Matter of McCollum (Fire Is. Union Free Sch.Dist.—Commissioner of Labor)
2014 NY Slip Op 04544 [118 AD3d 1203]
June 19, 2014
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 30, 2014


[*1]
 In the Matter of the Claim of Shoshanna McCollum,Respondent. Fire Island Union Free School District, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent.

Guercio & Guercio, LLP, Farmingdale (Gary L. Steffanetta of counsel), forappellant.

Cynthia Feathers, Glens Falls, for Shoshanna McCollum, respondent.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Mary Hughes of counsel),for Commissioner of Labor, respondent.

Appeals from two decisions of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedApril 23, 2013, which ruled, among other things, that the Fire Island Union Free SchoolDistrict was liable for additional unemployment insurance contributions based onremuneration paid to claimant and others similarly situated.

Claimant performed services for the Fire Island Union Free School District, primarilyas the coordinator of its adult education program. After claimant filed a claim forunemployment insurance benefits, the Department of Labor issued an initialdetermination finding that claimant was an employee and, thus, eligible to receivebenefits. Ultimately, the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board affirmed thatdetermination,[FN1]prompting this appeal by the school[*2]district.

We affirm. Whether there exists an employee-employer relationship is a factualquestion to be resolved by the Board and we will not disturb its determination when it issupported by substantial evidence in the record (see Matter of Joyce [Coface N. Am. Ins. Co.—Commissionerof Labor], 116 AD3d 1132, 1133-1134 [2014]; Matter of Jaeger [Vendor ControlServ., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 106 AD3d 1360, 1360 [2013]).The determination rests not on one single factor, but consideration is given to whethercontrol was exercised over the results or the means used to achieve those results, with thelatter factor deemed more important (see Matter of Joyce [Coface N. Am. Ins.Co.—Commissioner of Labor], 116 AD3d at 1134; Matter of Anwer [ExclusiveFragrance & Cosmetics, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 114 AD3d1114, 1115 [2014]).[FN2]Here, claimant testified that when shewas hired, she received training on coordinating the program, negotiating with teachersand using the school district's finance software. Claimant was given a school districtcomputer for use in coordinating the program, maintained a file cabinet and mailbox atthe school, was given use of the photocopier and postage machine, had access to schooldistrict transportation and stated that she performed most of her work at the school,including some tasks that were required to be performed there. Claimant further testifiedthat instructors were not hired until the school district approved their fees; that thesuperintendent had disapproved classes, directed claimant to hire a specific teacheragainst her wishes and had final approval over cancelling classes; and that claimant wasrequired to seek approval before assigning herself to teach a class and that request hadbeen denied. Notably, both claimant and the superintendent testified that, in addition toher duties supervising the adult education program, claimant also provided office helpand performed general records management duties for the school district. Thus,notwithstanding evidence that might support a different conclusion, we find thatsubstantial evidence supports the Board's decision (see Matter of Joyce [Coface N.Am. Ins. Co.—Commissioner of Labor], 116 AD3d at 1135; Matter of Reich [Posner &Gaier—Commissioner of Labor], 55 AD3d 1077, 1078 [2008]; Matter of Sepulveda [Myles-PatAssoc., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 46 AD3d 1031, 1032[2007]).

Peters, P.J., Stein, Garry, Egan Jr. and Devine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisionsare affirmed, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:The Department ofLabor appears to have issued two case numbers in the instant matter, after which acombined hearing was held and both the Administrative Law Judge and theUnemployment Insurance Appeal Board issued identical decisions in each case (see Matter of Scinta [ExamOneWorld Wide Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 113 AD3d 959, 960 n[2014]).

Footnote 2:We agree with theschool district that the Board erred to the extent that it relied upon the "overall control"test inasmuch as claimant was not acting in the capacity of a "professional" (see Matter of Empire State Towing& Recovery Assn., Inc. [Commissioner of Labor], 15 NY3d 433, 437-438[2010]). Nonetheless, substantial evidence is present to support the Board's decisionunder either test (see Matter ofRichins [Quick Change Artistry, LLC —Commissioner of Labor], 107 AD3d1342, 1343 n 2 [2013]).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.