| People v Godbold |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 03624 [117 AD3d 565] |
| May 20, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Respondent, v Ronald Godbold, Appellant. |
Pamela D. Hayes, New York, for appellant.
Cyrus R. Vance, Jr., District Attorney, New York (Nicole Coviello of counsel), forrespondent.
Judgment, Supreme Court, New York County (Laura A. Ward, J., at pretrial motions;Lewis Bart Stone, J., at jury trial and sentencing), rendered July 30, 2009, convictingdefendant of two counts of criminal possession of a controlled substance in the thirddegree and sentencing him, as a second felony drug offender, to concurrent terms of 10years, unanimously affirmed.
The court properly denied defendant's motion to preclude, on the ground of lack ofCPL 710.30 (1) (a) notice, audio recordings containing statements by defendant. Thestatements were outside the scope of the statute, both because they were made as part of acriminal transaction, and also because they were made to persons who were not publicservants (see People v Semidey, 254 AD2d 57 [1st Dept 1998], lv denied92 NY2d 985 [1998]).
After dismissing the indictment on the ground of legal insufficiency of the grand juryevidence, the motion court properly exercised its discretion in reinstating the indictmentupon the People's submission of a portion of the grand jury minutes that had beeninadvertently omitted from their original submission (see People v Contreras, 192AD2d 417 [1st Dept 1993], lv denied 81 NY2d 1071 [1993]). The court hadinherent authority to reinstate the indictment (see People v Frederick, 14 NY3d 913, 916-917 [2010]),and defendant's claim that the indictment was unlawfully amended is without merit,because the text of the indictment remained unchanged. Although defendant asserts thatnothing in the CPLR is relevant to the court's action, he inconsistently asserts that thePeople exceeded the 30-day time limit for reargument motions set forth in CPLR 2221(d). In any event, that time limit would be inapplicable because the People's motion wasessentially for renewal rather than reargument, and the court had discretion to entertain it(see e.g. Framapac Delicatessen v Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., 249 AD2d36 [1998]). Finally, we note that defendant was not prejudiced by any mislabeling ofthe People's motion.
After conducting a suitable inquiry and determining that an absent juror would notappear within two hours after the time that the trial was scheduled to resume, the courtproperly exercised its discretion in substituting an alternate juror (see CPL 270.35[2]; People v Jeanty, 94 NY2d 507, 511 [2000]).
Defendant's legal sufficiency claim is unpreserved and we decline to review it in theinterest of justice. As an alternative holding, we reject it on the merits. We also find thatthe [*2]verdict was not against the weight of the evidence(see People v Danielson, 9NY3d 342, 348-349 [2007]). There is no basis for disturbing the jury's credibilitydeterminations.
The record is unclear as to whether the court received or considered defendant'smidtrial motion to receive in evidence portions of the grand jury testimony of an absentwitness. In any event, there was no basis for receiving this hearsay evidence, and noviolation of defendant's constitutional right to present a defense (see People vRobinson, 89 NY2d 648, 654 [1997]). Since there is no evidence that defendant tookany actions, other than vaguely alluding to possible remedies, when the witness failed torespond to a subpoena, defendant did not establish that the witness was unavailable.Furthermore, despite ample opportunity to do so, defendant never established that theabsent witness's testimony would have been material and not cumulative.
The court properly declined to give an accomplice corroboration charge regardingone of the People's witnesses. There was no evidence that she was involved in any of thefacts or conduct constituting the offenses charged (see People v Sweet, 78 NY2d263 [1991]), and no basis on which to submit to the jury the issue of whether she was anaccomplice. The witness was only defendant's accomplice in the commission of separatecriminal activity that preceded the crimes at issue (see e.g. People v Cruz,291 AD2d 1 [1st Dept 2002], lv denied 97 NY2d 752 [2002]). We perceive nobasis for reducing the sentence.
Defendant's remaining contentions are unpreserved and we decline to review them inthe interest of justice. As an alternative holding, we reject them on the merits.Concur—Gonzalez, P.J., Friedman, Moskowitz, Freedman and Kapnick, JJ.