moved to dismiss the complaint asuntimely, maintaining that the action sounded in medical malpractice and was barred bythe 21/2-year statute of limitations (see CPLR 214-a, 3211 [a] [5]).Plaintiff cross-moved to amend the complaint to delete any reference to "the standards ofthe medical profession." Defendant Danilo Cosico, the assistant surgeon, [*2]cross-moved to dismiss the complaint as untimely under themedical malpractice statute of limitations. Supreme Court denied plaintiff's cross motionto amend and granted the motion and cross motion of Attaroglu and Cosico (hereinaftercollectively referred to as defendants) dismissing the complaint.[FN*]

Plaintiff appeals.

The sole issue here is whether the complaint sounds in medical malpractice such thatit is subject to a 21/2-year statute of limitations, which would make ituntimely, or whether it alleges personal injury claims based on ordinary negligence thatare subject to a three-year statute of limitations (compare CPLR 214-awith CPLR 214 [5]). "Conduct may be deemed malpractice, rather thannegligence, when it 'constitutes medical treatment or bears a substantial relationship tothe rendition of medical treatment by a licensed physician' " (Scott vUljanov, 74 NY2d 673, 674-675 [1989], quoting Bleiler v Bodnar, 65 NY2d65, 72 [1985]; accord Maki vBassett Healthcare, 85 AD3d 1366, 1367 [2011], appeal dismissed 17NY3d 855 [2011], lv dismissed and denied 18 NY3d 870 [2012]).

The record here does not contain enough factual information to make such adetermination. The complaint contains some language that generally refers tomalpractice, such as that the "action arose from a surgery," that plaintiff was "owed aduty by [d]efendants to use the due care of medical specialists in performing" thesurgery, and that plaintiff fell after she "was extubated by the [a]nesthesiologist" or"while extubated by" him. While some of the medical records also indicate that plaintiff'sfall from the operating table may have been substantially related to the rendition ofmedical treatment, one medical note indicates that plaintiff rolled off the table due to thefailure to remove an obstruction that prevented a stretcher from being placed next to theoperating table. Plaintiff's causes of action would sound in medical malpractice if she felloff the table due to improper pressure or movement in the removal of the breathing tube,or the failure to properly evaluate her safety and restraint needs while she was underanesthesia (see Scott v Uljanov, 74 NY2d at 674-675; Hranek v United Methodist Homesof Wyo. Conference, 27 AD3d 879, 880 [2006]; Lomonaco v United Health Servs.Hosps., Inc., 16 AD3d 958, 960 [2005]; see also Bleiler v Bodnar, 65NY2d at 73).

On the other hand, her causes of action would sound in ordinary negligence if shenever received any safety assessment, if the hospital staff failed to remove an obstructionbetween the operating table and stretcher and allowed her to fall between them, or if shewas simply dropped by the staff members when they were transferring her from theoperating table to the stretcher (see Cochran v Cayuga Med. Ctr. At Ithaca, 90 AD3d 1227,1228 [2011]; Lipe v AlbanyMed. Ctr., 85 AD3d 1442, 1443 [2011]; Reardon v Presbyterian Hosp. inCity of N.Y., 292 AD2d 235, 236-237 [2002]). It is unclear exactly how plaintiffwas injured. She asserts that she was unable to provide more precise information, as shewas under the effects of anesthesia when the accident [*3]occurred and no discovery has taken place. Under thecircumstances, we must deny defendants' motions to dismiss based on statute oflimitations grounds, without prejudice to renewal when further factual information isavailable (see CPLR 3211 [f]).

Supreme Court denied plaintiff's cross motion to amend the complaint based on itsdetermination to dismiss the complaint. Because we are reversing the portion of the orderaddressing defendants' motions, we also reverse the portion addressing plaintiff's crossmotion. Plaintiff must serve the amended complaint within 20 days of the date of thisdecision.

Peters, P.J., Lahtinen and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is modified, onthe law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as (1) granted motions by defendantHakan Attaroglu and Danilo Cosico to dismiss the complaint and (2) denied plaintiff'scross motion to amend the complaint; motions denied as to those defendants, plaintiff'scross motion granted, and plaintiff must serve the amended complaint within 20 days ofthe date of this Court's decision; and, as so modified, affirmed.

Footnotes


Footnote *:Plaintiff had previouslystipulated to discontinue the action against the other individual defendants. In the orderon appeal, Supreme Court dismissed the complaint in its entirety, which would includedismissing as against Bellevue and defendant Ellis Hospital despite those parties nothaving moved for dismissal (see CPLR 3211 [b]; Merritt Hill Vineyards vWindy Hgts. Vineyard, 61 NY2d 106, 110 [1984]). On appeal, plaintiff onlyaddresses the dismissal as to defendants, rendering any arguments concerning Bellevueand Ellis Hospital abandoned.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.